Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Codes and grid connection: US, UK, CA, AU

NERC PRC-019: Voltage Control and Limiter Coordination

NERC PRC-019 asks owners to coordinate excitation limiters with generator protection. See how the coordination works, with a worked timing margin example.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

busGgenerator=~exciterIffield currentfield overloadrelayoverexcitationlimiterreduces fieldtripacts at 20 sacts at 12 sPower / fieldMeasure / controllimiter 12 s, relay 20 s at 1.40 puslowest limiter: 12 x 1.05 = 12.6 sfastest relay: 20 x 0.95 = 19.0 smargin 19.0 - 12.6 = 6.4 s: limiter firstif capability is 10 s, both are too slowfield current (pu)t (s)1.201.401.60102040limiter (qualitative shape)relay (qualitative shape)6.4 sexample capability 10 sillustrative valuesCoordinationField currentLimiterRelayMarginCapability© tizagrp.combusGgenerator=~exciterIffield currentfield overloadrelayoverexcitationlimiterreduces fieldtripacts at 20 sacts at 12 sPower / fieldMeasure / controllimiter 12 s, relay 20 s at 1.40 puslowest limiter: 12 x 1.05 = 12.6 sfastest relay: 20 x 0.95 = 19.0 smargin 19.0 - 12.6 = 6.4 s: limiter firstif capability is 10 s, both are too slowfield current (pu)t (s)1.201.401.60102040limiter (qualitative shape)relay (qualitative shape)6.4 sexample capability 10 sillustrative valuesCoordinationField currentLimiterRelayMarginCapability© tizagrp.com
NERC PRC-019: a generator with its exciter, the field current measurement, the overexcitation limiter and the field overload relay, and the time-current plot at 1.40 per unit where the limiter acts at 12 s and the relay at 20 s. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

NERC PRC-019 requires owners of generators and synchronous condensers to coordinate the voltage regulating controls, including excitation limiters, with the equipment capability and the protection settings. The limiter must act before the protection so a disturbance does not remove the unit. The coordination is repeated at least every five calendar years and within 90 calendar days after a relevant change.

Short answer

NERC PRC-019, a standard of the North American Electric Reliability Corporation (NERC), is about one simple idea. When the grid pushes a generator hard, the excitation controls should limit the unit within its capability before the protective relays trip it. The standard asks owners to coordinate voltage regulating controls, including limiters and protection functions, with the capability of the equipment.

The version in force is PRC-019-2. It applies to Generator Owners (GO) and to Transmission Owners (TO) with synchronous condensers. NERC Project 2021-01 is reviewing PRC-019 together with MOD-025, so check NERC’s standards page for any newer version. The wider framework is in the US electrical codes and grid interconnection guide.

The pieces being coordinated

Three groups of settings must fit together:

  1. Equipment capability. The machine’s capability curve, the field thermal limit and the stator limits.
  2. Control settings. The automatic voltage regulator and its limiters: overexcitation (OEL), underexcitation (UEL) and volts-per-hertz limiters.
  3. Protection settings. The relay functions that detect the same conditions: field overload, loss of excitation (40), overvoltage (59) and volts-per-hertz (24).

The right order of action on a rising condition is: control acts first, limiter second, protection last. That order keeps the unit online through an event the equipment can ride out. The guide on synchronous generator protection describes the protection functions, and AVR tests explains how the regulator and limiters are tested.

Why the standard exists

Disturbances revealed generators that tripped because a relay was faster than the limiter. The unit went offline just when the system needed reactive support. PRC-019 makes the owner show on paper that the order is correct, and keep that record current.

It also links to ride-through. A generator that must stay online under PRC-024 cannot have an excitation limiter that fights it.

What the owner documents

  • The capability data of the machine and the exciter.
  • The settings of each limiter and its timing.
  • The settings of the related protection functions.
  • A coordination plot or table showing the order of action.
  • The date of verification and what triggered it.

R1 sets a cycle of at least every five calendar years. Under R2, a change in the regulator, the protection, the equipment capability or the step-up transformer triggers a new coordination within 90 calendar days.

Worked example (illustrative)

All numbers are illustrative assumptions. The real curves come from the machine, exciter and relay data.

Assumptions. At an overload of 1.40 per unit field current, the overexcitation limiter reduces the field after 12 seconds. The field overload relay trips at 20 seconds for the same current. Both timers have a tolerance of 5 percent.

Step 1. Slowest limiter action. 12 × 1.05 = 12.6 seconds.

Step 2. Fastest relay action. 20 × 0.95 = 19.0 seconds.

Step 3. Margin. 19.0 − 12.6 = 6.4 seconds. The limiter acts first even in the worst case.

Step 4. Check the capability. If the machine thermal limit at 1.40 per unit allows only 10 seconds, the limiter time of 12.6 seconds is too slow. The relay at 19.0 seconds would not protect the machine either. Both settings move below 10 seconds, with the limiter still acting first. The coordination must hold against the capability too.

Step 5. Record. The result is a short table: limiter time, relay time, margin and the capability limit.

Common mistakes

Using a generic curve instead of the machine’s. Thermal limits are specific to the machine. A curve from another unit or from a textbook can be far from the real capability, and a coordination built on it gives false comfort.

Forgetting tolerances. Limiter and relay timers have tolerances, and so do the measuring chains. A coordination that works on nominal values and fails at the extremes is not a coordination. Always check with the worst case.

Treating the limiter as a safety device. The limiter is a control function. It depends on the regulator being in service. If the regulator is in manual mode or has failed, the limiter may not act, and the protection is the only thing left. The settings of the protection must still protect the machine in that case.

Not retesting after a change. A new firmware version for the regulator or a changed gain can change the limiter’s response. The same applies to a relay replacement. Each change should trigger a check of the coordination.

Keeping the documents apart. The excitation settings are held by one group and the relay settings by another. The coordination needs both on one page. Put the data in a single record with a clear owner.

Related functions are explained in generator unit configurations and their protection.

Reading the result

A coordination result is only as good as its inputs, so keep the inputs visible. For each condition, the record should show the machine limit, the limiter pickup and delay, the relay pickup and delay, and the tolerance applied to each. A reviewer should be able to rebuild the margin in a few minutes without calling the person who made it.

When the margin is thin, there are three honest options: slow the relay, speed the limiter, or document why the margin is acceptable for that machine. Changing a relay time delay can also affect its coordination with downstream protection, so check that side as well before accepting the change.

Checklist for the engineer

  • Collect the machine capability curve and the exciter documentation.
  • List every limiter and every protection function that responds to the same condition.
  • Read the current PRC-019 text on NERC’s site.
  • Plot or tabulate the order of action, with tolerances.
  • Confirm the limiter acts inside the equipment capability.
  • Test the limiters with the regulator, not only with a simulation.
  • Record the verification date and who performed it.
  • Repeat after changes in the regulator, exciter or relay settings.

Who signs and seals

In the United States, protection and control design is normally signed and sealed by a professional engineer licensed in the state of the project. Our work is delivered ready for your engineer of record to review and stamp. Tiza does not sign, seal or certify work in the United States. Compliance with a NERC standard stays with the registered owner; our studies support its analysis and evidence.

How Tiza can help

If your generator needs its relay settings coordinated with the excitation limiters, Tiza provides remote relay configuration and settings plans in English, ready for your engineer of record to review and stamp. Contact us with the capability curve, the limiter settings and the relay settings.

Figure: time-current plot of the limiter action, the relay action and the machine thermal limit.

Frequently asked questions

What does coordinating a limiter with protection mean?

It means the limiter, for example an overexcitation limiter, reaches its action before the protective relay on the same condition. If the relay were faster, the unit would trip where the control could have held it within capability.

How often is the coordination checked?

In PRC-019-2, R1 asks for the coordination at least every five calendar years. R2 asks for it again within 90 calendar days after a change that affects it, such as new regulator, protection or step-up transformer settings or equipment.

Is this a relay setting exercise or a controls exercise?

Both. The relay settings come from protection engineering, the limiter settings from the excitation system, and PRC-019 asks the owner to show that the two fit together and sit inside the equipment capability.

WhatsApp