Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Codes and grid connection: US, UK, CA, AU

Protection at the Point of Interconnection in Canada

What Alberta and Québec require of protection at a generator's interconnection point: redundancy, breaker failure and teleprotection, with a timing check.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

HV busCBto collector and plantCT core 1CT core 2VT, windings 1 and 2Protection 1(relay A)Protection 2(relay B)TC1TC2to remotesubstationPowerProtection and teleprotectionCB: breaker; TC: trip coil138 kV solar plant in Alberta (assumed values)breaker failure: 6 + 1.5 = 7.5 cyclesmargin 12 - 7.5 = 4.5 cycles = 0.075 s99.99 %: 0.876 h a year; 99.5 %: 43.8 h12 A x 8 h = 96 Ah; with 1.25: 120 Ahmargin 4.5 cyclestimer 61.5limit 12 cycles067.512channel 99.99 %: 0.876 h a year (about 53 min)channel 99.5 %: 43.8 h a yearbattery 12 A x 8 h = 96 Ah, with 1.25 = 120 Ahillustrative: timer, channel, battery assumedProtectionCT / VTRelays A, BTrip coilsBreakerTeleprotection© tizagrp.comHV busCBto collector and plantCT core 1CT core 2VT, windings 1 and 2Protection 1(relay A)Protection 2(relay B)TC1TC2to remotesubstationPowerProtection and teleprotectionCB: breaker; TC: trip coil138 kV solar plant in Alberta (assumed values)breaker failure: 6 + 1.5 = 7.5 cyclesmargin 12 - 7.5 = 4.5 cycles = 0.075 s99.99 %: 0.876 h a year; 99.5 %: 43.8 h12 A x 8 h = 96 Ah; with 1.25: 120 Ahmargin 4.5 cyclestimer 61.5limit 12 cycles067.512channel 99.99 %: 0.876 h a year (about 53 min)channel 99.5 %: 43.8 h a yearbattery 12 A x 8 h = 96 Ah, with 1.25 = 120 Ahillustrative: timer, channel, battery assumedProtectionCT / VTRelays A, BTrip coilsBreakerTeleprotection© tizagrp.com
Single-line protection diagram at the connection point: HV bus, breaker with two trip coils, step-up transformer, two CT cores and one VT with two windings feeding two relays, each tripping through its own trip coil, and the teleprotection channel to the remote breakers, drawn with the protection in yellow dashed; with the breaker failure budget of 7.5 cycles against a 12 cycle limit, the channel availability and the battery size of a 138 kV example. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

Canadian transmission operators ask for two independent protection systems at a generator's connection point. AESO ISO rule 503.15 in Alberta and the Hydro-Québec transmission requirements spell out the detail. It covers separate current transformer (CT) and voltage transformer (VT) windings, independent DC supply, breaker failure with remote tripping and event recording. Automatic reclosing of the plant is banned by default. Ontario fixes the detail through the connection assessment.

Short answer: protection at the point of interconnection in Canada

Protection at the point of interconnection in Canada is set by the system operator and the transmission owner of each province. For plants on the transmission system, two public documents give the most detail. They are ISO rule 503.15 of the Alberta Electric System Operator (AESO) and chapter 8 of the Hydro-Québec transmission requirements. Both ask for two independent protection systems, breaker failure and fast communication channels. Ontario sets the detail through the connection assessment. See the overview of Canadian electrical codes and grid connection for the wider frame.

What the point of interconnection protection must do

The protection at the connection point has three jobs. It clears faults inside the plant so that the grid is not affected. It removes the plant’s contribution to faults on the grid. And it stays out of the way during disturbances the plant must ride through, as explained in ride-through requirements by province.

Alberta: ISO rule 503.15

Version in force: effective April 1, 2024. It covers plants connected directly to the transmission system. The size limits are 18 MW for generating units, 67.5 MW for aggregated facilities and 18 MW for storage.

  • Two protection systems. Each has an independent CT core, VT winding, communication channel, interconnecting cables, DC supply and trip circuit, including the trip coil. One relay must come from a different manufacturer or use a different principle.
  • Instrument transformers. Protection-class CTs and VTs, with separate cores and windings for each system. A loss-of-potential alarm is required on VTs used for protection.
  • Operate times. Maximum primary operate times by voltage and function, for example 2.00 cycles for bus protection at 138 kV.
  • Breaker failure. Every breaker has breaker failure protection. For 240 kV and above, it uses direct tripping of remote breakers by communications. For 144 kV and below, it trips local and remote breakers, with a channel of at least 99.5% availability or within a defined time. The maximum breaker failure time is 12 cycles (0.200 s) at 138 and 144 kV, 7 cycles at 240 kV and 6 cycles at 500 kV.
  • Communications. Overall availability of at least 99.99% for each protection channel, unless the functional specification states otherwise.
  • Event recording. At least one fault recorder per zone, time-stamped within 1.0 ms of UTC, with records retrievable within 24 hours.
  • Reclosing. If a dedicated single line connects the plant to the grid, auto-reclosing is prohibited unless the functional specification provides for it. Reclosing of the generator breakers after a plant fault is prohibited.
  • Plant side. Aggregated facilities need two protection systems on the step-up transformer and two on the high-voltage bus. Two systems must detect reverse power on generating units.

Québec: chapter 8 of the transmission requirements

Hydro-Québec’s Technical Requirements for the Connection of Generating Stations to the Hydro-Québec Transmission System (Decision D-2022-088, effective July 15, 2022) asks for:

  • Two primary protections, each with its own trip relay, covering all fault types, including high-impedance faults with the fault resistance the document sets.
  • Current and voltage transformers on each phase, with separate secondary windings for the two primary protections.
  • Two sets of trip coils with separate cores at 230 kV and above.
  • Breaker failure protection, with a dedicated link to trip remote breakers when needed.
  • Remote tripping when Hydro-Québec requires it, for example if reclosing is faster than 2 s or if islanding is possible.
  • Protection relays certified by Hydro-Québec, and no setting changes without written authorisation.
  • No automatic reclosing of the station unless agreed after the interconnection study.

Hydro-Québec supplies, installs and maintains the teleprotection transmission equipment. The telecommunications junction point marks the boundary with the plant’s equipment. More detail is in Hydro-Québec technical requirements for generators.

Ontario: set through the connection assessment

The Market Rules require transmitters’ protection systems to be built and maintained according to the applicable reliability standards. They also require communication channels as reliable as the associated protection. For a generator, the exact relay arrangement is confirmed with the connecting transmitter and the IESO during the connection assessment.

Worked example (illustrative)

A 138 kV solar plant in Alberta. The timer, channel and battery values are assumed.

  1. Breaker failure budget. The rule measures this time from the primary protection’s trip contact to the last local breaker receiving the open signal. Timer setting 6 cycles plus 1.5 cycles for the output relay and auxiliary elements gives 7.5 cycles. The limit is 12 cycles, so the margin is 12 − 7.5 = 4.5 cycles = 0.075 s at 60 Hz.
  2. Channel availability. At 99.99%, the allowed outage is (1 − 0.9999) × 8,760 h = 0.876 h, about 53 minutes per year. At 99.5%, the level the rule accepts for breaker failure channels at 144 kV and below, the allowed outage is 43.8 hours per year.
  3. Battery. A protection DC load of 12 A for 8 hours needs 12 × 8 = 96 Ah before temperature and ageing factors. With a 1.25 factor, 120 Ah.

Checklist for the engineer

  • Identify the operator’s current rule and the plant’s size class.
  • Draw two independent protections with separate CT cores, VT windings and DC supplies.
  • Use relays from different manufacturers, or different principles, for the two systems.
  • Set breaker failure with a timing budget and a remote trip path.
  • Define the teleprotection channel, its availability and the junction point.
  • Disable reclosing of the plant unless the operator agrees in writing.
  • Add fault recording with time synchronisation and a retrieval procedure.
  • Coordinate protection settings with ride-through, so that no relay trips inside the required region.
  • Get the settings approved by the operator before energisation.

In Canada, electrical engineering is stamped by a professional engineer (P.Eng.) licensed in the province or territory of the project. Tiza delivers protection design and studies ready for your P.Eng. to review and stamp. Tiza does not stamp, sign or certify designs.

From the rule to a protection design your engineer can stamp

The path from a clause to a protection scheme runs through the single-line diagram, the relay list, the channel design and the settings. We prepare the engineering design and the protection settings plan, ready for your engineer of record to review and stamp. Contact us with the plant data and the operator’s requirements.

Figure: single-line protection diagram at the connection point. Two relays are fed from separate CT cores and VT windings, each trips the breaker through its own trip coil, and the teleprotection channel links them to the remote breakers.

References

  • AESO, ISO rules Section 503.15 Interconnected Electric System Protection, effective April 1, 2024.
  • Hydro-Québec TransÉnergie, Technical Requirements for the Connection of Generating Stations to the Hydro-Québec Transmission System, Decision D-2022-088, effective July 15, 2022, chapter 8.
  • IESO, Renewed Market Rules, Chapter 4 Grid Connection Requirements, Appendices, Issue 2.0, December 3, 2025, Appendix 4.4.

Frequently asked questions

Does a generator in Alberta need two protection systems at the connection point?

Yes, for generating units of 18 MW or more, aggregated facilities of 67.5 MW or more and storage of 18 MW or more connected directly to the transmission system. ISO rule 503.15 asks for two independent systems with separate CT cores, VT windings, channels, DC supplies and trip circuits.

Is breaker failure protection required?

Both Alberta and Québec require it. In Alberta every breaker needs breaker failure protection, and Québec requires it to trip adjacent zones when a breaker needed for transmission protection fails. Remote tripping over a communication link is added when fast clearing is needed.

Who supplies the teleprotection equipment in Québec?

Hydro-Québec supplies, installs and maintains the equipment that carries teleprotection signals. The plant provides power, secure space, ducts, junction boxes and the tone or teleprotection units that form part of its protection systems.

WhatsApp