Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Codes and grid connection: US, UK, CA, AU

NERC Bulk Electric System Definition: What Applies to You

How the NERC bulk electric system definition sorts a plant into BES, Category 2 non-BES or neither, with the 20, 60, 75 and 100 kV limits and an example.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

34.5 kV collector=~12 solar inverters5.0 MVA each, 60 MVA=~4 battery inverters5.0 MVA each, 20 MVA34.5 / 115 kVcommon point115 kVto the gridsolar alone: 60 MVAnot above 75 MVAaggregation point: 80 MVAabove 75 MVAPowerBES core and inclusionsexclusions and the exception routesolar alone: 60 MVA at 115 kVadding 20 MVA of battery: 80 MVABES: inverters and collector to 115 kVCore: transmission and resources, 100 kV+I1 transformers, primary and a secondary 100 kV+I2 unit over 20 MVA or plant over 75 MVA, 100 kV+I3 blackstart resources in the restoration planI4 dispersed resources over 75 MVA, 100 kV+ pointI5 reactive devices that are not generatorsat 100 kV+ or via a dedicated transformerI4 catches solar, wind and battery plantsE1 radial systems: only load, or onlygeneration of 75 MVA or lessE2 customer-side generation behind a retailmeter, net to the BES 75 MVA or lessand standby service arrangedE3 local networksE4 reactive devices for one retail customerE1 cannot remove what I2, I3 or I4 capturewrong class: exception process, Appendix 5CInverter-based plantAggregate over 75 MVA,common point 100 kV+?yesBES,Category 1noAggregate of 20 MVA+,common point 60 kV+?yesNon-BES,Category 2noNeitherillustrative valuesClassificationCollectorAggregationCommon pointCategory 2BES© tizagrp.com34.5 kV collector=~12 solar inverters5.0 MVA each, 60 MVA=~4 battery inverters5.0 MVA each, 20 MVA34.5 / 115 kVcommon point115 kVto the gridsolar alone: 60 MVAnot above 75 MVAaggregation point: 80 MVAabove 75 MVAPowerBES core and inclusionsexclusions and the exception routesolar alone: 60 MVA at 115 kVadding 20 MVA of battery: 80 MVABES: inverters and collector to 115 kVCore: transmission and resources, 100 kV+I1 transformers, primary and a secondary 100 kV+I2 unit over 20 MVA or plant over 75 MVA, 100 kV+I3 blackstart resources in the restoration planI4 dispersed resources over 75 MVA, 100 kV+ pointI5 reactive devices that are not generatorsat 100 kV+ or via a dedicated transformerI4 catches solar, wind and battery plantsE1 radial systems: only load, or onlygeneration of 75 MVA or lessE2 customer-side generation behind a retailmeter, net to the BES 75 MVA or lessand standby service arrangedE3 local networksE4 reactive devices for one retail customerE1 cannot remove what I2, I3 or I4 capturewrong class: exception process, Appendix 5CInverter-based plantAggregate over 75 MVA,common point 100 kV+?yesBES,Category 1noAggregate of 20 MVA+,common point 60 kV+?yesNon-BES,Category 2noNeitherillustrative valuesClassificationCollectorAggregationCommon pointCategory 2BES© tizagrp.com
BES or non-BES classification of an inverter-based plant: a one-line diagram of 12 solar inverters of 5.0 MVA and a battery of 4 inverters of 5.0 MVA on a 34.5 kV collector with the 75 MVA aggregation point, a step-up transformer and a 115 kV common point, the bulk electric system core with inclusions I1 to I5 and exclusions E1 to E4, and a decision tree: over 75 MVA at 100 kV or above is BES, 20 MVA or more at 60 kV or above is Category 2, otherwise neither, with solar alone at 60 MVA as Category 2 and 80 MVA with the battery as BES. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

The NERC bulk electric system (BES) definition decides which reliability standards bind a generating plant. Resources connected at 100 kV or above are BES when a unit exceeds 20 MVA, a plant exceeds 75 MVA, or dispersed resources such as solar and storage aggregate above 75 MVA through a collector system. Inverter-based plants below that line but at 20 MVA and 60 kV or above are Category 2 non-BES resources. The classification is made on gross nameplate MVA at the common point of connection.

Short answer: where the NERC bulk electric system definition draws the line

The North American Electric Reliability Corporation (NERC) defines the bulk electric system (BES) in its glossary, and that definition decides which reliability standards bind a generating plant. In summary: transmission elements operated at 100 kV or higher, plus real and reactive power resources connected at 100 kV or higher, are BES unless an exclusion removes them. Inverter-based plants that stay outside the BES can still be registered as Category 2 resources. The wider frame is in the US electrical codes and grid interconnection guide.

The core definition and the inclusions that matter for generation

The definition has a core and a list of inclusions (I) and exclusions (E). There are five inclusions, I1 to I5. For a generating plant, I2 to I5 matter most.

ItemWhat it captures
CoreTransmission elements at 100 kV or higher, and real and reactive power resources connected at 100 kV or higher
I1Transformers with the primary terminal and at least one secondary terminal operated at 100 kV or higher
I2Generating resources, from the generator terminals through the high side of the step-up transformer, connected at 100 kV or above, with a gross individual nameplate above 20 MVA or a gross plant aggregate above 75 MVA
I3Blackstart resources named in the transmission operator’s restoration plan
I4Dispersed power producing resources that aggregate to more than 75 MVA gross nameplate and connect through a system designed mainly to deliver that capacity to a common point at 100 kV or above
I5Static or dynamic reactive devices that are not generators, connected at 100 kV or above or through a dedicated transformer

Inclusion I4 is the one that catches solar, wind and battery plants. NERC’s reference document lists solar, wind, energy storage, flywheels, micro-turbines and fuel cells as examples of dispersed resources. It also states what becomes BES: the individual resources, and the collector system from the point where the resources aggregate to more than 75 MVA up to the common point of connection.

Exclusions and the exception process

Exclusion E1 removes radial systems that carry only load, or only generation of 75 MVA or less that is not captured by the inclusions. Exclusion E2 covers generation on the customer’s side of the retail meter that serves all or part of that customer’s load, when the net capacity delivered to the BES is 75 MVA or less and standby service is arranged as the definition requires. Exclusion E3 covers local networks and E4 covers reactive devices installed for the sole benefit of a retail customer. Exclusion E1 cannot remove generation captured by Inclusions I2, I3 or I4.

An owner who believes a facility was classified wrongly can use the exception process in Appendix 5C of the NERC Rules of Procedure. That process is the route to follow instead of arguing the classification in a study report.

What changes when you are not BES: Category 2

The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) approved revised registry criteria on June 27, 2024. Since then, owners and operators of non-BES inverter-based resources register too. The resources must have or contribute to an aggregate nameplate of 20 MVA or more, through a system designed mainly to deliver that capacity to a common point at 60 kV or above. NERC applies the same principles as Inclusion I4, with lower thresholds, and requires the resource to interface with the grid through inverters. The registration process is covered in NERC registration of inverter-based resources.

So there are three outcomes for an inverter-based plant:

  • BES, Category 1: the plant meets Inclusion I2 or I4.
  • Non-BES, Category 2: inverter-based, 20 MVA or more in aggregate, common point at 60 kV or above, but not BES.
  • Neither: below 20 MVA in aggregate, or below 60 kV at the common point.

Two measurement rules decide borderline cases. Gross nameplate means apparent power in MVA, and for inverters NERC’s guide says to use the inverter apparent power rating. For Category 2, a hybrid plant adds all its inverter-based resources and leaves out synchronous machines, which count only toward the BES thresholds.

Worked example (illustrative)

A developer plans a solar plant made of 12 inverters of 5.0 MVA each, connected at a 115 kV common point through a 34.5 kV collector system. It considers a battery of 4 inverters of 5.0 MVA each on the same collector system.

  1. Solar alone: 12 × 5.0 = 60 MVA. This is not above 75 MVA, so Inclusion I4 does not apply. It is at least 20 MVA and the common point is above 60 kV, so the plant is a Category 2 non-BES resource.
  2. Solar plus battery: 60 + 4 × 5.0 = 80 MVA. This is above 75 MVA at a 115 kV common point, so Inclusion I4 applies and the plant is BES.
  3. Which parts are BES: the individual inverters and the part of the collector system from the point where the aggregate passes 75 MVA to the 115 kV point.

Adding 20 MVA of storage moved the plant from Category 2 to Category 1. That is why the classification belongs in the earliest design review, before nameplates are fixed.

Checklist for the engineer

  • List every inverter and machine with its gross nameplate in MVA and its common point of connection.
  • Confirm the voltage at the common point, not only at the collector.
  • Add the dispersed resources and compare with 75 MVA and 100 kV (BES) and with 20 MVA and 60 kV (Category 2).
  • Check whether planned phases or a future battery change the total.
  • Review whether Exclusion E1 or E2 applies, remembering that E1 cannot remove generation captured by I2, I3 or I4.
  • Record the result in the project file and confirm it with the Regional Entity.
  • Re-run the check when the nameplate or the connection point changes.

The classification and every registration filing remain with the registered owner. In the United States, electrical engineering is stamped by a professional engineer (PE) licensed in the state of the project. Tiza prepares engineering and studies ready for your engineer of record to review and stamp. Tiza does not stamp, sign or certify, and it does not sell any NERC certification.

From classification to a design your engineer can stamp

The BES result drives relay settings, ride-through settings, model data and event recording, so it belongs in the design basis. We prepare the power-system studies and the engineering design that carry those items, ready for your engineer of record to review and stamp. Contact us with the nameplates and the one-line diagram.

Figure: one-line diagram of a collector system with the 75 MVA aggregation point and the 100 kV and 60 kV common points marked.

References

  • NERC, Glossary of Terms Used in NERC Reliability Standards, definition of Bulk Electric System.
  • NERC, Bulk Electric System Definition Reference Document, April 2014.
  • NERC, Rules of Procedure, Appendix 5B (Statement of Compliance Registry Criteria) and Appendix 5C (exception process).
  • ERO Enterprise, Application of the Registration Criteria for Category 2 Generator Owner and Generator Operator Inverter-Based Resources, version 2, April 30, 2026.

Frequently asked questions

What is the NERC bulk electric system definition for a solar plant?

Under Inclusion I4, dispersed power producing resources are BES when they aggregate to more than 75 MVA gross nameplate and connect through a system designed mainly to deliver that capacity to a common point at 100 kV or above. The individual resources and the system from the point where they pass 75 MVA are BES.

Is a 60 MVA solar plant at 115 kV part of the BES?

No, because 60 MVA does not exceed 75 MVA. It is still registered as a Category 2 generator owner and operator, because it is inverter-based, at least 20 MVA and connected at 60 kV or above.

Does adding a battery change the classification?

It can. Storage counts as a dispersed power producing resource, and the nameplates are added at the common point. A plant at 60 MVA that adds a 20 MVA battery reaches 80 MVA and moves from Category 2 to BES.

WhatsApp