Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Codes and grid connection: US, UK, CA, AU

NERC CIP for Solar and BESS Plants: Low and Medium Impact

How NERC CIP-002 rates solar and battery plants, why most are low impact, when a fleet control center turns medium, and the low impact controls to plan.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

to the BESPlant: low impactBES cyber systems(criterion 3.3)Fleet control centermedium at 1,500 MW or moremanufacturerfirewallswitchPPCgatewayEMS=~solarinverters=~BESSinvertersPowerComms12 plants of 150 MW, one control centerplant: 150 MW, below 1,500 MW: lowfleet 1,800 MW: control center medium9 plants: 9 × 150 = 1,350 MW, belowplan the six low impact controlsvendor access: who, how, end, record1,500 MW01.0002,000 MWone plant: 150 MWfleet of 12 plants: 1,800 MWfleet of 12 plants: 1,800 MWfleet of 9 plants: 1,350 MWlow impact policy (CIP-003-9): six areas1 awareness2 physical security3 electronic access4 incident response5 transient cyber assets6 vendor remote accessillustrative valuesCIP ratingControllerGatewayVendor accessControl centerLow impact© tizagrp.comto the BESPlant: low impactBES cyber systems(criterion 3.3)Fleet control centermedium at 1,500 MW or moremanufacturerfirewallswitchPPCgatewayEMS=~solarinverters=~BESSinvertersPowerComms12 plants of 150 MW, one control centerplant: 150 MW, below 1,500 MW: lowfleet 1,800 MW: control center medium9 plants: 9 × 150 = 1,350 MW, belowplan the six low impact controlsvendor access: who, how, end, record1,500 MW01.0002,000 MWone plant: 150 MWfleet of 12 plants: 1,800 MWfleet of 12 plants: 1,800 MWfleet of 9 plants: 1,350 MWlow impact policy (CIP-003-9): six areas1 awareness2 physical security3 electronic access4 incident response5 transient cyber assets6 vendor remote accessillustrative valuesCIP ratingControllerGatewayVendor accessControl centerLow impact© tizagrp.com
Network of a solar and battery plant under NERC CIP: the plant systems, a power plant controller, a protocol gateway, an energy management system, solar inverters and battery inverters behind a firewall and a switch inside a security envelope rated low impact, the fleet control center above it rated medium at 1,500 MW or more, and a yellow dashed manufacturer remote access path through the firewall to the gateway, with the worked example of 12 plants of 150 MW at 1,800 MW against 9 plants at 1,350 MW and the six low impact controls. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

NERC CIP applies to BES cyber systems at facilities in the bulk electric system. Under CIP-002 a solar or battery plant is low impact unless a shared system could affect 1,500 MW or more at one plant within 15 minutes, a planner designates it, or its control center operates 1,500 MW or more in one Interconnection. Low impact plants follow the CIP-003 attachment: awareness, physical, electronic access, incident response, transient devices and vendor remote access.

Short answer: NERC CIP for a solar or battery plant

The NERC Critical Infrastructure Protection (CIP) standards apply to BES cyber systems, which are cyber systems that belong to the bulk electric system (BES). CIP-002 sorts them into high, medium and low impact. A solar or battery plant that is BES is low impact in nearly every case, and low impact has a short list of controls. A plant becomes medium impact in three situations, set out below. The general series is in NERC CIP requirements: what they ask and what to reuse. The first step is the BES test in what applies to your plant, part of the US electrical codes and grid interconnection guide.

What CIP-002 looks at

The rating follows the asset, not the technology. The general method of categorization is in NERC CIP-002: BES cyber system categorization. Here are the parts that decide solar and storage plants, using the text of CIP-002-5.1a.

Medium impact for generation needs one of these:

  • Criterion 2.1: commissioned generation, by group of units at a single plant location, with an aggregate highest rated net real power of the preceding 12 calendar months of 1,500 MW or more in a single Interconnection. Only the shared BES cyber systems that could, within 15 minutes, adversely affect units totalling 1,500 MW or more qualify.
  • Criterion 2.3: a generation facility that its planning coordinator or transmission planner designates, and tells the owner, as necessary to avoid an adverse reliability impact in the planning horizon of more than one year.
  • Criterion 2.11: a control center, or backup control center, used for the functions of the generator operator for an aggregate of 1,500 MW or more in a single Interconnection.

Low impact, criterion 3.3: every other BES cyber system at generation resources. Control centers (3.1) and substations (3.2) are rated in the same way.

The third case matters for fleets. A fleet of small plants is low impact plant by plant, but the control center that operates them can be medium impact once the fleet total reaches the threshold. A generator operator (GOP) control center becomes high impact under criterion 1.4 if it operates a plant that meets criterion 2.1 or 2.3.

What changes for batteries

CIP-002 has no separate battery rating. A battery plant that is BES is generation, so criteria 2.1, 2.3, 2.11 and 3.3 apply as above. What changes is the system list. The BES cyber systems of a storage plant include the power plant controller, the energy management system and the gateways that can command real power within 15 minutes. They are covered in BESS cybersecurity: BMS, PCS and EMS and cybersecurity of the PPC and SCADA of a solar plant. Cell-level battery management that cannot move plant output within 15 minutes needs a case-by-case reading.

Low impact controls to plan

CIP-003 requires cyber security policies. In CIP-003-9, the version in force in the United States, the policy covers, for assets with low impact BES cyber systems, these six areas, plus declaring and responding to CIP Exceptional Circumstances:

  1. Cyber security awareness.
  2. Physical security controls.
  3. Electronic access controls.
  4. Cyber Security Incident response.
  5. Transient cyber assets and removable media malicious code risk mitigation.
  6. Vendor electronic remote access security controls.

The last item matters to inverter and battery plants, because manufacturers often connect for support, as covered in manufacturer remote access to inverters. The plan should name who may connect, how, and how sessions are ended and recorded.

What is coming

The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) approved the next versions in March 2026. CIP-002-7, CIP-002-8, CIP-003-10 and the rest of the virtualization package take effect in the United States on July 1, 2028. CIP-003-11 takes effect on July 1, 2029 and adds remote user authentication, protection of authentication data and detection of malicious communications for low impact assets with external routable connectivity. CIP-015-1, on internal network security monitoring, takes effect on October 1, 2028 for high impact and some medium impact systems. Check each standard’s applicability section, because a date says nothing about scope.

Worked example (illustrative)

A developer operates 12 solar plants of 150 MW each in the same Interconnection from one control center, and each plant has its own power plant controller.

  1. Per plant: 150 MW is below 1,500 MW, so criterion 2.1 does not apply. Unless a planner designates the plant, the BES cyber systems are low impact under criterion 3.3.
  2. Fleet: 12 × 150 = 1,800 MW, which is 1,500 MW or more in one Interconnection. Under criterion 2.11 the control center that performs the generator operator functions is medium impact.
  3. Result: the plants follow low impact controls. The control center carries the medium impact program, including personnel, electronic security perimeter, system security management and the rest of the CIP series.

If the fleet were 9 plants, 9 × 150 = 1,350 MW, the control center would stay below the threshold.

Checklist for the engineer

  • Confirm first whether each plant is BES, with the nameplates and the point of connection.
  • List every cyber system that can change real power output and mark which could do it within 15 minutes.
  • Add the fleet total per Interconnection and compare with 1,500 MW for control centers.
  • Ask the planning coordinator whether it has designated the facility under criterion 2.3.
  • Write the six low impact controls into the plant’s cyber security plan.
  • Document vendor remote access: who, how, and how it is ended.
  • Recheck when plants are added to the fleet or the control center changes.

CIP rating and compliance belong to the registered owner. Tiza prepares engineering and network designs ready for your engineer of record, a professional engineer licensed in the state of the project, to review and stamp. Tiza does not stamp, sign or certify, and does not sell a NERC certification.

From the rating to a secure design

Where a plant is low impact, the work is in the network, the access and the documentation. We prepare the engineering design of the plant network and its remote access, ready for your engineer of record to review and stamp. Contact us with the plant architecture.

Figure: network diagram of a solar and battery plant, with the controller, gateway and vendor access path marked by impact level.

References

  • NERC CIP-002-5.1a, BES Cyber System Categorization, Attachment 1, criteria 2.1, 2.3, 2.11 and 3.3.
  • NERC CIP-003-9, Security Management Controls, Requirement R1 (part 1.2) and Attachment 1.
  • NERC, Standards, Compliance, and Enforcement Bulletin, July 27 to August 2, 2026, table of US effective dates.

Frequently asked questions

Is a solar plant low or medium impact under NERC CIP?

Almost always low impact. Medium impact needs shared systems at a single plant able to affect 1,500 MW or more within 15 minutes, a designation by the planning coordinator or transmission planner, or a generator operator control center running 1,500 MW or more in one Interconnection.

Does a BESS have its own CIP category?

No. CIP-002 rates BES cyber systems by the asset they belong to. A battery plant that is part of the bulk electric system is rated by the same generation criteria as a solar plant.

Does a non-BES Category 2 plant fall under CIP?

CIP-002 categorizes BES cyber systems, and a Category 2 plant is not a BES facility. That points to the plant's own cyber systems sitting outside CIP-002, but the standard does not say so for Category 2. A shared control center can also change the answer, so confirm the classification with your Regional Entity.

WhatsApp