PRC-027-1 is a NERC reliability standard for North America that requires transmission owners, generator owners and distribution providers to have a process for setting protection so that it operates in the intended sequence during faults, to use that process for every new setting and to check periodically that coordination still holds. Its method, primary and backup pairs with a time margin, is a useful reference for any study.
Short answer
PRC-027-1 is a reliability standard from NERC, the body for the North American power grid. Its title is Coordination of Protection Systems for Performance During Faults. It requires transmission owners, generator owners and distribution providers to have a process for setting the protection of the elements of NERC’s bulk electric system (BES) so that it operates in the intended sequence during a fault, to use that process for every new or revised setting and to check periodically that coordination is still adequate. It is not a Colombian standard: it serves as a method reference, and as a requirement if a contract mentions it.
What the standard asks for
The standard is organized in three requirements.
- R1. Process. Each applicable entity establishes a process for developing new and revised settings for BES elements, so that protection operates in the intended sequence during faults. The process includes a review and update of the short-circuit model data, a review of the developed settings and, when the settings apply to elements that join facilities of different entities, providing the proposed settings to the other owner, responding to theirs by identifying coordination issues, and verifying that they are addressed before implementation.
- R2. Periodic review. For each BES element with the Attachment A functions (distance 21 under certain conditions, instantaneous overcurrent 50, inverse-time overcurrent 51 and directional 67 if not in a communication-aided scheme), the entity chooses among three options: (1) a coordination study at an interval of no more than six calendar years; (2) comparing present fault current values with a baseline and running the study when the comparison shows a deviation of 15 percent or more (three-phase or phase-to-ground) at a bus the element is connected to, all within an interval of no more than six calendar years; or (3) a combination of both.
- R3. Application. Each new or revised setting is developed with the R1 process.
The standard does not give a calculation procedure; it requires that the process exists, is used and is checked. The content of the process is defined by each company, which is why it helps to start from an orderly method such as protection coordination step by step. A company that already has a documented setting procedure can compare it point by point with R1: where it states how new settings are reviewed, who approves them and where the data is kept.
What a coordination study is in this context
It is the analysis that checks, for the possible faults, that protections operate in the intended order: first the primary and, if it fails, the backup, with a time margin between them and without tripping healthy elements. The time margin is explained in coordination time intervals (CTI). The study uses the fault currents of maximum and minimum short circuits and the actual relay settings.
How the scope is built: primary and backup pairs
For each protected element (a line, a transformer, a busbar) the following are listed:
- The primary protections: those that clear the fault on that element.
- The backup protections: those that would see it and act if the primary or its breaker fails, both local and remote.
Each primary is compared with each backup, for each fault type and at several points of the element. The number of comparisons grows quickly; that is why an orderly list of pairs is useful before calculating.
Example: a ring of four substations
Example data (assumed): four substations A, B, C and D joined in a ring by four lines (AB, BC, CD and DA), with a relay at each end of each line. For each line, the primary protection is the relay at each end and the remote backup is the relay of the adjoining line at that same end; once the end breaker opens, the backup no longer sees the fault. Phase and ground faults are checked at three points of the line (near each end and in the middle). Minimum margin between backup and primary: 250 ms. Primary clearing: 80 ms.
1. Pairs per line. For line AB: A-AB with D-DA and B-AB with C-BC. That is 2 pairs per line.
2. Pairs in the ring. 4 lines × 2 pairs = 8.
3. Fault types. Phase and ground: 8 × 2 = 16 comparisons.
4. Fault points. 16 × 3 = 48 time comparisons in the study.
5. One pair with its margin. Primary: 80 ms. Remote backup (zone 2) at 400 ms. Margin: 400 − 80 = 320 ms. Since 320 ms exceeds the 250 ms of the criterion, the pair complies.
6. One pair that does not comply. Another backup set at 300 ms: 300 − 80 = 220 ms, less than 250 ms. It has to be raised to at least 80 + 250 = 330 ms; in the example it is taken to 350 ms. Afterwards it is checked that this delay does not exceed the system’s maximum clearing time.
Reading. With 48 comparisons, the study needs a spreadsheet or a program that runs through the pairs, and a record of which ones were reviewed. It is the work that must later be repeated no later than the periodic review period of the standard, or sooner if fault-current tracking indicates it (R2).
How it applies to other countries
Even if the obligation is North American, the scheme it proposes is good method practice:
- A written setting process that lets another person repeat the result.
- Periodic review, because the grid changes: new lines, generation, topology changes.
- A record of decisions: what was set, with what data and what was accepted as a limitation.
In Colombia, what is required in studies from whoever connects generation is explained in CNO EACP guidelines and studies required by the CNO to connect generation.
What is worth documenting
With or without a NERC obligation, a defensible study records: the input data and its date, the version of the short-circuit model, the list of pairs reviewed with their margin, the decisions taken when a pair did not comply and the pairs accepted as an exception, with their reason. If tracking fault current against a baseline is chosen, that baseline and the date it was taken are also kept. With that record, whoever repeats the study years later can understand what changed and why.
Common mistakes
- Studying only the maximum fault and forgetting the minimum and the emergency topologies.
- Leaving out the elements that join facilities of two companies.
- Taking the settings from the old sheet without checking the actual relay settings.
- Not recording which pairs were reviewed.
- Doing the study once and not going back to it when the grid changes.
- Treating the periodic review as paperwork instead of rerunning the comparisons with current data.
Checklist
- Written and current setting process.
- Protected elements and their primary protections listed.
- Local and remote backups identified for each element.
- Primary-backup pairs compared with phase and ground faults.
- Minimum time margin defined and verified on each pair.
- Actual relay settings used in the study.
- Date and scope of the next periodic review.
- Decisions and exceptions recorded.
Related guides
- Protection coordination step by step (IEEE 242)
- What a protection coordination study needs
- Main and backup protection
- Time and current selectivity
- Coordinating the plant relay with the grid operator
References
- NERC, standard PRC-027-1, Coordination of Protection Systems for Performance During Faults, requirements R1, R2 and R3.
- Calculations and example data: our own.
Need this study?
The coordination study of your protection, with the list of primary and backup pairs, the time margins and the record for the periodic review, is part of our engineering design and studies service. We do it for projects in any country. Write to us.
Frequently asked questions
Does PRC-027 apply to a project outside North America?
Not as an obligation: it is a NERC standard for the North American power grid. It serves as a method reference. If the project is in another country, that country's standard or grid code governs, and the contract may ask for PRC-027 as an additional criterion.
What does a company have to do to comply?
Have a written process for setting protection, use it every time a setting is created or revised, and check periodically that coordination remains valid, with a coordination study at an interval of no more than six calendar years, by comparing fault current with a baseline and running the study if the deviation reaches 15 % (R2), or by combining both options.
What is a primary and backup pair?
It is the pair formed by the protection that must clear a fault and the protection that backs it up if the first one does not act. The study checks, for each fault, that the backup takes longer than the primary, with a sufficient time margin, and that it does not trip first.