A coordination study is only as good as its data. What to request is grouped in five blocks: single-line diagram and equipment, short circuit, existing settings, instrument transformers and operating conditions. It explains how to request it, how to validate it, what to do with what is missing, and shows with numbers how much a result changes when one datum is not confirmed.
Short answer
The coordination study is calculated with five blocks of data: the single-line diagram with its equipment, the short circuit of the source, the settings the relays already have, the current and voltage transformers, and the conditions in which the installation operates. What does not arrive is requested in writing, validated against a second source and, if it is still missing, recorded as an assumption with its estimated effect. A doubtful datum changes the result more than it seems: in the example, a transformer impedance of 5 % against 6 % moves the fault current by 16.7 %. To know what the finished study contains, see what a protection coordination study needs.
The five blocks of data
1. Single-line diagram and equipment
- Current, dated single-line diagram showing buses, breakers, transformers, cables, generation and major loads.
- Nameplate data of each transformer: rating, voltages, impedance, connection and tap positions.
- Cables: size, material, length and installation type.
- Breakers and fuses: make, model and interrupting rating.
- Large motors: rating, starting current and starting time.
2. Short circuit
- Short-circuit power or current of the source, maximum and minimum, with the X/R ratio. This datum is supplied by the grid operator; see how short circuit is calculated in a plant.
- Contribution of own generation, if any, with the manufacturer’s datasheet.
- The installation’s short-circuit study, if one already exists, with its date.
3. Existing settings
- Settings of each relay (pickup, curve, dial, instantaneous) in the device’s file, not only on paper.
- Settings of the grid operator’s upstream relay, when you have to coordinate with it.
- Curves of fuses and low-voltage breakers.
- Date of the last change to each setting.
4. Instrument transformers
- Ratio of each CT, accuracy class, connected burden and connection type.
- Ratio of each PT.
- To see what to ask for and why, see CT selection: burden and saturation.
5. Operating conditions
- Normal and emergency configurations: which ties are opened, which transformers end up in parallel.
- Maximum and minimum demand and generation.
- Changes planned in the short term.
How to request the data
A clear request saves weeks. A format that works is a table with these columns: datum, block, accepted format, owner, deadline, status and priority. Priority is marked critical if the calculation cannot be done without the datum, important if it can be assumed at some risk and minor if it only improves detail. Critical data is requested first and in writing.
It pays to ask for files, not only photos: each relay’s settings file, the short-circuit program model if one exists, the single-line diagram in an editable format. To see how information is downloaded from a relay, see connecting to a protection relay.
Validate before calculating
A received datum is not a confirmed datum. Before using it:
- Compare it with another source: the transformer nameplate against the test report, the single-line diagram against the site visit.
- Check the units: kVA against MVA, ohms against per unit, primary current against secondary.
- Check the date: a ten-year-old single-line diagram probably does not reflect the present plant.
- Record the source and date of each datum in the study report.
What to do when a datum is missing
You can move ahead with an assumption if you do three things: declare it in the report, calculate with a range (for example, nameplate impedance and the tolerance limit) and leave the setting dependent on confirmation. It is not hidden. And it is requested again with a date, because an assumption without an owner turns into a datum through oversight.
Worked example
Example data (assumed): a 1,000 kVA, 13.2/0.48 kV transformer whose impedance is not on the nameplate and could be 5 % or 6 %. The 13.2 kV source is 250 MVA. The request list has 38 items and 26 have arrived.
- Rated current at 480 V: 1,000 / (1.732 · 0.48) = 1,202.8 A.
- Fault on the secondary, infinite source, 5 % impedance: 1,202.8 / 0.05 = 24,056 A.
- With 6 % impedance: 1,202.8 / 0.06 = 20,047 A.
- Difference: (24,056 − 20,047) / 24,056 = 16.7 %. An instantaneous set with the higher current may not see the minimum fault, and one set with the lower may cross with the downstream device.
- Short-circuit current of the 13.2 kV source: 250 / (1.732 · 13.2) = 10.93 kA.
- Request progress: 26 / 38 = 68.4 %. 12 items are missing; if 5 are critical, the study cannot close until they arrive or an assumption is agreed for each.
The practical conclusion: the impedance datum, though it looks minor, defines the range of the setting. It is requested from the manufacturer or taken from the test report.
Who usually supplies each datum
| Block | Who normally has it |
|---|---|
| Single-line diagram and equipment | Plant maintenance or engineering; if it does not exist, it is surveyed on site |
| Source short circuit | The grid operator, on a written request |
| Existing settings | Whoever programmed the relays or the device itself, by downloading the file |
| CTs and PTs | The nameplates in the field and the equipment test reports |
| Operating conditions | Plant operations |
It pays to name one owner per block and a date in the request. A general email to «the plant» tends to go unanswered; one addressed to a person with a date does not. If a datum can only be obtained on site, the visit is scheduled from the start, because it needs permits and sometimes an outage window.
Frequent mistakes
- Receiving the single-line diagram undated and calculating on an installation that has already changed.
- Accepting handwritten relay settings without comparing them with the device file.
- Confusing the grid operator’s short-circuit current with that of the plant bus: they are different points.
- Not asking for the CT ratios and finding in the field that they do not match the drawing.
- Leaving assumptions without an owner or a confirmation date.
Checklist
- Current single-line diagram, dated and signed by whoever delivers it.
- Complete transformer nameplate data, with impedance.
- Cables, breakers and fuses identified with their rating.
- Maximum and minimum short circuit of the source, with X/R, in writing.
- Settings files of the existing relays.
- Settings of the grid operator’s relay, if you have to coordinate with it.
- Ratio, class and burden of each CT; ratio of each PT.
- Operating configurations defined.
- Each datum with source and date; each assumption with an owner and a confirmation date.
Related guides
- What a protection coordination study needs
- Equipment data for a short-circuit study
- How short circuit is calculated in a plant
- CT selection: burden and saturation
- Protection settings record
- Frequent mistakes in a coordination study
References
- The list of data blocks follows the general practice of coordination studies; it does not reproduce a standard.
Need this study?
We prepare the data request, validate what is received and carry out the full coordination study as part of our protection coordination work, for projects in any country. Write to us.
Frequently asked questions
Which data is essential to start a coordination study?
The current single-line diagram with the protection devices, the short-circuit power or current of the source (with its X/R ratio), the nameplate data of transformers and cables, the present relay settings and the ratios and classes of the current transformers. Without any of them you can move ahead with assumptions, but each one is recorded and confirmed later.
What if the grid operator does not provide the short circuit?
It can be estimated with the available data, but it is declared as an assumption, a range (maximum and minimum) is calculated and the settings are conditional on the official value confirming it. Requesting it in writing from the start avoids redoing the study at the end.
How do you know a received datum is reliable?
By comparing it with another source: the nameplate against the test sheet, the single-line diagram against a site visit, the relay setting against the file downloaded from the device. A datum that exists only in an undated, unsigned document is treated as an assumption.