Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Studies and design

Substation Calculation Report: Chapters and What Each Does

Outline of a substation calculation report: what each chapter calculates, its inputs and who uses the result. Chained numerical example.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

115 kV grid, 1,500 MVA20 MVA, 10 %13.8 kV bus52TC50/51chapters: loads, short circuit, equipment, busbarseach chapter uses the result of the previous oneIn = 20,000 / (√3 × 13.8)836.7 AtransformerX = 20/1,500 + 0.100.1133 pugrid + transformerIcc = 836.7 / 0.11337 383 Ashort-circuitip = 1.6 × √2 × 7,38316 706 Apeakbreaker: 7,383 A < 12 500 AsatisfieddeviceF = 2·10⁻⁷ × 0.866 × ip² / 0.25193 N/mrigid busbarinput datum → result → who uses it nextChainDataCalculationResultNext chapter© tizagrp.com115 kV grid, 1,500 MVA20 MVA, 10 %13.8 kV bus52TC50/51chapters: loads, short circuit, equipment, busbarseach chapter uses the result of the previous oneIn = 20,000 / (√3 × 13.8)836.7 AtransformerX = 20/1,500 + 0.100.1133 pugrid + transformerIcc = 836.7 / 0.11337 383 Ashort-circuitip = 1.6 × √2 × 7,38316 706 Apeakbreaker: 7,383 A < 12 500 AsatisfieddeviceF = 2·10⁻⁷ × 0.866 × ip² / 0.25193 N/mrigid busbarinput datum → result → who uses it nextChainDataCalculationResultNext chapter© tizagrp.com
Substation calculation record: from the transformer to the short-circuit current, breaker selection and force on the busbar. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

The calculation report of a substation gathers, in ordered chapters, the calculations that justify each design decision: loads and transformer, short circuit, equipment, busbars, clearances, grounding, lightning shielding, auxiliary services and protection. Each chapter takes the results of the previous one, so the order and the input data matter as much as the formulas. A reviewer must be able to follow every number back to its source datum.

Short answer

The calculation report of a substation is the document that shows every design decision has a number behind it. It is organized in chapters read in the order they are calculated: data and criteria, loads and transformer, short circuit, equipment, busbars, clearances, grounding, lightning shielding, auxiliary services and protection. The result of each chapter is the input of the next, so a reviewer must be able to follow any figure back to its origin. Below, what each chapter calculates and, with assumed data, how the first ones are chained.

If the scope of the design is not defined yet, see what a substation engineering design includes and the stages of primary design.

What the report is for

It does three things. First, it justifies: whoever reviews the design (the owner, the grid operator or a third party) checks that equipment and clearances withstand the site conditions. Second, it is the basis for purchasing: the equipment data sheets come from its results. Third, it is a record: when the substation is extended, whoever designs the extension starts from the data used for the original.

A useful report is short in prose and long in traceability. Each chapter states its input data, the formula or method, the result, the criterion for acceptance and the chapter that uses it next.

The chapters and what each calculates

ChapterWhat it calculatesInputsUsed by
1. Data and criteriaVoltages, frequency, altitude, pollution, applicable standardsOperator and site dataAll
2. Loads and transformerDemand, transformer rating, rated currentsLoad schedule, projectionShort circuit, equipment
3. Short circuitSymmetrical, peak and thermal current at each busGrid, transformer, impedancesEquipment, busbars, grid, protection
4. EquipmentRated current, breaking capacity and withstand of each deviceChapters 2 and 3Data sheets
5. Busbars and connectionsCurrent capacity and stressesChapters 2 and 3Structures, insulators
6. Clearances and insulationInsulation levels and minimum clearancesVoltage and altitudePhysical layout
7. GroundingGround grid, step and touch voltagesGrid current IG (from the ground fault), soilGrid drawings
8. Shielding and arrestersProtected zone and arrester locationGeometry, lightning levelYard drawings
9. Auxiliary servicesAC and DC loads, battery, chargerEquipment listAuxiliary boards
10. Measurement and protectionCT ratios, secondary burdenChapters 2 and 3Coordination study
AnnexesData sheets, reference drawings, versionsAll of the aboveReviewer

Chapters 3 to 7 concentrate most of the errors, because almost all of them depend on the same number: the short circuit. Each chapter has a calculation guide with the detail:

How the results chain together

The central idea is that no chapter invents a datum that another has already calculated. The transformer rated current (chapter 2) goes into the short circuit (chapter 3). The short-circuit current goes into the equipment check (chapter 4) and into the force on the busbars (chapter 5). The grid current IG, which is obtained from the ground fault of chapter 3, goes into the grid (chapter 7).

If the grid operator changes the short-circuit power of its network, chapter 3 changes and everything hanging from it. That is why each chapter of the report must carry the version of the input data it was calculated with.

Chained numerical example

Example data (assumed): a substation with a 20 MVA, 115/13.8 kV transformer, impedance 10 %. The 115 kV grid has a short-circuit power of 1 500 MVA. Peak factor κ = 1.6 (datum). Phase spacing of the 13.8 kV bus: 0.25 m. Candidate bay breaker: 12 500 A breaking capacity.

The example uses reactances only and an equivalent source without a voltage factor. A real study applies the method and factor that correspond; here the point is to see the chain.

  1. Rated current at 13.8 kV: In = 20 000 / (√3 × 13.8) = 836.7 A. At 115 kV it is 100.4 A.
  2. Grid reactance, on the 20 MVA base: 20 / 1 500 = 0.01333 pu. The transformer’s is 0.10 pu. Total: 0.11333 pu.
  3. Three-phase short circuit at the 13.8 kV bus: Isc = 836.7 / 0.11333 = 7 383 A. That is a power of √3 × 13.8 × 7.383 = 176.5 MVA.
  4. Peak current: ip = 1.6 × √2 × 7 383 = 16 706 A.
  5. Breaker: 7 383 A is lower than 12 500 A, so the breaking capacity complies, with a ratio of 12 500 / 7 383 = 1.69. The making capacity is also compared with ip: 16.7 kA against 2.6 × 12.5 = 32.5 kA at 60 Hz; it complies.
  6. Maximum force per metre between phases of the rigid busbar: F’ = 2·10⁻⁷ × 0.866 × 16 706² / 0.25 = 193 N/m. The rigid busbar guide explains the formula and what is checked with it.

A reviewer can walk this list from top to bottom and stop wherever in doubt. That is the test of a good report: every line names its datum and its result.

What each chapter must carry

  • Input data with their origin: operator letter, manufacturer data sheet, measurement, or an assumption marked as such.
  • Method and formulas with the standard cited by number and edition.
  • Result with units and reasonable significant figures. A current of 7 383 A needs no decimals.
  • Acceptance criterion: what it is compared with and with what margin.
  • Conclusion: one sentence saying what is decided, for example “12.5 kA, 1 250 A breaker”.

Frequent mistakes

  • Short circuit without a version. Equipment is bought for a current that later changes and nobody notes it.
  • Results without source data. The figure appears on a data sheet and cannot be traced.
  • Hidden assumptions. An estimated impedance later taken as measured.
  • Chapters in an order different from the calculation order. They read badly because each uses results from the next.
  • Mixing the report with protection settings. They are updated at different times and must be reviewable separately.

Checklist

  • Each chapter states its input data and where they come from.
  • The short circuit has a version and a date, and dependent chapters cite it.
  • Equipment is compared with the peak and thermal short circuit, not only the symmetrical.
  • Busbars are checked for current and for stress.
  • The grid uses the grid current IG, obtained from the ground fault of the short-circuit chapter.
  • Auxiliary service loads have their own chapter.
  • Each conclusion says what is decided.
  • Assumptions are labelled as assumptions.

References

  • The force between phases uses the three-phase peak formula of rigid busbars; the short-circuit method of your project is set by the study.

Need this study?

The complete calculation report of a substation, with its short circuit, equipment, busbars and ground grid, is part of our engineering design and studies service. We do it for projects in any country. Write to us.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between the calculation report and the drawings?

The drawings say what is built; the report says why. It holds the input data, the formulas, the results and the acceptance criterion of each decision, for example why a breaker is rated 12.5 kA and not 8 kA. Without the report, a reviewer can only accept or reject a drawing without being able to check it.

In what order are the chapters written?

In order of dependency: first the data and the loads, then the short circuit, and then everything that is checked against the short circuit (equipment, busbars, ground grid). If the short circuit changes, those chapters are redone, so it pays to close it early and date the version used for everything else.

Does the report include the relay settings?

No. The settings come from a protection coordination study and go in their own report. The substation report supplies that study with the data it needs: short-circuit currents, current transformer ratios and the list of equipment to protect.

WhatsApp