Distance reaches are calculated in ohms on the line impedance: zone 1 covers about 80% so it does not overreach the far end, zone 2 covers the whole line with a margin and does not go past half of the shortest next line, and zone 3 backs up the neighbouring lines. They are then converted to secondary ohms with the CT and VT ratios and checked so that normal load does not enter any zone.
Short answer
Distance protection (21) measures the impedance seen from the relay and compares it with the reaches of its zones. The reaches are calculated in ohms from the line impedance: zone 1 covers about 80% of the line and trips without delay; zone 2 covers the whole line with a margin and trips after a short delay; zone 3 backs up the neighbouring lines and trips after a longer delay. The primary values are converted to secondary with the ratio between the CT and the VT, and at the end it is checked that maximum load does not enter any zone. To understand how the function works, see distance protection (21).
The data needed
- Positive-sequence impedance of the line, in primary ohms, with its angle. Its calculation starts from impedance of lines, cables and reactors.
- Impedance of the neighbouring lines: the shortest, to limit zone 2, and the longest, to size zone 3.
- CT and VT ratios, and transformer data if there are transformers within the reach.
- Maximum load current and minimum operating voltage.
- Intermediate infeeds on the line (generation or a tap): they change the impedance the relay sees and are studied with the short-circuit study.
- Coordination times of the neighbouring protections.
Criteria for each zone
The percentages below are the example’s criteria; each grid company sets its own and the study confirms them.
Zone 1. About 80% of the line impedance, with no intentional delay. The margin covers data and measurement errors.
Zone 2. The whole line plus a margin: in the example, 120% of the line impedance. It must not exceed the line impedance plus about half of the shortest next line, so it does not reach the part of the next line that its zone 1 does not cover, where it would compete with the zone 2 of that line. Its delay is coordinated with the main protection of the neighbouring line.
Zone 3. It backs up the neighbouring lines: the line impedance plus 120% of the longest neighbouring line, with a longer delay. It is the zone most exposed to load and to power swings (see distance trip due to load or swing).
Example: 60 km, 115 kV line
Example data (assumed): line impedance 0.45 Ω/km at an angle of 75°; length 60 km; shortest neighbouring line 40 km and longest 55 km; CT 600/5; VT 115 kV / 115 V; maximum load 500 A at a power factor of 0.95 (angle 18°); minimum operating voltage 0.9 per unit. Example delays: zone 2 at 0.4 s and zone 3 at 0.9 s.
1. Line impedance. 0.45 × 60 = 27 Ω primary.
2. Zone 1. 0.80 × 27 = 21.6 Ω.
3. Zone 2. 1.20 × 27 = 32.4 Ω. Limit check: the line plus half of the shortest neighbour, 27 + 0.5 × (0.45 × 40) = 27 + 9 = 36 Ω. Since 32.4 Ω does not exceed 36 Ω, it is accepted.
4. Zone 3. The longest neighbour measures 0.45 × 55 = 24.75 Ω. Reach: 27 + 1.2 × 24.75 = 56.7 Ω.
5. Conversion to secondary. The CT ratio is 600 / 5 = 120 and the VT ratio is 115,000 / 115 = 1,000. The factor is 120 / 1,000 = 0.12. Zone 1: 21.6 × 0.12 = 2.592 Ω. Zone 2: 32.4 × 0.12 = 3.888 Ω. Zone 3: 56.7 × 0.12 = 6.804 Ω.
6. Minimum load impedance. Phase voltage at 0.9 per unit: 0.9 × 115,000 / √3 = 59,756 V. With 500 A: 59,756 / 500 = 119.5 Ω.
7. Effect of the angle. A circular characteristic that passes through the origin and is oriented at 75° reaches, in the direction of the load (18°), only the cosine of the difference: cos(75° − 18°) = 0.545. The zone 3 reach in that direction is 56.7 × 0.545 = 30.9 Ω.
8. Check. 119.5 / 30.9 = 3.9 times: the load is far from zone 3. Even ignoring the angle, 56.7 Ω is 47% of the load impedance.
9. Two test faults. A bolted fault at 70% of the line has an impedance of 0.70 × 27 = 18.9 Ω: it is inside zone 1 and trips without delay. Another at 90% of the line, 24.3 Ω, is outside zone 1 and inside zone 2: it trips at 0.4 s, unless a teleprotection scheme speeds up the trip.
These two test faults are also the first checks to run with the test set on the finished settings: each one must land in the zone and with the delay that the calculation predicted.
The stretch zone 1 does not cover
With zone 1 at 80%, a fault in the final 20% of the line is seen by the opposite end in its zone 1 and by this end only in its zone 2. Without communication between the two, the line clears in two times: fast at one end and with a delay at the other. To avoid that, teleprotection schemes are used, such as permissive underreaching transfer trip, which allow tripping with no delay at both ends when both see the fault.
What changes with intermediate infeed and fault resistance
If there is a source between the relay and the fault (a tap with generation, for example), the current the relay sees is lower than the total and the apparent impedance is higher: the zone reaches less than calculated. And a fault with an arc or contact resistance adds resistance to the loop and can push the fault out of the zone. Both effects are studied with the short-circuit calculation and are compensated, depending on the case, with extended zones, wider characteristic shapes or teleprotection schemes.
Common mistakes
- Calculating the reach with the line impedance without its angle.
- Forgetting the conversion to secondary ohms, or applying it with the CT ratio of another bay.
- Letting zone 2 go past the zone 1 of the shortest next line without coordinating the delay.
- Not checking the load at minimum voltage.
- Copying the percentages of another project without checking the line data.
- Not recording the criterion used for each zone, so the next engineer cannot repeat the calculation.
Checklist
- Line impedance with its angle and length confirmed.
- Zone 1 with its margin from the end of the line.
- Zone 2 not beyond the limit set by the shortest neighbouring line.
- Zone 3 with the longest neighbouring line.
- CT and VT ratio of the bay correct.
- Secondary reaches calculated and recorded.
- Minimum load impedance checked against zone 3.
- Delays coordinated with the neighbouring protections.
Related guides
- Distance protection (21)
- Zone acceleration
- CTs for distance protection
- Switch onto fault (SOTF)
- VT and CT supervision: fuse failure (60)
References
- Calculations and example data: our own, with assumed values for the sample line.
Need this study?
The calculation of reaches, times and load check for the distance protection of your lines, with the settings sheet ready to load into the relays, is part of our engineering design and studies service. We do it for projects in any country. Write to us.
Frequently asked questions
Why does zone 1 not cover 100% of the line?
Because the line data, the CTs, the VTs and the relay all carry error. If zone 1, which trips without delay, reached 100% or more, it could trip for a fault on the remote busbar or on the next line, and selectivity would be lost. That is why a margin is left; in the example, 80%.
What covers the remaining 20% of the line?
Zone 2 of this end, with a delay, and zone 1 of the opposite end, which does see that fault as close. So that the trip is not slow, a teleprotection scheme linking the two ends is used, as explained in [zone acceleration](/blog/aceleracion-de-zona/).
How do you know load will not trip the distance relay?
You calculate the minimum impedance the relay sees with maximum load and the lowest operating voltage, and check that the reach of the largest zone stays clearly below it, also taking the load angle into account. If it does not fit, a limited characteristic or a load blinder is used.