Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Codes and grid connection: US, UK, CA, AU

S5.2.5.11 Frequency Control and Droop: NER Guide

How NER clause S5.2.5.11 sets primary frequency response for generators: droop, deadband, operating limits and a droop calculation worked out step by step.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

connection pointCTVT: frequencyfrequency responsedroop 4 %, +/-0.15 Hzsetpoint to turbinesG100 MW wind farm80 MW runningPowerMeasure / control80 MW running; limits 20 and 100 MW49.50 Hz: 0.7 / 4 = 17.5 MW, 80 + 17.5 = 97.550.60 Hz: 0.9 / 4 = 22.5 MW, 80 - 22.5 = 57.50.9 %: 45 MW at 2 % droop, 9 MW at 10 %MWHz49.55050.6208057.597.5max 100 MWmin 20 MWillustrative valuesDroop controlFrequencyDeadbandDroopSetpointOutput© tizagrp.comconnection pointCTVT: frequencyfrequency responsedroop 4 %, +/-0.15 Hzsetpoint to turbinesG100 MW wind farm80 MW runningPowerMeasure / control80 MW running; limits 20 and 100 MW49.50 Hz: 0.7 / 4 = 17.5 MW, 80 + 17.5 = 97.550.60 Hz: 0.9 / 4 = 22.5 MW, 80 - 22.5 = 57.50.9 %: 45 MW at 2 % droop, 9 MW at 10 %MWHz49.55050.6208057.597.5max 100 MWmin 20 MWillustrative valuesDroop controlFrequencyDeadbandDroopSetpointOutput© tizagrp.com
NER S5.2.5.11: a 100 MW wind farm with its CT and frequency VT feeding the frequency response controller set to droop 4 percent and a deadband of 0.15 Hz, the setpoint to the turbines, and the droop characteristic with 97.5 MW at 49.50 Hz and 57.5 MW at 50.60 Hz between the 20 and 100 MW limits. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

Clause S5.2.5.11 of the National Electricity Rules requires a generating system to respond to frequency in the right direction, to operate in a proportional frequency response mode with an adjustable deadband and droop, and to be able to support market frequency control services. Frequency control capability has been mandatory since 5 October 2018.

Clause S5.2.5.11 of the National Electricity Rules (NER) is titled “Frequency control”. It sets how a generating system moves its output when system frequency moves. That is the primary frequency response that holds the grid together in the first seconds after a loss of generation or load. The Australian Energy Market Operator (AEMO) and the network service provider (NSP) assess it with root-mean-square (RMS) and electromagnetic transient (EMT) models.

The clause is part of the generator performance standards (GPS) described in the Australia electrical codes and grid connection guide.

Short answer

S5.2.5.11 requires four things of a generating system. Power transfer must not move the wrong way when frequency changes. The plant must be able to run in a frequency response mode that changes output in proportion to the frequency deviation. The response must be fast enough and last long enough for the plant to offer frequency control services in the market. The control must be adequately damped. Frequency control capability has been mandatory since 5 October 2018, and the clause was updated again for the primary frequency response rule change.

What the clause says, in plain words

  • Right direction. Output must not rise when frequency rises, and must not fall when frequency falls.
  • Proportional response. The plant can decrease output on rising frequency and increase it on falling frequency. The response is quick enough and lasts long enough for the generator to offer measurable amounts of every market frequency control service. A plant with storage that can switch between producing and consuming has its own wording, with a smooth change of operating mode through zero.
  • Limits. The plant is not required to go below its minimum operating level or above its maximum. The response starts with no delay beyond what stable operation or the plant controls require, once frequency leaves a deadband around 50 Hz.
  • Settings. The deadband is set within 0 to plus or minus 1.0 Hz. Droop is adjustable within the range the clause sets, and the agreed values go into the performance standard.
  • Damping and registration. Every control system used for the standard is adequately damped. The amount of market ancillary service the plant is registered for must not exceed what the standard supports.

The clause also defines droop. It is the percentage change in frequency at the connection point divided by the percentage change in power transfer, on the plant’s maximum operating level. It is measured outside the deadband.

Under the access standard process, a plant that proposes something below the automatic standard has to show that its response is as close as practicable to it. The agreed maximum and minimum operating levels go into the performance standard.

What the assessor asks for

AEMO and the NSP ask for evidence. It includes control block diagrams, operating modes, time constants, droop settings and deadbands for both directions. It also asks for RMS and EMT time-domain studies of the response to frequency changes. Commissioning includes plant-level frequency injection tests, and model data is reviewed against recorded events. A study on a single machine against an infinite bus is not enough on its own, because droop settings need checking against the wider network for damping.

The operating and reset characteristic of protection 81 is a useful companion. Frequency relays and frequency response controllers share the same measurement but have opposite jobs, so their settings must not conflict.

Worked example (illustrative)

The numbers are illustrative. A wind farm has a maximum operating level of 100 MW and a minimum operating level of 20 MW. It is running at 80 MW with enough wind to move up to its maximum. Settings: deadband plus or minus 0.15 Hz, droop 4 percent. Assume the response is measured from the edge of the deadband.

Frequency falls to 49.50 Hz

  1. Deviation outside the deadband: 0.50 - 0.15 = 0.35 Hz.
  2. As a percentage of 50 Hz: 0.35 / 50 = 0.7 percent.
  3. Power change = 0.7 / 4 = 17.5 percent of 100 MW = 17.5 MW.
  4. New output = 80 + 17.5 = 97.5 MW, below the 100 MW limit, so the full response is delivered.

Frequency rises to 50.60 Hz

  1. Deviation outside the deadband: 0.60 - 0.15 = 0.45 Hz.
  2. As a percentage: 0.45 / 50 = 0.9 percent.
  3. Power change = 0.9 / 4 = 22.5 percent of 100 MW = 22.5 MW.
  4. New output = 80 - 22.5 = 57.5 MW, above the 20 MW floor, so the plant stays in range.

Sensitivity. The same 0.9 percent deviation gives 45 MW at 2 percent droop and 9 MW at 10 percent, a fivefold difference in response.

The agreed droop and operating limits must be written in the performance standard. For the same frequency event, the delivered MW depends entirely on them.

Checklist for the engineer

  • Maximum and minimum operating levels, defined and written into the standard.
  • Droop and deadband settings for rise and fall, within the ranges of the clause.
  • Block diagram of the control with time constants and the frequency measurement point.
  • Energy source headroom: what happens at curtailed or fully dispatched output.
  • Proof that the response is in the correct direction in all operating modes, including start-up and ramping.
  • Time-domain studies in RMS and EMT models, with damping checked.
  • Commissioning test plan for frequency injection at the plant level.
  • Market service registration no larger than the standard supports.

Figure

Figure: droop characteristic of a 100 MW plant, with the deadband around 50 Hz, the sloped response outside it, and the minimum and maximum operating levels as flat limits.

Next step

Tiza runs the frequency response studies and prepares the control documentation for submissions to the network service provider and AEMO, remotely and in English. Tiza does not stamp, sign or certify: it delivers engineering and studies ready for review and certification by your RPEQ in Queensland, or by the registered engineer your state requires. Contact us with the plant data and the control description.

Next in the series: S5.2.5.12 on impact on network capability and S5.2.5.14 on active power control. Related reading: underfrequency load shedding and 81 frequency trip with on-site generation.

Frequently asked questions

What deadband does the clause allow?

The deadband must be set within the range of 0 to plus or minus 1.0 Hz. The droop is also adjustable, and the agreed deadband and droop settings are recorded in the performance standard.

How is droop defined in the clause?

Droop is the percentage change in frequency at the connection point divided by the percentage change in power transfer, expressed on the maximum operating level of the plant. It is measured at frequencies outside the deadband and within the limits of power transfer.

Does the plant have to go below its minimum operating level on high frequency?

No. The clause states that the plant need not operate below its minimum operating level when frequency rises, or above its maximum operating level when frequency falls. Those two levels are agreed values recorded in the performance standard.

WhatsApp