Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Testing, commissioning and faults

What a Protection Coordination Study Costs

What drives the price of a protection coordination study: settings, scenarios, data and review rounds, with a worked example. We can run this study.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

example plantM50/5112341 and 4 busbars · 2 relay · 3 transformerWhat drives the price (not to scale)Points to set: busbars and relaysOperating scenariosQuality of received dataMeetings and reviews includedDelivery timeeach factor is asked before quotingChainScopeDataCalculation and settingsDelivery and review© tizagrp.comexample plantM50/5112341 and 4 busbars · 2 relay · 3 transformerWhat drives the price (not to scale)Points to set: busbars and relaysOperating scenariosQuality of received dataMeetings and reviews includedDelivery timeeach factor is asked before quotingChainScopeDataCalculation and settingsDelivery and review© tizagrp.com
What drives the price of a coordination study: points to set, scenarios, data, reviews and deadline. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

The price of a protection coordination study depends not on the size of the plant but on how much work there is: how many relays and buses are set, how many operating scenarios are checked, how complete the data arrives, how many review rounds are included and what deadline is asked for. One part of the work is fixed and another grows with every point and every scenario.

Short answer

The price of a protection coordination study depends on the work behind it, not on the size of your plant. Five factors move it: how many relays and buses must be set, how many operating scenarios are checked, how complete the data arrives, how many review rounds are included and what deadline is asked for. One part of the work is fixed (gathering and validating the data) and another grows with every point and every scenario.

If you do not yet know what data the study needs, start with what a protection coordination study needs.

Why the price does not depend on the size of the plant

A coordination study is not measured in installed power. A small plant with many relays, two sources and several ways of operating means more work than a large plant with one transformer and one feeder. What the engineer does is calculate fault currents at each point, plot the curve of every device against the damage curve of every piece of equipment, and adjust until each protection operates in its time and lets the one nearest the fault operate first. Each pair of devices that must be coordinated is one check, and it is repeated in every operating scenario.

The five factors that move the price

1. Points to set. These are the buses where faults are calculated and the devices that must be set: relays, breakers with electronic trip units and fuses. More points mean more curves, more device pairs and more calculation.

2. Operating scenarios. A plant that can run on one or two sources, with its own generator in service or out, with the ring closed or open, has a different set of fault currents in each case. The settings must work in all reasonable cases. Each scenario multiplies the checks. To see where the maximum and minimum currents come from, see short-circuit currents for setting protections.

3. Data quality. When you hand over an updated one-line diagram, transformer nameplates, cable sizes and lengths and the settings the relays have today, the work moves straight ahead. When they are missing, they must be surveyed in the field, requested from the manufacturer or assumed, and every assumption must be written down. The data each piece of equipment needs is in equipment data for a short-circuit study.

4. Meetings and reviews. A serious study includes at least one round in which you review the results and the engineer adjusts. A second or third round is normal when the plant’s operation changes or the grid operator makes comments. If the quote does not say how many rounds it includes, that doubt is paid for later.

5. Deadline. A very short deadline forces more people to work at once and to work on unvalidated data. A comfortable deadline allows the data to be validated before calculating. The deadline also depends on how long you take to deliver the information.

Two more matters weigh in depending on the case: whether the study must be submitted to the grid operator or a third party in a defined format, and whether other studies (for example, arc flash) are also requested from the same data.

Fixed part and variable part

It helps to think of the work in two blocks. The fixed part is what is done once regardless of size: gathering the one-line diagram and data, validating them and building the model. The variable part grows with the number of checks: device pairs to coordinate multiplied by scenarios. Additional reviews are added as a fraction of the variable part, because they force recalculation and redrawing some curves.

This logic does not set a price by itself, but it lets you ask the provider what is in each block and check that the quote grows coherently when you add a scenario or a relay.

Worked example: how much the work grows

Example data. The figures are assumed for illustration and are neither prices nor real hours. Work is measured in work units (WU). Assumed: fixed part of 20 WU; each check is worth 1 WU; each additional review round is worth 25 % of the variable part.

  • Plant A: 11 devices to coordinate, 2 scenarios.
  • Plant B: 14 devices to coordinate, 3 scenarios, with 2 additional review rounds.

Step 1. Pairs to coordinate. In a radial network, each device is coordinated with the one upstream of it, except the first. Plant A: 11 − 1 = 10 pairs. Plant B: 14 − 1 = 13 pairs.

Step 2. Checks. Pairs times scenarios. Plant A: 10 × 2 = 20. Plant B: 13 × 3 = 39.

Step 3. Base work. Fixed part plus variable part. Plant A: 20 + 20 = 40 WU. Plant B: 20 + 39 = 59 WU.

Step 4. Additional reviews for plant B. Each round is worth 0.25 × 39 = 9.75 WU. Two rounds: 2 × 9.75 = 19.5 WU. Total for plant B: 59 + 19.5 = 78.5 WU.

Step 5. Comparison. Plant B without additional rounds requires 59 / 40 = 1.475 times the work of plant A. With the two additional rounds, 78.5 / 40 = 1.96 times, almost double.

Reading: three more devices and one more scenario do not add 27 % (14 against 11) but almost half again as much work, because scenarios multiply the checks. And additional reviews, if they are not defined, can become the factor that weighs most.

What to ask before accepting a quote

  • How many points and devices does it include, and which are left out?
  • How many operating scenarios are studied?
  • What data does the provider assume, and what happens if the real data differ?
  • How many review rounds are included, and what does an additional one cost?
  • What do you receive at the end: report, curves, settings per device, model?
  • Does the study include answering the grid operator’s comments?

For a fuller list of what the quote should state, see what to ask for in a protection study quote, and for choosing whom to hire, how to choose an electrical testing company.

Checklist

  • I have the updated one-line diagram of the plant.
  • I have the nameplates of transformers, motors and generators.
  • I have the sizes and lengths of the main cables.
  • I have the current settings of relays and electronic trip units.
  • I defined the operating scenarios I want covered.
  • The quote says how many points and scenarios it includes.
  • The quote says how many review rounds it includes and the cost of an additional one.
  • The quote lists the assumptions about missing data.
  • I know which deliverables I will receive and in what format.

When to call us

Do you need this study? We do it from engineering design and studies, for plants and substations in any country, starting from your one-line diagram and your data. We first deliver the scope with the assumptions written down, so you can compare with clarity. Contact us and tell us about your plant.

References

  • IEEE Std 242-2001, IEEE Recommended Practice for Protection and Coordination of Industrial and Commercial Power Systems (Buff Book).

Frequently asked questions

Why can two quotes for the same study differ so much?

Because they almost never cover the same thing. One may include five scenarios and two review rounds and the other a single scenario and no rounds. Before comparing prices, compare the scope: points to set, scenarios, deliverables, reviews and deadline.

Can a fixed price be given without seeing the plant data?

Only if the scope is closed with written assumptions. If the one-line diagram, transformer data, cables or current settings are missing, the correct approach is to quote with declared assumptions and to define what happens when the real data contradict them.

Is the study paid for only once?

Not necessarily: a plant study is repeated when the available short-circuit current changes or there are major load changes. What carries over from one study to the next is the model and the collected data, which is why you should receive them in a format you can keep.

WhatsApp