A coordination study is justified when there are several protections in series, own generation, a grid operator requirement, trips that shut down more than they should or recent changes to the installation. An eight-criteria score helps decide, with guidance on when a settings review is enough and a worked example of what not doing it costs and how long the study takes to pay back.
Short answer
You hire a coordination study when there are several protections in series, when there is own generation, when a third party requires it (the grid operator or the customer), when trips have already shut down more than they should, or when the installation has changed. If none of those conditions applies, a settings review may be enough. To decide without arguing, an eight-criteria score is proposed here, with an example of what the downtime a study avoids costs. The score is a decision tool, not a standard requirement. If you have already decided to hire, see what to ask for in the quote.
What factory settings do and what they do not
A new relay comes with factory values designed so it works in any installation. That means they do not know your installation’s fault current, the equipment downstream or the equipment upstream. With those values the relay trips, but nobody has checked that it trips in the right order. The most common symptom is the one described in the lack of selectivity: a small fault on one branch shuts down the whole switchboard.
The eight criteria
One point is marked for each question answered «yes»:
| No. | Criterion |
|---|---|
| 1 | There are three or more protections in series between the source and the farthest load |
| 2 | There is own generation (solar, engine generators, cogeneration) |
| 3 | The grid operator or the customer asks for the study |
| 4 | There have been trips that shut down more than necessary |
| 5 | Load, generation or a transformer was added in recent years |
| 6 | The relays already have settings nobody can explain or there is no record of them |
| 7 | There are large motors, power transformers or cables whose short-circuit withstand limits the clearing time |
| 8 | The installation must be able to operate in more than one configuration (ties, parallel, backup) |
How to read the score
- 0 to 1 points: a settings review with a simple table is enough.
- 2 to 3 points: a study limited to the part that changed or fails is advisable.
- 4 points or more: full study, with short circuit, curves and setting sheets.
This split is a practical guide. A single criterion can decide: if the grid operator requires the study (criterion 3), it is done even if the score is low.
When a review is enough
A small, radial installation, with one or two protections in series, without generation and without third-party requirements can be resolved with a review: you check that the settings of each relay or breaker are within the limits of the equipment they protect and that each one sits below the upstream one. If a crossing between curves appears in that review, you move to the study. For the criteria of these checks, see frequent mistakes in coordination studies.
When it cannot be postponed
- Before energizing a plant or a large expansion, because the settings must be loaded and tested at commissioning. See the substation commissioning plan.
- After a trip that shut down more than it should, because the cause repeats.
- When generation is added, because the direction and value of the fault current change.
- When the transformer or the short-circuit level changes, because the values the settings were based on stop being true. For the cases where an existing study has to be redone, see the method guide.
Worked example
Example data (assumed): industrial plant with own solar generation and a 2 MVA transformer. In the last year it had 3 non-selective trips that shut down the whole plant. Each lasted 2 h. Let C be the cost of one hour of downtime; the study quote equals 2.25 C. Criteria 1, 2, 4, 5 and 6 are marked.
- Score: criteria 1, 2, 4, 5 and 6 = 5 points. It corresponds to a full study.
- Downtime hours per year: 3 trips × 2 h = 6 h.
- Cost of the downtime: 6 h × C = 6 C per year.
- Payback: 2.25 C / 6 C = 0.375 years, that is, 0.375 × 12 = 4.5 months.
- Reading: if the study eliminates the non-selective downtime, it pays for itself in under six months. If it eliminates only half, the calculation gives 2.25 C / 3 C = 0.75 years, that is, 9 months.
The ratio of 2.25 C is an assumption of the example. With your project’s real quote and real cost of an hour of downtime, the calculation repeats the same way. What is not counted here, because it is hard to put in figures, is equipment damage from a fault cleared late. To understand what the price of the study depends on, see how much a coordination study costs.
What to ask before deciding
- Who requires the study and with what content? Ask for it in writing.
- Is there enough data? The input data list lets you know the state of your installation.
- What does a stoppage cost in your process? With that figure the decision becomes a calculation like the example.
- Do the relays allow the settings to be loaded? If not, the study may end up unapplied.
What you receive with each option
| Option | What it normally includes |
|---|---|
| Settings review | Check of the present settings against the equipment limits and against each other; list of crossings found |
| Limited study | Short circuit and coordination of the part that changed or fails, with new settings for those relays |
| Full study | Model of the whole installation, maximum and minimum short circuit, curves of each level, setting sheets and study report |
Names vary between companies; what you should ask whoever quotes is to write down what is delivered in each case. And if there is own generation, a study limited to a single part may leave out what changes the most: the current the generation contributes reaches almost every relay.
Frequent mistakes
- Thinking a new relay is already coordinated.
- Waiting for the trip that shuts everything down to decide.
- Buying the study without an updated single-line diagram or the existing settings, and paying for the delay later.
- Hiring only the report and not loading or testing the settings.
- Deciding on price alone, without comparing the scope.
Checklist
- The eight criteria answered and the score noted.
- Third-party requirement (grid operator, customer) confirmed in writing.
- History of non-selective trips with date and duration.
- Cost per hour of stoppage estimated.
- Current single-line diagram and present relay settings available.
- Scope defined: what is studied, which scenarios and what is delivered.
- Plan to load and test the resulting settings.
Related guides
- How much a coordination study costs
- What to ask for in a protection study quote
- What a protection coordination study needs
- Lack of selectivity: several feeders trip
- Reviewing a third-party coordination study
- Protection coordination step by step
References
- The score does not come from a standard.
Need this study?
If your score says yes, we carry out the coordination study, from the data to the setting sheets, as part of our protection coordination work, for projects in any country. We also review studies made by third parties. Write to us.
Frequently asked questions
Doesn't a new relay already come set?
It comes with factory values, which are generic and do not know your installation. They let the device work when connected, but they do not guarantee that it trips before the upstream protection or with the real fault current of your system. Only a study with your data establishes that.
When is a settings review enough, instead of a full study?
When the installation is small, radial and with few protections in series, has no own generation, there is no grid operator requirement and there have been no non-selective trips. A review of the settings against a simple table may be enough; if any of those conditions changes, you move to the study.
Who usually requires the study?
The grid operator when connecting generation; the contract with the customer can also require it. It is worth confirming the requirement before quoting, because it defines the scope and the schedule.