Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Codes and grid connection: US, UK, CA, AU

ESB Networks Protection Requirements for Generators

ESB Networks protection requirements for generators: interface protection by voltage level, loss of mains ROCOF at 1 Hz/s and 0.6 s, and an island example.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

ESB Networks networkCBCTGgeneratorVTInterfacerelayV, f, loss of mains, NVDintertrip fromESB Networks endLV microgeneration: ROCOF 1.0 Hz/s, 0.6 svector shift not permittedPowerInterface protection and intertrip10 kV island: 2.0 MVA, H = 2.5 sdf/dt = 50 x dP / (2 x 2.5 x 2.0)0.4 MW: 2.0 Hz/s, trips after 0.6 s0.1 MW: 0.5 Hz/s, no trip; limit 0.2 MWat 2.0 Hz/s: 48.8 or 51.2 Hz at the tripdf/dt (Hz/s)imbalance (MW)00.10.20.30.40.501.02.0blindsetting 1.0 Hz/s0.4 MW: 2.00.1 MW:0.5 Hz/s0.2 MW: 1.0illustrative; relay 1.0 Hz/s with 0.6 sProtectionCT / VTInterface relayIntertripInterface CBESB end© tizagrp.comESB Networks networkCBCTGgeneratorVTInterfacerelayV, f, loss of mains, NVDintertrip fromESB Networks endLV microgeneration: ROCOF 1.0 Hz/s, 0.6 svector shift not permittedPowerInterface protection and intertrip10 kV island: 2.0 MVA, H = 2.5 sdf/dt = 50 x dP / (2 x 2.5 x 2.0)0.4 MW: 2.0 Hz/s, trips after 0.6 s0.1 MW: 0.5 Hz/s, no trip; limit 0.2 MWat 2.0 Hz/s: 48.8 or 51.2 Hz at the tripdf/dt (Hz/s)imbalance (MW)00.10.20.30.40.501.02.0blindsetting 1.0 Hz/s0.4 MW: 2.00.1 MW:0.5 Hz/s0.2 MW: 1.0illustrative; relay 1.0 Hz/s with 0.6 sProtectionCT / VTInterface relayIntertripInterface CBESB end© tizagrp.com
Single-line diagram of the interface protection of an embedded generator in Ireland: ESB Networks network, CT and VT feeding the interface relay (voltage, frequency, loss of mains and neutral voltage displacement) that trips the interface breaker, and the intertrip from the ESB Networks end over the communications channel drawn in yellow dashed, with the low-voltage microgeneration setting of ROCOF 1.0 Hz/s with 0.6 s and no vector shift; and the island example where 0.4 MW gives 2.0 Hz/s and trips while 0.1 MW gives 0.5 Hz/s and is not detected. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

ESB Networks sets interface protection for embedded generators in company standards. For low voltage microgeneration, loss of mains protection is mandatory, rate of change of frequency is set at 1.0 Hz/s with a 0.6 s clearance time and vector shift is not permitted. At medium voltage, the standard DTIS-250701-BDW lists the required functions by connection type, allows vector shift only where ESB Networks agrees, and prefers intertripping at 38 kV where a communications channel exists. The Distribution Code also requires generators to ride through up to 1.0 Hz/s.

Short answer: ESB Networks protection requirements for generators

ESB Networks protection requirements for generators come from company standards read together with the Distribution Code. For low voltage microgeneration, loss of mains protection is mandatory and the rate of change of frequency (ROCOF) setting is 1.0 Hz/s with a 0.6 s clearance time, with vector shift not permitted. At medium voltage and 38 kV, the standard DTIS-250701-BDW lists the interface protection by connection type, and favours intertripping over ROCOF where a communications channel exists.

The Great Britain rules are covered in the G99 loss of mains guide and the Australian ones in the AS 4777 and GPS protection guide. For the national frame see the Ireland and New Zealand grid codes guide.

Which document applies

  • Distribution Code Version 8.0 (February 2023). DCC6.2 sets the minimum protection of a user at the ownership boundary. The interface circuit breaker needs relays acceptable to ESB Networks, with three phase overcurrent elements and one earth fault element, and settings for selectivity that ESB Networks provides. DCC10.10.6 asks 110 kV connected generators above 2 MW for transformer differential, backup, under frequency and loss of excitation protection. ESB Networks may add schemes such as loss of mains, based on rate of change of frequency or vector shift.
  • Micro-generation conditions (DTIS-230206-BRL, Version 6.1): low voltage installations up to about 6 kVA single phase or 11 kVA three phase.
  • Mini-generation conditions (DOC-030221-GAP, Version 1.2): inverter installations up to about 50 kVA, using inverter-integrated protection.
  • Conditions at medium voltage (DTIS-250701-BDW, Version 2, status date 25 July 2019): embedded generators at LV, MV and 38 kV, with tables of required protection by connection type.

Microgeneration interface settings

Table 3 of the micro-generation conditions fixes the interface settings. Besides over and under voltage in the table, it sets:

  • Over frequency 52 Hz and under frequency 47 Hz, 0.5 s clearance. For relays with a 0.1 Hz step, the settings are 52.1 Hz and 46.9 Hz.
  • Loss of mains is explicit. ROCOF or passive source impedance measurement may be used. Pulses injected into the network are not permitted.
  • ROCOF 1.0 Hz/s with 0.6 s, and the reset interval above 0.6 s to detect step changes.
  • Vector shift not permitted.
  • Detection performance. Islanding must be detected for a generation-to-load mismatch of 75% and 125% or greater, and demonstrated in the type test certificate.

The same document requires ROCOF immunity: the micro-generator must stay connected for a rate of change up to 1 Hz/s over a 500 ms sliding window. If ROCOF is the island detection method, the setting for that demonstration is as close as practical to 1 Hz/s.

Medium voltage and 38 kV

For larger generators, DTIS-250701-BDW lists the interface protection by voltage and connection category. Items that recur across the tables are under and over voltage, under and over frequency, loss of mains and neutral voltage displacement (NVD). Points to note:

  • At 38 kV Category 1, the standard says intertripping should be used instead of ROCOF where a suitable communications channel is available, and impedance intertripping must be enabled.
  • At 110 kV, a special protection scheme should provide loss of mains protection.
  • Vector shift appears in Table 4M as “not preferred but may be allowed by ESB”. ROCOF values there vary by generator class, and a lower setting is permitted for small “trickle feed” import cases.
  • The interface protection devices must be independent, in a secure compartment, with relay types specified by ESB Networks. Settings may not be altered without written permission, and the circuit breaker cannot reclose until all relays have reset.
  • Both a primary and a back-up circuit breaker are required per installation. The relays measure system quantities through their own current and voltage transformers (CTs and VTs) and trip the interface circuit breaker, as close as practical to the interface. An intertrip from the ESB Networks end trips the same breaker over the communications channel.

Check the tables for your voltage and category. The status date of this standard is 25 July 2019, so ask ESB Networks for the version that applies to your project.

Worked example: an island and the ROCOF setting

The figures are illustrative. They assume the micro-generation values: ROCOF at 1.0 Hz/s with 0.6 s, and frequency limits of 47 Hz and 52 Hz. At medium voltage the settings come from Table 4M. Take a 10 kV feeder section that loses its supply and forms an island. In the island there is a 2.0 MVA synchronous generator with an inertia constant H = 2.5 s. The island frequency changes at df/dt = f0 × ΔP ÷ (2 × H × S), where ΔP is the power imbalance and S the machine rating.

  1. Imbalance of 0.4 MW. df/dt = 50 × 0.4 ÷ (2 × 2.5 × 2.0) = 2.0 Hz/s. This is above the 1.0 Hz/s setting, so a ROCOF relay set at 1.0 Hz/s with 0.6 s trips once the rate has held for 0.6 s.
  2. Imbalance of 0.1 MW. df/dt = 50 × 0.1 ÷ 10 = 0.5 Hz/s. This is below the setting, so ROCOF alone does not detect the island.
  3. The detection limit. The imbalance that gives exactly 1.0 Hz/s is ΔP = 1.0 × 10 ÷ 50 = 0.2 MW. Between zero and 0.2 MW the relay is blind.
  4. Timing. At 2.0 Hz/s the frequency moves 1.2 Hz in the 0.6 s delay, so the island is at 48.8 Hz or 51.2 Hz when the relay operates. Over and under frequency at 52 Hz and 47 Hz would not have acted yet.

The lesson is that ROCOF covers large mismatches quickly and leaves a gap for small ones. That is why the micro-generation conditions require a demonstrated detection at 75% and 125% mismatch, and why medium voltage and 38 kV connections favour intertripping when a channel exists.

Checklist for the engineer

  • Identify the document and version for your voltage level and generator size.
  • List the required functions from the table for your connection category.
  • Confirm the ROCOF setting, delay and reset interval with ESB Networks in writing.
  • Check that vector shift is not enabled on low voltage microgeneration.
  • Ask whether intertripping applies at 38 kV or special protection at 110 kV.
  • Check the ride-through immunity of the generator against 1.0 Hz/s over 500 ms.
  • Record the settings and the written agreement in the commissioning file.

From the requirements to a design your engineer can sign

Interface protection fails on details: the wrong delay, a reset interval that misses steps, a relay that nobody can reach remotely. We prepare the protection design and settings plan, and we configure relays remotely. Tiza does not sign, stamp or certify designs in Ireland. We deliver engineering and settings ready for your Chartered Engineer (Engineers Ireland) to review and sign. Contact us with the relay or inverter model and the ESB Networks requirements.

Related guides: ROCOF 81R protection, interconnection relays, how anti-islanding rules compare across markets, UK interface protection and NVD and the ESB Networks Distribution Code.

Frequently asked questions

What are the ESB Networks loss of mains settings for microgeneration?

Table 3 of the micro-generation conditions (Version 6.1) lists rate of change of frequency at 1.0 Hz/s with a 0.6 s clearance time, with the reset interval set above 0.6 s. Vector shift is not permitted. Over frequency is 52 Hz and under frequency 47 Hz, each with 0.5 s.

Is the Irish ROCOF setting the same as in Great Britain?

The rate is the same, 1 Hz/s. The delay differs: 0.6 s in the ESB Networks microgeneration table, 0.5 s in G99 Issue 2. Both reject vector shift as loss of mains protection at the smaller end, although ESB Networks medium voltage rules allow it where ESB Networks agrees.

Does a generator have to ride through a rate of change of frequency?

Yes. The Distribution Code Version 8.0 requires generation units to remain synchronised during a rate of change of frequency up to plus or minus 1.0 Hz/s, measured as a rolling average over 500 ms. The micro-generation conditions repeat this as an immunity requirement proved in type testing.

WhatsApp