The settings sheet is the document that links the coordination study to the tests on site. It must identify the relay and its version, give the instrument transformer ratios, list each function with its setting in primary and secondary values, indicate the outputs each function trips and fix test tolerances. With it, the person testing knows what to inject and what to expect. It is shown with a conversion and expected-time example.
Short answer
The settings sheet is the document that carries the result of the coordination study to the relay and to whoever tests it. At a minimum it must have: the identification of the relay and its software version, the ratios of the instrument transformers, each function with its setting in primary and secondary values, the outputs each function trips, the expected time at the test points with its tolerance, and who approved it and when. It does not include the device loading procedure. With a sheet like this, the secondary injection test is prepared without calling the study engineer.
What it is for
It has three uses. First, it is the setting order: what is loaded into the relay. Second, it is the test pattern: what is injected and what is expected at each point during commissioning tests. Third, it is the future reference: the relay is compared against it at each maintenance. For the records of what was found and what was left, see the as-found and as-left settings record.
Content of the sheet
Identification
- Substation, bay and relay name as they appear on the single-line diagram.
- Manufacturer, model and order reference.
- Relay software version and the configuration file version the sheet was made with.
- Number and date of the coordination study and of the sheet revision.
Inputs
- Current transformer ratio (for example 300/5 A) and its connection.
- Voltage transformer ratio, if used.
- Which relay input corresponds to which phase.
- Secondary rated current (1 A or 5 A) the relay is configured for; see 1 A or 5 A CTs.
Functions and settings
For each function (for example 50, 51, 50N, 51N), one row with:
- Whether it is enabled or not, and the setting group where it applies.
- Pickup in primary values (network amperes) and secondary values (amperes at the relay).
- Curve and dial, or definite time.
- Additional delay, if any, and blocking conditions.
- Function it depends on (for example, if it is blocked by another one).
Outputs and logic
- Which contact or signal each function trips and to which breaker.
- Which functions start breaker failure or reclosing.
- Which signals are sent to control (alarm, trip) and with what name.
- Plain-language description of any custom logic; logic is drawn with gates, not with program text.
Expected tests
- Injection points: pickup multiple, secondary current, expected time and tolerance.
- Test conditions: what is blocked, which breaker is simulated.
Control
- Who prepared, who reviewed and who approved, with dates.
- Revision history with the reason for each change.
- Number of setting groups and which one stays active.
What the sheet does not carry
The sheet is not the relay’s programming manual. It does not carry the manufacturer’s software steps to write each value, nor passwords or access keys. That goes in the loading procedure, which is kept under access control. Nor does it carry long calculations: those go in the study report; see the protection settings record.
From the study to the test: the link with SAT
In the site test, whoever injects takes the secondary current and the expected time from the sheet. If the sheet carries only primary values, the tester has to divide by the CT ratio on the spot, and a conversion error is mistaken for a wrongly loaded setting. With both values written, the test compares three things: what is injected, what the relay reads and the time it trips.
Worked example
Example data (assumed): phase overcurrent relay on a 34.5 kV breaker. CT of 300/5 A (ratio 60). Pickup of function 51 at 220 A primary, standard inverse curve from the IEC 60255-151:2009 family (t = TMS · 0.14 / ((I/Is)^0.02 − 1)) with TMS 0.17. Instantaneous (50) at 2,000 A primary. Example time tolerance: ±5 %.
- 51 pickup on the secondary: 220 / 60 = 3.67 A.
- Instantaneous on the secondary: 2,000 / 60 = 33.3 A.
- Test point 1, at 2 times pickup: 440 A primary = 440 / 60 = 7.33 A secondary. Expected time: 0.17 × 0.14 / (2^0.02 − 1) = 1.705 s. With ±5 %: between 1.620 s and 1.790 s.
- Test point 2, at 5 times pickup: 1,100 A primary = 18.33 A secondary. Expected time: 0.17 × 0.14 / (5^0.02 − 1) = 0.728 s. With ±5 %: between 0.691 s and 0.764 s.
- Check: 1,100 A is below 2,000 A, so the instantaneous does not intervene at point 2. At 10 times pickup (2,200 A) the instantaneous would trip and the curve test would be worthless; that is why the test point is chosen below it.
With this sheet, the tester injects 7.33 A and expects 1.70 s, then 18.33 A and expects 0.73 s. If the relay trips in 2.3 s at the first point, there is a difference to investigate: a wrongly loaded setting, a wrongly configured CT ratio or a different curve.
Changes during commissioning
On site, a setting sometimes has to change: the grid operator asks for another value, the test shows the CT ratio was not the one on the drawing, or a device changes model. When that happens, the change is not made only in the relay. It is noted on the sheet with a new revision, the date and the reason, the person who did the study is told so they can confirm the coordination still holds, and the tests of the affected function are repeated. If the relay has several setting groups, the sheet carries one column per group and says which one stays active. That way, years later, whoever opens the relay can tell what was changed, who approved it and why.
Frequent mistakes
- Sheet with only primary values and without the CT ratio beside them.
- Sheet without the relay software version: when the file is opened with another version, settings may change name or range.
- Settings written on the sheet that do not match the study because of a last-minute change without review.
- Test points that activate another function, such as the instantaneous, and hide the curve being tested.
- Disabled functions not noted, so the tester looks for them and cannot find them.
Checklist
- Relay identified with model, reference and software version.
- CT and PT ratios written, with their connection.
- Each function with primary and secondary pickup.
- Curve, dial and delays written; disabled functions noted.
- Trip outputs and signals to control described.
- Test points with secondary current, expected time and tolerance.
- Study revision and sheet date noted.
- Prepared, reviewed and approved with signature and date.
- No passwords or manufacturer software steps.
Related guides
- As-found and as-left settings record
- Protection settings record
- FAT, SAT and energization test matrix
- 1 A or 5 A CTs and the rated burden
- SGCB setting groups in IEC 61850
- Substation commissioning plan
References
- IEC 60255-151:2009, Measuring relays and protection equipment, Part 151: Functional requirements for over/under current protection, inverse-curve family and its formula.
Need this study?
We prepare the settings sheets from the coordination study as part of our protection coordination work, for projects in any country. Write to us.
Frequently asked questions
Why must the sheet carry primary and secondary values?
Because the study works in network values (primary) and the relay and the test set work in values at the CT secondary. If the sheet carries only one, the tester has to convert on site, and that is where errors appear. With both written and the CT ratio beside them, the conversion can be checked at a glance.
Does the settings sheet include the procedure to load them into the relay?
No. The sheet says what value each setting takes, not the steps of the manufacturer's software to write them. The loading procedure is a separate document and depends on the relay model and version.
What tolerance is put on the test times?
The relay manufacturer's tolerance for the function and curve used, or the one the contract or the grid operator requires. The example uses ±5 % to illustrate the calculation; it is not a standard value.