Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Studies and design

Periodic Protection Coordination Review: When to Redo It

Grid, load and generation changes that outdate a coordination study, how to spot them with a quick calculation and which settings to fix first.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

250 MVA grid, then 400 MVA13.8 kV52TC50/51fault at the feeder endthe head-end 50 picks up due to the grid increasefault current at the feeder endbefore, 250 MVA grid: 4,061 Aafter, 400 MVA grid: 4,754 Ahead-end 50: 4,500 A4,500 / 4,061 = 1.11: 11 % margin4,754 / 4,500 = 1.06: the 50 picks upthe 51s keep 0.61 s of marginthe setting is corrected, not the 51ChainGridFault currenthead-end 50Breaker 52© tizagrp.com250 MVA grid, then 400 MVA13.8 kV52TC50/51fault at the feeder endthe head-end 50 picks up due to the grid increasefault current at the feeder endbefore, 250 MVA grid: 4,061 Aafter, 400 MVA grid: 4,754 Ahead-end 50: 4,500 A4,500 / 4,061 = 1.11: 11 % margin4,754 / 4,500 = 1.06: the 50 picks upthe 51s keep 0.61 s of marginthe setting is corrected, not the 51ChainGridFault currenthead-end 50Breaker 52© tizagrp.com
Periodic coordination review: as grid capacity rises, the fault current at the feeder end exceeds the head-end 50 pickup. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

A coordination study describes the system on the day it was made. When the grid, the load or the generation changes, fault currents change and the settings stop being correct. The review recalculates the fault currents, compares them with the pickup of each protection and redoes only what no longer complies. A worked example with assumed data shows how a grid reinforcement from 250 to 400 MVA makes the instantaneous element at the feeder head trip for a fault at the end of the feeder.

Short answer

A coordination study is a snapshot of the system on the day it was made. When the short-circuit capacity of the grid changes, a load or a generator is added, a transformer is replaced or a relay is swapped, the fault currents are no longer those of the study and protection coordination can be lost without anyone noticing. The review works like this: recalculate the fault currents, compare them with the pickup of each protection and redo only what no longer complies.

What changes outdate a study

Each change in this list alters a current or a time that the study took as fixed:

  • The utility grid. A reinforced substation or a new line raises the short-circuit power of the source. The user does not control this change and usually learns of it late. See how it is obtained and what changes between the maximum and minimum current.
  • Transformers. A new transformer with another rating or impedance changes the fault current on the low-voltage side and the inrush current.
  • Own generation. A generator, a solar plant or a cogenerator contributes fault current and can reverse the current direction in a feeder.
  • Loads and motors. A large motor changes the starting current and the maximum load current that the setting must respect.
  • Relays and settings. A replaced relay, a firmware update or a setting changed in the field without a record leaves the system different from what was studied. An as-left and as-found settings record lets you compare what is loaded with what was studied.
  • Operating configuration. A new operating mode, such as closing a tie between buses, changes where the fault current flows.
  • An unexpected operation. If a fault at the periphery of the plant unexpectedly shuts down an important part of the system, the study is redone without discussion.

How the review is done

  1. Request the new data. Short-circuit capacity of the grid with its X/R ratio, data of the new equipment and the settings each relay has loaded today. The guide on study input data lists what to ask for.
  2. Recalculate the fault currents. Maximum and minimum at each bus and at the end of each feeder. The short-circuit calculation procedure explains the method.
  3. Compare each fault with each pickup. For each protection note two things: the maximum fault it should not see (a downstream fault that another protection must clear) and the minimum fault it must see. The pickup must lie between the two.
  4. Recalculate the times. With the new currents, calculate the time of each curve and verify that the coordination interval between protections in series is kept.
  5. Redo only what fails. Change the setting that no longer complies, recheck its neighbours and update the settings sheet and the settings report.

Worked example

Assumptions of the example (all are assumed data for the calculation): a 13.8 kV bus fed by the grid; a feeder with an impedance of 1.2 Ω to its end; the head protection has a 50 (instantaneous) with a pickup of 4,500 A and a 51 with a pickup of 400 A and TMS 0.30; the downstream protection is a 51 with a pickup of 200 A and TMS 0.10. All curves are IEC 60255-151 normal inverse: t = TMS × 0.14 / ((I / Is)^0.02 − 1). The impedances are added as real numbers, a simplification of the example.

The utility reinforces the connection point and its short-circuit power goes from 250 to 400 MVA.

  1. Grid impedance. Before: 13.8² / 250 = 190.44 / 250 = 0.762 Ω. After: 190.44 / 400 = 0.476 Ω.
  2. Fault current at the end of the feeder. The phase voltage is 13,800 / √3 = 7,967 V. Before: 7,967 / (0.762 + 1.2) = 7,967 / 1.962 = 4,061 A. After: 7,967 / (0.476 + 1.2) = 7,967 / 1.676 = 4,754 A.
  3. Comparison with the head 50. Before: 4,500 / 4,061 = 1.11, a margin of 11 %, and the 50 does not pick up for faults at the end of the feeder. After: 4,754 / 4,500 = 1.06, and the 50 picks up. A fault at the end of the feeder trips the head immediately and selectivity with the downstream protections is lost.
  4. The 51s are still fine. With 4,754 A, the downstream 51 has M = 4,754 / 200 = 23.8 and operates in 0.1 × 0.14 / (23.8^0.02 − 1) = 0.214 s. The head one has M = 4,754 / 400 = 11.9 and operates in 0.3 × 0.14 / (11.9^0.02 − 1) = 0.828 s. The difference is 0.614 s, more than a 0.3 s interval.
  5. New setting for the 50. A margin of 1.2 over the new end-of-feeder fault is requested: 1.2 × 4,754 = 5,705 A, rounded to 5,800 A. The fault at the 13.8 kV bus is 7,967 / 0.476 = 16,735 A, well above 5,800 A, so the 50 still protects the bus.

The result: the review showed that the 51 curve needed no change and that raising a single instantaneous protection was enough. Without the review, the problem would have been found in operation, with an unnecessary outage of the whole feeder.

What to record from the review

Leave in writing what changed, the fault currents before and after, which protections were verified, which were modified and who approved the new settings. This traceability lets a third party reproduce the review, and it is the first thing requested when an unexpected operation forces an explanation of what settings were in place. Each review should leave the single-line diagram, the settings sheet and the report with the date and the version of the grid data used, so the next review starts from a clear point and not from an assumption. If someone else did the review, apply the steps of reviewing a coordination study made by third parties.

Checklist

  • I received the current short-circuit capacity and its X/R ratio from the utility.
  • I have the list of plant changes since the last study: equipment, loads, generation and configurations.
  • I recalculated the maximum and minimum currents at each bus and at the end of each feeder.
  • I compared each current with the pickup of each instantaneous and time-delay protection.
  • I verified the coordination interval between protections in series with the new currents.
  • I compared the settings loaded in each relay with those of the study.
  • I updated the settings sheet, the report and the single-line diagram with the date of the review.

References

  • IEC 60255-151:2009, Measuring relays and protection equipment, Functional requirements for over/under current protection: normal inverse curve.

Need this study?

We review and redo coordination studies as part of our engineering design and studies service: we recalculate the fault currents with the current data of your grid, verify the loaded settings and deliver only the changes needed. The work is engineering done remotely, for projects in any country. To load the new settings into the relays, see remote relay configuration. Contact us.

Frequently asked questions

How often must a coordination study be redone?

It depends on changes, not on the calendar. A new study is needed when the available short-circuit current changes or there are major load changes. It is also good practice to schedule a review in the plant procedure even when nothing has changed, to confirm that the settings loaded in the relays are still those of the study.

Does a review mean redoing the whole study?

No. The maximum and minimum fault currents are recalculated, compared with the pickup of each protection, and only the curves and settings that no longer comply are redone. If the change is large, such as a new transformer or a generating plant, a complete study is advisable.

Which grid change most often goes unnoticed?

An increase in the short-circuit capacity of the source, because the utility decides it and the user does not see it. It raises the fault currents throughout the system and can make an upstream instantaneous element pick up for faults it did not see before.

WhatsApp