A protection study quote must state six things: the scope with its boundary, the assumptions about the data, the operating scenarios, the deliverables and model files, the review rounds included, and the deadline with payment and change terms. Whatever is not written is argued about later. Comparing only the price without comparing these six points leads to choosing the offer that only looks cheap.
Short answer
The quote for a protection study must state six things in writing: the scope with its boundary, the assumptions about the data, the operating scenarios, the deliverables with the model files, the review rounds included, and the deadline with payment and change terms. Whatever does not appear in the quote is argued about later, when work is already done and there is less room to negotiate. With these six points you can compare two or three offers by what they cover, not only by price.
To see what the price depends on, read what a protection coordination study costs. To see what data to hand over, read what a protection coordination study needs.
1. Scope and boundary
The scope says which part of the system is studied. It must name the buses and devices included (relays, breakers, fuses) and the point where the provider’s responsibility starts. The usual boundary is the connection point with the grid operator: from there toward the grid, an equivalent supplied by the operator is used. Ask the quote to state how many devices are in scope. If you add a bay later, that figure lets the change be calculated without argument.
2. Assumptions about the data
Almost no study starts with all the data. The quote must say which data are assumed and by what criterion, for example the impedance of a transformer with no nameplate, the length of a cable or the contribution of motors. It must also say who supplies the current relay settings and what happens if the real data change the results: whether it is recalculated within the agreed price, up to a margin, or billed as a change of scope. The data each piece of equipment needs is in equipment data for a short-circuit study.
3. Operating scenarios
The settings must work in every reasonable way of operating the plant. The quote must list the scenarios: with one or two sources, with own generation in service or out, with the ring closed or open, with the spare transformer. Each scenario multiplies the checks. If you operate in a way the quote does not list, add it now. The maximum and minimum currents used are explained in short-circuit currents for setting protections.
4. Deliverables and files
Ask for each deliverable to be named: the report with the calculation record, the time-current curves per zone, the settings table per device with its unit (on the secondary and on the primary of the current transformer), the one-line diagram with the protection zones and the study model in the program’s format. A settings table without the curve behind it cannot be audited. A curve without the file cannot be updated. Also ask whether the settings come in a format your maintenance team can use for the change log.
5. Included reviews
The study is a trial-and-error procedure: set, review, set again. The quote must say how many review rounds it includes and the price of an additional one. It must also say whether answering the grid operator’s or an auditor’s comments is included. A cheap offer without reviews usually turns out more expensive than a complete one.
6. Deadline, payments and changes
The deadline must be tied to your deliveries: «twenty working days from receipt of the complete data». A deadline without that condition commits nobody. Payments should be tied to deliverables, for example one on validating the data, another on delivering the settings and another on closing the reviews. And there must be a change rule: what counts as a change of scope and how it is quoted.
Worked example: comparing three quotes
Example data. These are assumed figures for illustration, in monetary units (MU). Each quote is evaluated against the six points. If a point is missing, it is assumed you will pay for it separately at 18 MU per missing point.
- Quote X: 100 MU. Covers 4 of 6 (it lacks the model file and the reviews).
- Quote Y: 130 MU. Covers 6 of 6.
- Quote Z: 90 MU. Covers 2 of 6.
Step 1. Missing points. X: 6 − 4 = 2. Y: 0. Z: 6 − 2 = 4.
Step 2. Cost to complete. X: 2 × 18 = 36 MU. Y: 0. Z: 4 × 18 = 72 MU.
Step 3. Real cost. X: 100 + 36 = 136 MU. Y: 130 MU. Z: 90 + 72 = 162 MU.
Step 4. Price per covered point, before completing. X: 100 / 4 = 25 MU. Y: 130 / 6 = 21.67 MU. Z: 90 / 2 = 45 MU.
The cheapest offer on paper (Z, 90 MU) turns out the most expensive once complete (162 MU), and the middle-priced one (X) ends up 6 MU more expensive than the highest (Y). In practice the cost of what is missing is not known in advance, which is why you should ask for everything in the initial quote.
How to ask for what is missing
Send every provider the same list of the six points and ask them to answer each one. With answers in the same order they can be compared in minutes. If a provider does not answer a point, treat it as not covered.
A short conversation with each provider also helps. Ask how it plans to receive the data, who on its team will do the study and who will review it before delivery, and whether the study relies on a recognized calculation program. An offer that answers these questions clearly usually comes from someone who has done similar work. And keep the answers in writing: if the scope changes, they will be the starting point for agreeing the price adjustment.
Checklist
- The scope names the buses and devices included, and how many.
- The boundary with the grid operator is defined.
- The assumptions about missing data are written down.
- It is defined what happens if the real data change the results.
- The operating scenarios are listed.
- Each deliverable is named, including the model and its format.
- The settings table indicates secondary and primary.
- There is a number of review rounds and a price for an additional one.
- It says whether the grid operator’s comments are answered.
- The deadline depends on delivery of the data and payments are tied to deliverables.
- There is a rule for scope changes.
Related guides
- What a protection coordination study needs
- Equipment data for a short-circuit study
- Protection coordination step by step (IEEE 242)
- Electrical studies with software: what to ask for
- How to choose an electrical testing company
When to call us
Do you need this study? We do it from engineering design and studies, for plants and substations in any country. We give you a quote that states the six points of this guide, with the assumptions written down and the reviews defined. Contact us with your one-line diagram.
References
- IEEE Std 242-2001, IEEE Recommended Practice for Protection and Coordination of Industrial and Commercial Power Systems (Buff Book), clauses 15.6 and 15.7 (study planning and procedure).
Frequently asked questions
Should I receive the study model and not just the report?
It is advisable to ask for it in the quote. The report shows today's results; the model with its data lets the study be repeated when the plant changes without starting from zero. If it is not delivered, the quote should say why and what it would cost to deliver it.
What do I do if the quote does not mention assumptions?
Ask for them in writing before accepting. A study always uses assumptions when data is missing. What matters is that they are declared and that it is agreed what happens if the real data contradict them.
How many review rounds is it reasonable to ask for?
One round is the minimum for you to review and the engineer to adjust. If the plant has several scenarios or the study is submitted to the grid operator, it is prudent to ask for two and to fix the price of an additional one, so it is not negotiated once work is under way.