Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Codes and grid connection: US, UK, CA, AU

S5.2.5.14 Active Power Control and Ramp Rate: NER Guide

What NER clause S5.2.5.14 requires for dispatch, ramp rates and AGC signals in scheduled and non-scheduled plants, with a worked ramp rate example for you.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

control centredispatch, AGCplant controllerramp, cap, AGCsetpointto invertersbus=~100 MWPowerControlCommscase A: 40 to 90 MW at 10 MW/min50 / 10 = 5.0 min; 0.67 MW per 4 s cycle300 s / 4 s: about 75 stepscase B: cap 60 MW in 5 min: 12 MW/minat 10 MW/min: 6.0 min, 1 min latemin0123456A: ramp 50 MW at 10 MW/min = 5.0 minB: time allowed 5 minB: 60 MW at 10 MW/min = 6.0 min5illustrative valuesControl pathDispatchLinkPlant controllerInvertersOutput© tizagrp.comcontrol centredispatch, AGCplant controllerramp, cap, AGCsetpointto invertersbus=~100 MWPowerControlCommscase A: 40 to 90 MW at 10 MW/min50 / 10 = 5.0 min; 0.67 MW per 4 s cycle300 s / 4 s: about 75 stepscase B: cap 60 MW in 5 min: 12 MW/minat 10 MW/min: 6.0 min, 1 min latemin0123456A: ramp 50 MW at 10 MW/min = 5.0 minB: time allowed 5 minB: 60 MW at 10 MW/min = 6.0 min5illustrative valuesControl pathDispatchLinkPlant controllerInvertersOutput© tizagrp.com
NER S5.2.5.14: the control path from the control centre dispatch and AGC signal over the communications link to the plant controller and the inverters of a 100 MW semi-scheduled solar plant, with the power circuit, and a ramp of 10 MW per minute that takes 5.0 minutes for a 50 MW change but 6.0 minutes for a 60 MW cap due in 5. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

Clause S5.2.5.14 of the National Electricity Rules sets how a generating system follows dispatch instructions: scheduled and semi-scheduled plants need an active power control system with linear ramping and automatic generation control, while non-scheduled plants must move to or below a level set by the control centre within 5 minutes.

Clause S5.2.5.14 of the National Electricity Rules (NER) is titled “Active power control”. It tells the plant how to follow the market’s dispatch: how fast to ramp, what signals to accept and how to hold a cap when the control centre asks. The Australian Energy Market Operator (AEMO) issues the dispatch instructions, and the plant reports through supervisory control and data acquisition (SCADA).

It is part of the generator performance standards (GPS) in the Australia electrical codes and grid connection guide.

Short answer

S5.2.5.14 requires an active power control system that is adequately damped and follows dispatch. For scheduled generation it also ramps linearly between dispatch levels and responds automatically to automatic generation control (AGC) signals. For non-scheduled and semi-scheduled generation it moves to or below a level set by the control centre within 5 minutes, at a constant rate, subject to energy source availability.

What the clause says, in plain words

The clause has three versions, chosen by how the plant is classified in the market.

  • Scheduled plants. The control system follows dispatch instructions and ramps output linearly between dispatch levels. It also responds automatically to AGC signals.
  • Non-scheduled plants. Subject to energy source availability, output moves within 5 minutes, at a constant rate, to or below the level in an electronic instruction from a control centre. The system then limits output to that level. It does not change output by more than the raise and lower amounts in the instruction.
  • Semi-scheduled plants. Both sets of capabilities apply: the 5 minute dispatch response and cap, linear ramping, and AGC signals.

AGC capability has been mandatory for all scheduled and semi-scheduled plant since 5 October 2018, with no capacity exclusion. A non-scheduled plant must be able to apply a dispatch cap.

What the assessor asks for

The applicant supplies:

  • Ramp up and ramp down capability, for example in MW per minute, with the maximum and minimum achievable rates.
  • A control block diagram of the active power control scheme, including the proportional-integral parameters where they are used.
  • A qualitative description of the control system and dispatch logic, enough for AEMO to understand how the plant responds to dispatch.
  • For hybrid plants combining wind, battery and solar, the control logic and settings of each local controller, as well as the overall scheme.
  • A SCADA signal list that includes the ramp rates required by clause S5.2.6.1, and an end-to-end signal test (send, acknowledge, receive) before and just after energisation.

The control path is part of the design: the signal goes from AEMO’s control centre across the communications link to the plant controller, and from there to every inverter. The clause on remote monitoring covers the signal list and the link.

Worked example (illustrative)

The numbers are illustrative. A semi-scheduled solar farm has a rating of 100 MW and an active power control system with a ramp capability of 10 MW per minute.

Case A: a dispatch change from 40 MW to 90 MW

  1. Change required: 90 - 40 = 50 MW.
  2. Time at 10 MW per minute: 50 / 10 = 5.0 minutes.
  3. Change in each AGC cycle, assuming a 4-second cycle: 10 MW per minute × 4 / 60 = 0.67 MW. A linear ramp is therefore about 75 steps (300 s / 4 s).

Case B: a cap instruction to reduce by 60 MW within 5 minutes

  1. Required constant rate: 60 / 5 = 12 MW per minute.
  2. The plant’s ramp capability is 10 MW per minute, below the 12 MW per minute required.
  3. Time at the plant’s rate: 60 / 10 = 6.0 minutes, which exceeds the 5 minutes.

Result. The plant can follow the dispatch ramp, but it would miss the 5 minute cap instruction by 1 minute. The remedy is a ramp capability of at least 12 MW per minute downward. A plant that can only ramp down at 10 MW per minute must report that lower rate in its SCADA data, so AEMO’s systems know the real figure. The design would also have to show the limit comes from the energy source or hardware, and agree it in the access standard. Ramp rates in the clause are about capability that is truthful and signalled, not about a number the controller cannot hold.

The AGC cycle also sets a timing budget for the communications link. The guide on SCADA signals that reach the relay but not the control centre is a good test of the whole chain.

Checklist for the engineer

  • The plant’s market classification: scheduled, semi-scheduled or non-scheduled.
  • Ramp up and down capability in MW per minute, from controller and inverter specifications.
  • Active power control block diagram, with the controller parameters and the signal path.
  • Dispatch cap and runback functions, with the timing from instruction to reached level.
  • AGC signal handling at the period AEMO uses.
  • Behaviour when energy source availability falls below the dispatch target.
  • SCADA signal list, end-to-end test plan and results before and after energisation.
  • Settings for hybrid plants where battery and generation controllers share a connection point.

Figure

Figure: control path from the dispatch signal through the communications link and plant controller to the inverters, with the power circuit, the control signals and the communications link.

Next step

Tiza prepares the active power control documentation and the signal lists for submissions to the network service provider and AEMO, working remotely and in English. Tiza does not stamp, sign or certify: it delivers engineering ready for review and certification by your RPEQ in Queensland, or by the registered engineer your state requires. Contact us with the plant controller description and the connection requirements.

See S5.2.5.11 on frequency control, S5.2.5.13 on voltage and reactive power control, the PPC and SCADA cybersecurity guide and DNP3 points, classes and events.

Frequently asked questions

Which plants need automatic generation control under S5.2.5.14?

Automatic generation control capability has been mandatory for all scheduled and semi-scheduled plant since 5 October 2018. Non-scheduled plant must be able to apply a dispatch cap instead.

How often does the plant receive the control signal?

At the update period of AEMO's automatic generation control system. The plant controller and the communications link must handle each new setpoint within that cycle, which the design should confirm with AEMO.

What evidence shows compliance?

A SCADA signal list that includes the ramp rates, an end-to-end signal test before and after energisation, ramp capability in MW per minute, and a block diagram of the active power control scheme, with the control logic of each controller for hybrid plants.

WhatsApp