Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Protection, control and communications

Recloser or Fused Cutout at a Customer Tap: Design Criteria

How to choose protection at an industrial customer's tap: fused cutout, recloser or breaker, by connected kVA, fault current, tap length and metering.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

Short answer

At a customer tap the choice between a fused cutout, a recloser or a breaker starts from three numbers: the connected kVA, the fault current at the tap and its length. The utility sets the load threshold; the design shows that the device interrupts the fault current and coordinates with the feeder.

Short answer

At the tap of an industrial customer, three numbers decide the protection: the connected kVA, the fault current at the tap and the length of the tap. A fused cutout is the simplest device and fits small loads where the fault current is below its interrupting rating. A recloser takes over when the load is larger, the fault level is high, or automatic reclosing and remote operation add value. The utility sets the load threshold; the design proves the rest.

How a recloser is built and tested is in recloser; coordination with fuses, in recloser-fuse coordination.

Selection criteria

CriterionCutout with fuse linkRecloser
Connected loadSmall, below the utility thresholdAbove the threshold
Fault current at the tapMust not exceed the cutout ratingInterrupting rating chosen above the study value
Operation after a transient faultFuse blows, crew replaces itOpens and recloses automatically
Remote operation and recordsNoneYes, through the control
MeteringDownstream of the deviceDownstream of the device

Two details that are often missed:

  • The fuse link is selected at the standard value nearest to the maximum demand current, then checked for coordination with the upstream device.
  • On a long tap the line needs surge arresters at the tap point, because the exposure is higher.
Protection at a customer tap
  • Is the connected load above the utility threshold?
    • Yes: Recloser, or breaker with relay if the utility accepts it. Meter downstream.
    • No: Does the fault current at the tap exceed the cutout rating?
      • Yes: Recloser, or a cutout with a higher interrupting rating
      • No: Cutout with a fuse link sized to the maximum demand current

What the recloser design must settle

  • Ratings: continuous current and interrupting current above the load and the study fault value, with margin for growth.
  • Settings: curves, reclosing sequence and lockout, coordinated with the feeder device upstream.
  • Control and communications: protocols and auxiliary power for the communications equipment, defined before the equipment is ordered.
  • Test plan: primary and secondary tests with the control set, before energization.

Example with numbers (assumptions)

An industrial plant at 13.2 kV with transformers of 750 kVA and 500 kVA, and a fault current of 14 kA at the tap.

  1. Connected load: 750 + 500 = 1 250 kVA.
  2. Demand current: I = 1 250 ÷ (1.732 × 13.2) = 1 250 ÷ 22.86 = 54.7 A.
  3. Fault level: with 14 kA at the tap, a cutout rated 12 kA is not enough; a recloser, or a cutout with a higher interrupting rating, is needed.
  4. Settings: the phase pickup is set above the demand with margin, and the curve is chosen to open before the feeder device.

The real fault current comes from the utility study.

Design checklist

  • Connected kVA added up, with expected growth.
  • Fault current at the tap checked against the interrupting rating.
  • Device chosen and the utility threshold confirmed.
  • Arresters at the tap if it is long.
  • Meter downstream of the protection device.
  • Settings and communications defined for the control.

We design the protection coordination for the recloser your project requires and configure its control remotely, whatever its make. See remote relay configuration.

References

  • IEC 62271-111:2019 / IEEE C37.60-2018, automatic circuit reclosers for alternating current systems up to 38 kV.
  • IEEE C37.104-2022, Guide for automatic reclosing of circuit breakers for AC distribution and transmission lines.

Frequently asked questions

When does a customer tap need a recloser instead of a fused cutout?

When the connected load is above the threshold the utility sets, when the fault current at the tap exceeds the interrupting rating of the cutout, or when the tap is long enough that automatic reclosing and remote operation are worth having. The utility fixes the threshold; the design checks the other two.

Where should the revenue meter sit relative to the recloser?

Downstream of the recloser, seen from the feeder. A fault in a measurement transformer then opens the recloser and does not affect the other customers on the feeder.

What does the recloser control need to be configured?

Phase and ground curves, the reclosing sequence and lockout, communications and the event record. These are settings, set and tested before energization, and can be done remotely.

WhatsApp