Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Protection, control and communications

Recloser Selection and Coordination for an Industrial Load

How to pick a single-phase or three-phase recloser for a plant and coordinate it with upstream fuses, relays and reclosers, with minimum time margins.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

Short answer

A three-phase recloser locks out all three phases on a permanent fault, which protects large three-phase motors; a single-phase one suits branches with single-phase load. Minimum coordination margins of 0.25 s between curves, and 0.15 s between fuse clearing and the slow recloser curve, are a common design basis.

Short answer

Two decisions shape the recloser of an industrial plant: its type and the time margins against the protection upstream. A three-phase recloser opens and locks out all three phases on any permanent fault, so large three-phase motors do not keep running on two phases. Margins are usually checked on the time-current curves over the range of common fault currents.

Settings are covered in recloser settings: reclosing, curves and sequence and fuse pairing in recloser-fuse and recloser-relay coordination.

Type

TypeUseEffect on an industrial plant
Single-phaseSingle-phase branches; three-phase circuits with mostly single-phase load, isolating only the faulted phaseRare in plants with three-phase loads
Three-phaseWhen all three phases must lock out on any permanent faultThe normal choice

Selection criteria

  • Insulation level chosen from the system voltage.
  • Rated current above the maximum load current.
  • Interrupting capacity above the maximum short-circuit current at the site.
  • Minimum pickup not above the ampacity of the conductor it protects.

The data sheet should state the time-current curve, rated current and voltage, I²t and interrupting capacity.

Minimum coordination margins

PairMargin
Recloser fast curve to fuse minimum melting curve0.25 s
Fuse maximum clearing curve to recloser slow curve0.15 s
Upstream fuse minimum melting to recloser slow curve0.25 s
Relay and relay, relay and recloser, recloser and relay0.25 s, allowing for relay reset time
Recloser and recloser0.25 s, or different operating sequences if not achievable
From upstream data to an approved setting
  1. Utility: Upstream recloser curve. And short-circuit current
  2. Design: Coordination study. Maximum and minimum faults, overlaid curves
  3. Design: Table of the recloser curve values. Same protections as the single-line
  4. Utility: Margins met? Yes: continue; No: back to step 2.
  5. Design: Settings file and tests

Example (assumptions)

A 3 MVA plant at 13.2 kV with 400 kW three-phase motors.

DataAssumed value
Upstream recloser, slow curve at 4 kA0.60 s
Minimum recloser-to-recloser margin0.25 s
Maximum clearing time of the plant main protection at 4 kA0.35 s
Rated current400 A against a 131 A load
TypeThree-phase, because of the motors

If the real curve leaves less margin, change the curve of the main protection or choose a different operating sequence.

Design checklist

  • Upstream curve and fault current obtained.
  • Type chosen from the load type.
  • Insulation, rating and interrupting capacity verified.
  • Margins met across common fault currents.
  • Protections in the study equal those in the single-line.
  • Surge arresters on the same structure.

We provide the design engineering and the remote configuration of the recloser control, from the coordination study to the settings file and the test plan: contact us with your network data and we will propose a scope. See remote relay configuration.

References

  • IEC 62271-111:2019 / IEEE C37.60-2018, automatic circuit reclosers for alternating current systems up to 38 kV.
  • IEEE C37.42, expulsion-type distribution-class fuses, cutouts and fuse links.

Frequently asked questions

Single-phase or three-phase recloser for an industrial plant?

Three-phase when motors or other three-phase loads must not run on two phases after a permanent fault. Single-phase reclosers fit branches and circuits with mostly single-phase load, where isolating only the faulted phase keeps the rest in service.

What time margin is usual between protections?

A common design basis is 0.25 s between relay and relay, relay and recloser, and recloser and recloser, and 0.25 s between the recloser's fast curve and the fuse minimum melting curve. Between the fuse maximum clearing curve and the recloser's slow curve, 0.15 s. They are minimums; a given case may need more.

Do reclosers need surge arresters?

Yes, on the same structure, upstream and downstream, unless the recloser has internal overvoltage protection, in which case upstream alone may be enough. A protection margin of at least 25 % is a common target.

WhatsApp