Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Codes and grid connection: US, UK, CA, AU

S5.2.5.12 Impact on Network Capability: NER Guide

What NER clause S5.2.5.12 means for a new generator: it must not cut network transfer capability, how that is studied, and a limit comparison worked out.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

region ACTVTmid-corridor substationto region B21 + MWcorridor endCT=~150 MW plant50/51plant feederrunbackcontrollerrunback via plant controllerPowerMeasure / tripCommslimit change with the 150 MW plantworst case: minimum synchronous, -17 MW17 / 438 = 3.9 %: any reduction failsrunback armed: back to 438 MW, change 00MWlight demand-3medium demand0high demand-5min synchronous gen-17high interconnector0low interconnector+1runback: 0illustrative valuesRunbackMeasure transferRunbackPlant controllerInvertersLimit held© tizagrp.comregion ACTVTmid-corridor substationto region B21 + MWcorridor endCT=~150 MW plant50/51plant feederrunbackcontrollerrunback via plant controllerPowerMeasure / tripCommslimit change with the 150 MW plantworst case: minimum synchronous, -17 MW17 / 438 = 3.9 %: any reduction failsrunback armed: back to 438 MW, change 00MWlight demand-3medium demand0high demand-5min synchronous gen-17high interconnector0low interconnector+1runback: 0illustrative valuesRunbackMeasure transferRunbackPlant controllerInvertersLimit held© tizagrp.com
NER S5.2.5.12: a 220 kV corridor with a mid-corridor substation, the corridor end breaker with its CT, VT and distance relay that also measures the transfer, a 150 MW solar plant with its feeder relay, and the runback signal over the communications link to the inverters, with the transfer limit changes of minus 3, 0, minus 5, minus 17, 0 and plus 1 MW. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

Clause S5.2.5.12 of the National Electricity Rules requires a new generating system to have plant capabilities and control systems that stop it reducing inter-regional or intra-regional power transfer capability below the level that applies without it. It is shown by load flow, dynamic and small-signal studies across a range of operating conditions.

Clause S5.2.5.12 of the National Electricity Rules (NER) is titled “Impact on network capability”. It is the shortest clause in the set and one of the most expensive to prove, because the proof is a network study and not a plant test. The Australian Energy Market Operator (AEMO) assesses it with root-mean-square (RMS) and electromagnetic transient (EMT) studies.

It forms part of the generator performance standards (GPS) in the Australia electrical codes and grid connection guide.

Short answer

S5.2.5.12 requires plant capabilities and control systems sufficient that the generating system does not cut any inter-regional or intra-regional transfer capability. The reference is the level that would apply without the plant. The evidence is a set of load flow, dynamic and small-signal studies across a range of operating conditions.

What the clause says, in plain words

  • No loss of capability. The plant, with its controls, must not lower any transfer limit between regions or inside a region. A transfer limit is the maximum power that can flow across a corridor before a thermal, voltage or stability limit is reached.
  • Capability, not behaviour. The clause speaks about capabilities and control systems the plant has. It asks what the plant can do to avoid harming the limit, not only what it does on the day.
  • Interaction with other clauses. The reactive power capability under S5.2.5.1 and the voltage control under S5.2.5.13 feed into this assessment. Small-signal stability and system strength arrangements overlap with it too.

Under the access standard process, a proposed standard below the automatic one has extra duties. Any control system included to limit a reduction in capability is detailed in the performance standard. So are the agreed capabilities and operating arrangements the generator keeps.

How the studies are run

The studies cover five areas.

  1. Steady-state load flow and time-domain studies that show the effect of the plant on the key transfer limits. These can be voltage limits, transient stability limits or thermal limits, depending on the corridor. The network service provider (NSP) advises which limits matter.
  2. Small-signal studies of the effect on the inter-area modes of oscillation, since small-signal stability can restrict transfer.
  3. A range of operating conditions. At a minimum: maximum output in the over-excited and under-excited range, light, medium and high regional demand, high and low interconnector transfer, and minimum synchronous generation. Existing networks, existing plants, other committed projects, control systems, protection systems, auxiliaries and automatic reclose are part of the model.
  4. Both RMS and EMT tools for plants with converters, to catch control interaction and instability that RMS models do not show.
  5. Operational arrangements, where needed, so the plant can be run to at least the minimum standard in abnormal conditions.

The clause is where power system studies and protection meet: a runback or intertrip scheme to hold a limit is itself a protection and control design.

Worked example (illustrative)

The numbers are illustrative. A 220 kV corridor has a transfer limit that the NSP’s studies set for six operating conditions. The table compares the limit without the new 150 MW plant and with it.

ConditionLimit without plant (MW)Limit with plant (MW)Change (MW)
Light demand450447-3
Medium demand4624620
High demand471466-5
Minimum synchronous generation438421-17
High interconnector transfer4554550
Low interconnector transfer448449+1

Step 1. Find the worst change: the minimum synchronous generation case, -17 MW.

Step 2. Express it against the base limit: 17 / 438 = 3.9 percent.

Step 3. Any reduction fails the automatic standard, so the design as modelled does not meet it. The cause is that, with less synchronous generation, voltage control at the connection point is weaker.

Step 4. Candidate remedies: a faster voltage control mode for the plant, additional reactive plant, or a runback scheme that reduces output when the corridor approaches its limit. Suppose a runback scheme is added and the studies are rerun. The minimum synchronous generation limit returns to 438 MW with the scheme armed. The change is now 0 MW and every row is 0 or higher.

Result. The plant now meets the clause, but only if the runback scheme is part of the performance standard and its communications, status and testing are stated. The arrangement that holds the limit is recorded, because the plant depends on it.

Checklist for the engineer

  • A list of corridors and limits the NSP considers relevant, with limit type for each.
  • Plant models in RMS and EMT, validated against the plant design.
  • A matrix of operating conditions covering the minimum set above.
  • Results for each condition with and without the plant, shown side by side.
  • Small-signal results for inter-area and local modes.
  • Details of any control, runback or intertrip scheme, and a protection and communications design for it.
  • Operating arrangements the generator will keep, written into the performance standard.

Figure

Figure: single line of a 220 kV corridor with the new plant on a mid-corridor substation, showing the transfer limit measurement point, the runback signal path and the protection of the corridor.

Next step

Tiza prepares power system studies and plant model documentation for submissions to the network service provider and AEMO, remotely and in English. Tiza does not stamp, sign or certify: it delivers studies ready for review and certification by your RPEQ in Queensland, or by the registered engineer your state requires. Contact us with the network data and the plant description.

See S5.2.5.11 on frequency control, S5.2.5.13 on voltage and reactive power control, transient stability basics and swing curves and damping.

Frequently asked questions

What does impact on network capability mean?

It means the transfer limit across a part of the network, set by thermal, voltage or stability limits. If connecting the new plant lowers that limit, the plant has a negative impact, and the clause requires the plant's capabilities and controls to prevent that.

Who runs the studies for this clause?

The connecting network service provider may run them, because it knows the modelling assumptions behind the network operating limits. The applicant's engineer supplies the plant models and reviews the results.

Does the study use RMS models only?

No. For plants with converters, both RMS and EMT studies are expected, to confirm there is no adverse operation for abnormal and unbalanced events, control interactions or control instability that might affect transfer capability.

WhatsApp