Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Studies and design

Setting the 50/51 Phase Overcurrent on an MV Feeder

How to set pickup, curve and instantaneous for the 50/51 phase overcurrent on an MV feeder, with a worked example step by step. We configure it remotely.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

13.2 kV busbar52TC 400/550/51branch fusefault on the branch: the fuse clears,the 50/51 picks up and resets without trippingcurrent (A)time (s)1001 00010 000load 240Is 320min. fault 1,350max. fault 3,20050: 3 84050/51 relay (TMS 0.15)branch fuse0.35 sChainFeederTC50/51 RelayBreaker 52© tizagrp.com13.2 kV busbar52TC 400/550/51branch fusefault on the branch: the fuse clears,the 50/51 picks up and resets without trippingcurrent (A)time (s)1001 00010 000load 240Is 320min. fault 1,350max. fault 3,20050: 3 84050/51 relay (TMS 0.15)branch fuse0.35 sChainFeederTC50/51 RelayBreaker 52© tizagrp.com
Medium-voltage feeder: pickup, curve and instantaneous of the 50/51 against the branch fuse curve and the load and fault current. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

Setting the phase 50/51 of an MV feeder takes three steps: the 51 pickup goes above the maximum load and below the minimum fault; the curve dial is calculated so the relay clears after the downstream device with a coordination margin; and the instantaneous goes beyond the first downstream device, above transformer inrush. Cold load is checked afterwards.

Short answer

The phase overcurrent protection of a medium-voltage feeder has two elements. The 51 is time-delayed: it picks up above the maximum load current, follows an inverse curve and acts as the feeder’s backup. The 50 is instantaneous: it trips with no delay for high faults near the feeder head. Setting them takes three steps: set the 51 pickup between the maximum load and the minimum fault; calculate the curve dial so the relay clears after the downstream device with a coordination time interval; and place the 50 beyond the first downstream device. The settings for your feeder come from your own study.

What data you need

Before calculating, gather the following (the same data described in the step-by-step coordination method):

  • Maximum load of the feeder and its expected growth, in amperes.
  • CT ratio and class. Saturation at maximum fault changes what the relay measures; see the CT for overcurrent protection.
  • Maximum and minimum faults at the feeder head, at the first downstream device and at the end of the feeder. See maximum and minimum short-circuit current.
  • Nearest downstream device (fuse, recloser or another relay) and its clearing time.
  • Connected transformers, to estimate inrush.
  • Relay curve and family. This example uses the IEC 60255-151 normal inverse curve: t = TMS × 0.14 / ((I/Is)^0.02 − 1).

The 51 pickup

The pickup has two limits. At the bottom, it must be above the maximum current the feeder carries in normal operation, with margin for relay and CT tolerance and for switching peaks. At the top, it must sit well below the minimum fault the relay has to clear as backup, normally the phase-to-phase fault at the end of the feeder, with the lowest generation condition.

If both limits cannot fit together (high load and low minimum fault), the feeder is too long or too heavily loaded for this protection, and the scheme has to be reviewed: another sectionalizing point, an intermediate recloser or a different protection.

Relay tolerance and CT tolerance add up. A pickup calculated right at the lower limit can end up below the real load if both errors go the same way. That is why the margin is not trimmed to gain sensitivity without first checking what error the manufacturer declares for each device.

The curve dial

With the pickup fixed, the dial (TMS) is calculated at the critical point: the maximum fault at the first downstream device. There the relay must take that device’s clearing time plus the coordination interval. Then the rest of the range is checked: the curves must not cross at any current between the pickup and the maximum fault. To read and plot curves, see the time-current diagram.

The instantaneous element

The 50 is set under three conditions. First, above the maximum fault current at the first downstream device, so it does not reach past it. Second, above the inrush of the feeder’s transformers (see overcurrent trips at start-up or energization). Third, below the minimum fault at the feeder head, so that it really trips there. If the third condition fails, the element is useless and is disabled.

Worked example

Example data (assumed for this guide): 13.2 kV feeder; maximum load 240 A; CT 400/5; relay with normal inverse curve; maximum three-phase fault at the first downstream fuse 3,200 A, with that fuse clearing in 0.10 s; minimum phase-to-phase fault at the end of the feeder 1,350 A; maximum fault at the feeder head 6,000 A and minimum 5,200 A; connected transformers 3 MVA; chosen coordination interval 0.30 s.

1. 51 pickup. With a margin of 1.3 over maximum load: 1.3 × 240 = 312 A. Take 320 A, which with the 400/5 CT (ratio 80) is 320 / 80 = 4.0 A secondary. Sensitivity against the minimum fault: 1,350 / 320 = 4.2 times the pickup. Both limits fit.

2. Dial. The target time at 3,200 A is 0.10 + 0.30 = 0.40 s. With TMS = 1, the curve gives 0.14 / ((3,200/320)^0.02 − 1) = 0.14 / 0.04713 = 2.97 s. The minimum dial is 0.40 / 2.97 = 0.135. Set 0.15 (the next value).

3. Check. With TMS = 0.15: at 3,200 A the relay takes 0.45 s (actual interval 0.35 s); at 1,350 A, 0.72 s.

4. Instantaneous. Take 1.2 times the maximum fault at the first fuse: 1.2 × 3,200 = 3,840 A. Checks: the rated current of 3 MVA at 13.2 kV is 131 A, and with an inrush of 8 times (an assumption of the example) it reaches 1,050 A, below 3,840 A. And the minimum fault at the feeder head, 5,200 A, exceeds 3,840 A: the 50 does see the fault at the head.

5. Cold load. If on re-energizing the load were double the maximum (480 A, an assumption of the example), the ratio to pickup would be 1.5 and the relay would trip in 2.6 s. If that current can last longer, raise the pickup, block the 51 for a time or use a temporary setting group.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Calculating the dial at a single current and not checking the rest of the range.
  • Setting the 50 without checking that it sees the fault at the head.
  • Forgetting cold load and transformer inrush.
  • Setting with the maximum fault and forgetting the minimum.
  • Leaving the pickup in primary amperes on a relay that expects secondary values.

Checklist

  • Maximum load and growth confirmed with the network operator.
  • Maximum and minimum faults calculated at the head, first device and end.
  • Pickup between the maximum load and the minimum fault.
  • Dial calculated at the maximum fault of the first downstream device.
  • Curves reviewed over the whole range, with no crossings.
  • 50 above the fault at the first device and above inrush.
  • 50 below the minimum fault at the feeder head.
  • Cold load reviewed.
  • Units (primary or secondary) confirmed against the CT ratio.

References

  • IEC 60255-151:2009, Measuring relays and protection equipment, Part 151: Functional requirements for over/under current protection (inverse-time curves).
  • Calculations and data in this guide: our own, with assumed data for the example.

Need this study?

Calculating pickups, dials and instantaneous settings for your feeders, with curves and a settings report, is part of our engineering design and studies service. We do it for projects in any country. Write to us.

Frequently asked questions

How far above the maximum load is the 51 pickup set?

There is no single factor. You choose a margin over maximum load that covers relay and CT tolerance and normal operating peaks, and then check that the minimum fault at the end of the feeder sits several times above the pickup. The example uses 1.3 times the maximum load and verifies it against the minimum fault.

Why is the 50 set beyond the first downstream device?

Because an instantaneous element that sees faults farther than the first fuse or recloser trips before it and drops the whole feeder for a fault on a branch. It is set above the maximum fault current at that first device, and then checked to make sure it still sees the fault at the feeder head.

What is cold load and how does it affect the setting?

It is the high current that appears when a feeder is re-energized after a long outage, because loads start together and transformers energize. It can exceed the pickup for a few seconds. You check that the curve does not trip in that time, or use a temporary setting.

WhatsApp