NERC PRC-024 limits how generator protection may trip during frequency and voltage excursions. PRC-024-4 covers synchronous generators, Type 1 and Type 2 wind resources and synchronous condensers. Owners set frequency and voltage relays so they do not trip inside the no-trip boundaries, document any exception, and provide settings to the planner on request.
Short answer
NERC PRC-024 is the generator ride-through standard of the North American Electric Reliability Corporation (NERC). It tells owners how their frequency and voltage protection may behave during grid disturbances. The rule is simple to state. Frequency and voltage relays must not trip the unit inside a published no-trip boundary. Outside the boundary the protection is free to act.
The current version is PRC-024-4. The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) approved it in Order No. 909, published in July 2025, and it replaces PRC-024-3. It applies to synchronous generators, Type 1 and Type 2 wind resources and synchronous condensers. The obligations fall on the Generator Owner (GO) and, for synchronous condensers, also on the Transmission Owner (TO). Inverter-based resources (IBR) are now handled by PRC-029-1, covered in our PRC-029 guide.
The wider framework is in the US electrical codes and grid interconnection guide. Effective dates and phase-in rules are set in NERC’s implementation plan, so check them before you plan a project.
What the standard asks, requirement by requirement
PRC-024-4 has four requirements that matter to an owner.
- R1, frequency. The owner sets generator frequency protection in line with Attachment 1. The attachment is a curve of frequency against time. Protection must not trip the unit within that region.
- R2, voltage. The owner sets voltage protection in line with Attachment 2. It works the same way, with a no-trip region for voltage measured at the point the standard defines.
- R3, exceptions. If a regulatory or equipment limitation prevents meeting R1 or R2, the owner documents it and communicates it to the Planning Coordinator (PC) and the Transmission Planner (TP) within 30 calendar days. Typical evidence is a study result or a manufacturer statement.
- R4, settings on request. The owner provides the settings to the PC or TP within 60 calendar days of a written request.
The curves themselves are in NERC’s published standard. Use the current text, because the attachments are what the compliance auditor will read.
Why the standard exists
A grid disturbance can lower voltage or move frequency over a wide area. If many generators trip together on tight relay settings, the loss of supply makes the event worse. The standard reduces that risk by making protection coordinate with the grid’s own limits. It does not require equipment to be damaged to stay online. It sets a boundary, and the owner shows the settings sit outside it.
Where the settings live
Most of the work is in a handful of devices. The generator protection relay holds the frequency elements (81O and 81U) and the voltage elements (59 and 27). Some plants also have volts-per-hertz limits, and the excitation system has limiters that act before protection. The guide on synchronous generator protection lists the functions, and the base data for generator protection settings shows what an engineer needs before touching a setting. Limiters are covered in our PRC-019 guide.
Two practical points come up often:
- The relay measures at the generator terminals, while the voltage boundary is defined for a different point. Convert with the step-up transformer ratio and the standard’s reference point.
- The time delay in the relay is not the only delay. Add the relay’s operating time, any trip logic and the timing tolerance before comparing against the curve.
Worked example (illustrative)
The numbers below are illustrative assumptions, not values from the standard. The real boundaries are in the current Attachment 1 and Attachment 2.
Assumptions. A 13.8 kV generator has a voltage transformer ratio of 13,800 V to 115 V, which is 120 to 1. For this exercise only, suppose a voltage no-trip boundary of 1.10 per unit for 3 seconds, with no point above it. The real Attachment 2 also has points above 1.10 per unit with shorter times, and each one must be checked. Assume the terminal voltage in per unit equals the voltage at the reference point. Suppose also an illustrative frequency boundary of no trip for 30 seconds at a given low-frequency point. The relay timer has a tolerance of 1 percent.
Step 1. Voltage pickup. Choose an overvoltage pickup of 1.12 per unit, which sits above the 1.10 boundary. Primary value: 1.12 × 13.8 kV = 15.456 kV.
Step 2. Secondary value. 15,456 V ÷ 120 = 128.8 V on the relay.
Step 3. Time check. The boundary needs 3 seconds of no trip at 1.10. Because the pickup is above 1.10, the relay does not start timing inside this illustrative boundary. The margin is 0.02 per unit.
Step 4. Frequency timer. Set the timer to 36 seconds against a 30 second hold requirement. With a tolerance of 1 percent the worst case is 36 × 0.99 = 35.64 seconds.
Step 5. Compare. 35.64 seconds is greater than 30 seconds, so the margin is 5.64 seconds. If the margin had been negative, the setting would move or the exception would be documented under R3.
Record the calculation with the relay model, firmware version and setting file, so a request under R4 can be answered quickly.
Common mistakes
Setting at the terminals and forgetting the reference point. The no-trip region is defined for a specific measuring point. A relay that sits on the generator side of a step-up transformer sees a different voltage, because of the transformer ratio and the voltage drop across it. Convert before you compare.
Counting only the relay timer. The time that matters is the time from the start of the excursion to the trip contact. It includes measuring windows, filters, trip logic and the breaker. A timer set exactly on the boundary leaves no margin once those pieces are added.
Leaving old settings in place after an upgrade. When a protection relay is replaced, the setting file is often copied from the old one. The new relay may use another measuring method or another default for a related function. Check every frequency and voltage element after a replacement, and not only the ones that were changed on purpose.
Treating an exception as a permanent answer. R3 allows an owner to document a limitation. It is meant for real equipment or regulatory constraints, with evidence. The record should state who reviewed it and when it will be reviewed again, so the exception does not outlive the equipment that caused it.
Ignoring the other trip paths. A unit can also trip through the excitation system, the turbine controls or a plant controller. The standard speaks about protection settings, but an owner who wants the unit to ride through has to look at every path to a trip, and the synchronous generator protection guide is a good starting list.
Checklist for the engineer
- Confirm which unit types you own: synchronous generator, Type 1 or Type 2 wind, synchronous condenser.
- Obtain the current PRC-024 text and the attachments from NERC.
- List every frequency and voltage element that can trip the unit.
- Convert relay values to the standard’s reference point.
- Add timer tolerance and relay operating time to each delay.
- Document any equipment limitation as an R3 exception, with evidence.
- Keep the setting files, so R4 requests can be met in 60 calendar days.
- Recheck after any relay replacement or firmware change.
Who signs and seals
In the United States, protection design is normally signed and sealed by a professional engineer licensed in the state of the project. Our work is delivered ready for your engineer of record to review and stamp. Tiza does not sign, seal or certify work in the United States. Compliance with a NERC standard stays with the registered owner; our studies support its analysis and evidence.
How Tiza can help
If your generator needs its protection settings calculated and documented against PRC-024, Tiza provides remote relay configuration and settings plans in English, ready for your engineer of record to review and stamp. Contact us with the relay model, the setting files and the unit data.
Figure: single-line sketch of a generator, step-up transformer, protection relay and the point where the voltage boundary is measured.
Frequently asked questions
Does PRC-024 still apply to solar and battery plants?
Not in its current version. PRC-024-4 was narrowed to synchronous generators, Type 1 and Type 2 wind resources and synchronous condensers. Inverter-based resources moved to PRC-029-1, which has its own requirements.
Is a generator required to stay online no matter what?
No. The standard defines no-trip boundaries. Protection must not operate inside them, but it can operate outside them. A documented equipment or regulatory limitation can also be an exception under R3, as long as it is communicated.
Who asks for the protection settings?
The Planning Coordinator or Transmission Planner can request the settings. Under R4 the owner provides them within 60 calendar days of a written request.