Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Studies and design

CT Selection: Burden, ALF and Saturation with an Example

How to choose a protection current transformer: ratio, class, cable burden, real ALF and saturation check, solved step by step.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

feeder, 12 kA faultRct 0.30 Ωcable 0.42 Ωrelay 0.004 Ωactual burden 10.6 VA (rated 15 VA)12 kA primary = 100 A secondaryActual ALF 24.9 > 20voltageexcitation currentknee-point voltage: 90 V72.4 V steady state796 V with the DC component72.4 V < 90 V: cumple en régimen permanente796 V > 90 V: fails with the worst-case DC componentChainTCBurdenActual ALFKnee© tizagrp.comfeeder, 12 kA faultRct 0.30 Ωcable 0.42 Ωrelay 0.004 Ωactual burden 10.6 VA (rated 15 VA)12 kA primary = 100 A secondaryActual ALF 24.9 > 20voltageexcitation currentknee-point voltage: 90 V72.4 V steady state796 V with the DC component72.4 V < 90 V: cumple en régimen permanente796 V > 90 V: fails with the worst-case DC componentChainTCBurdenActual ALFKnee© tizagrp.com
Protection CT selection: burden loop and required voltage versus the excitation curve. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

A protection CT is chosen with four data: the ratio, the class, the real connected burden and the fault current it must reproduce without saturating. The burden includes the resistance of the cable loop, that of the relay and the CT's own. With them the real accuracy limit factor is calculated and the voltage the fault demands is compared with the voltage the CT can deliver, also with the DC component.

Short answer

A protection current transformer (CT) is chosen with four data: the ratio, the class, the real burden and the fault current it must reproduce without saturating. The burden is not that of the relay alone: it is the sum of the cable loop resistance, the relay’s and the CT’s own resistance. With that sum the real accuracy limit factor (ALF) is calculated, together with the voltage the CT must deliver during the fault. If that voltage exceeds what the core withstands, the secondary becomes distorted and the protection sees less current than flows. The example in this guide solves it completely.

Ratio and secondary

The rated primary current is chosen above the bay’s maximum load current, with headroom for foreseeable overload, and so that the secondary fault current is not out of proportion. The secondary is chosen as 5 A or 1 A. With long cables 1 A is used, because the cable power falls with the square of the current.

Class: metering or protection

The metering class (for example 0.2 or 0.5) defines accuracy at currents close to rated, and the core saturates on purpose shortly after to protect the instrument. The protection class (5P or 10P in IEC 61869-2) defines the permitted composite error up to a multiple of the rated current, the ALF. A 5P20 core keeps a composite error of 5% up to 20 times the rated current, at its rated burden. Metering and protection cores are kept separate; in MV and HV separate cores are used for metering and protection. The class detail is in 5P and 10P classes.

The real burden

The burden is the load the secondary feeds. It has three parts.

  • Cable loop. The cable goes and returns: the length that counts is twice the distance. R = ρ · 2L / A.
  • Relay. Digital relays consume little, of the order of tenths of a VA, converted to ohms with R = S / I².
  • Contacts and terminals. Small resistances added to the total.

With the total resistance the power is calculated: S = I² · R. For the CT, its internal resistance Rct is added.

Real ALF

The nameplate ALF is guaranteed at the rated burden. With the real burden it changes. If Sn is the rated burden, S the real one and Sin the CT’s internal power (Rct times I²), the real ALF is:

ALF’ = ALF · (Sn + Sin) / (S + Sin)

A burden lower than rated gives a higher real ALF; a higher one, a lower real ALF. ALF’ must exceed the ratio between the maximum fault current and the rated primary current.

Saturation: steady-state criterion and with DC component

The secondary fault current produces a voltage in the core: V = I_fault,sec · (Rct + Rb). The CT can deliver up to its secondary limiting e.m.f. Eal, which for a class P protection core is approximately ALF · I_n · (Rct + Sn / I_n²). If the required voltage is lower, the CT reproduces the wave in steady state.

A real fault starts with a DC component that decays with the X/R ratio of the circuit. In the worst case, the flux that component demands multiplies the required voltage by (1 + X/R). It is a conservative criterion, used as an upper bound, and it does not account for remanence. To see how saturation is detected see CT saturation, and for the DC component, peak current and κ factor.

Worked example

Example data (assumed): 600/5 A CT class 5P20 of 15 VA, internal resistance Rct = 0.30 Ω; 2.5 mm² copper cable 30 m from the relay (60 m loop); resistivity 0.0175 Ω·mm²/m; relay consumption 0.1 VA at 5 A; maximum fault current 12 kA; X/R ratio of 10.

  1. Loop resistance: 0.0175 × 60 / 2.5 = 0.42 Ω.
  2. Relay resistance: 0.1 VA / 5² = 0.004 Ω. Total external resistance: 0.424 Ω.
  3. Real burden: 5² × 0.424 = 10.6 VA, below the rated 15 VA.
  4. Internal power: 0.30 × 5² = 7.5 VA.
  5. Real ALF: 20 × (15 + 7.5) / (10.6 + 7.5) = 20 × 22.5 / 18.1 = 24.9.
  6. Secondary fault current: 12,000 A / (600 / 5) = 100 A, that is 20 times rated. Since 24.9 exceeds 20, the class is enough in steady state.
  7. Voltage required in steady state: 100 × (0.30 + 0.424) = 72.4 V.
  8. Secondary limiting e.m.f. Eal the core can deliver: 20 × 5 × (0.30 + 15 / 5²) = 100 × 0.90 = 90 V. Since 72.4 V is lower than 90 V, it complies in steady state.
  9. With the DC component in the worst case: 72.4 × (1 + 10) = 796 V, far above 90 V. The CT does not comply with that conservative criterion.

Conclusion: this CT is suitable for an inverse-time protection, which operates after the DC component decays, but it is not a safe choice for a high-set instantaneous element. There are four ways out: a larger ratio, a core with a higher secondary limiting e.m.f. Eal, a lower burden (for example a 1 A secondary, which reduces the cable power 25 times) or a core of the defined-transient-response family.

Common mistakes

  • Using the CT’s rated burden instead of the real one.
  • Counting the cable distance only once, without the return.
  • Checking only steady state at a point with high X/R.
  • Sharing a core between metering and protection.
  • Forgetting that the star or delta connection changes the burden each CT sees.

Checklist

  • Primary current above the bay’s maximum load current.
  • Secondary of 5 A or 1 A according to cable length.
  • Separate cores for metering and protection.
  • Cable loop resistance with go and return.
  • Relay consumption in ohms at rated current.
  • Real burden less than or equal to rated.
  • Real ALF calculated and greater than the fault ratio.
  • Required voltage against secondary limiting e.m.f. Eal, in steady state and with DC component.

Need this study?

We choose and verify the current transformers of your substation with the real data of cables, relays and fault levels, and deliver the calculation report and the specification. Engineering work can be done for any country. See the engineering design and studies service and contact us.

References

  • IEC 61869-2:2012, instrument transformers: additional requirements for current transformers (protection classes P, accuracy limit factor).
  • IEEE Std C37.110-2007, guide for the application of current transformers used for protective relaying.

Frequently asked questions

Why does a 1 A secondary reduce the cable burden?

Because the power the cable consumes is I² times R. With the same cable resistance, going from 5 A to 1 A reduces the cable power 25 times. That is why a 1 A secondary is preferred in yards with long cables. The trade-off is that the 1 A CT needs more turns and a higher internal resistance.

Is the nameplate ALF the one the CT will have in service?

No. The nameplate ALF is guaranteed at the rated burden. If the connected burden is lower, the real ALF is higher; if it is higher, the CT saturates sooner. That is why the real ALF is calculated with the circuit's burden.

Is it enough that the CT does not saturate in steady state?

It depends on the protection and on the X/R ratio at the point. With a large DC component, saturation can appear before the first cycle and delay or prevent the instantaneous trip. The check is made with the steady-state criterion and with a criterion that includes the DC component, and if it does not comply the ratio, burden or class is changed.

WhatsApp