NERC PRC-023 requires transmission owners, generator owners and distribution providers to set phase protective relays on transmission circuits so they do not limit loadability. R1 gives a list of criteria, evaluated at 0.85 per unit voltage and a 30 degree power factor angle, and the owner applies one for each circuit terminal.
Short answer
NERC PRC-023, the transmission relay loadability standard of the North American Electric Reliability Corporation (NERC), stops line relays from tripping on a heavy but healthy load. The 2003 blackout showed how distance relays reading depressed voltage and high current as a fault can cascade. PRC-023 limits how far a relay’s settings may reach into the load region.
The version in force is PRC-023-6. NERC filed it with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) in 2023. FERC’s Office of Electric Reliability approved it in January 2024, in docket RD23-5, and it replaced PRC-023-5. Confirm the phase-in on NERC’s standards page. The wider framework is in the US electrical codes and grid interconnection guide, and the generator counterpart is PRC-025.
What R1 asks
R1 applies to Transmission Owners (TO), Generator Owners (GO) and Distribution Providers (DP). For each circuit terminal, the owner uses one of the criteria listed in R1, so that phase protective relay settings do not limit transmission loadability. Relays are evaluated at 0.85 per unit voltage and a power factor angle of 30 degrees.
The criteria cover different situations. Some keep the relay from operating at a multiple of the circuit’s facility rating, for example a multiple of the four-hour rating or a smaller multiple of the 15-minute rating. Others address transformers, weak sources or load-center circuits. The owner picks the one that fits the circuit and documents the choice.
The guide on CTs for distance protection and the one on line fault analysis explain the relay and the signals behind these criteria.
The load region on the R-X plane
A distance relay sees an impedance. A heavy load at depressed voltage appears as a point at a modest magnitude and an angle near the load power factor. If the relay characteristic reaches that point, the relay can trip on load.
The standard tells the owner to keep the characteristic clear of the load point defined by the criterion. The simplest way is to limit the reach in the direction of the load. With a mho circle, the direction of the load is at an angle from the maximum torque angle, and the reach in that direction is smaller than the nominal reach.
Worked example (illustrative)
All numbers are illustrative assumptions. The right criterion and rating come from your circuit and from R1.
Assumptions. A 230 kV line has a four-hour rating of 800 A. The chosen criterion keeps the relay from operating at 150 percent of that rating. Evaluate at 0.85 per unit voltage. The mho relay has a maximum torque angle of 75 degrees, and the load angle is 30 degrees.
Step 1. Current at the criterion. 1.5 × 800 = 1,200 A.
Step 2. Voltage. 0.85 × 230 kV = 195.5 kV line to line.
Step 3. Load impedance. 195,500 ÷ (1.732 × 1,200) = 94.06 ohms primary.
Step 4. Reach in the load direction. For a mho circle, the reach at an angle is the nominal reach times cos(75 − 30) = 0.7071.
Step 5. Maximum nominal reach. 94.06 ÷ 0.7071 = 133.0 ohms primary. A zone 3 reach above 133 ohms would pick up inside the load region at this stress level.
Step 6. Convert for the relay. With CT 1,200 to 5 and VT 2,000 to 1, the ratio is 240 ÷ 2,000 = 0.12, so 133.0 ohms primary is 15.96 ohms secondary.
Check the result against the line length and the remote-end coverage. If the line is long, the reach limit may mean using a load encroachment function or another criterion.
Why it matters in practice
Relay loadability problems tend to appear on long lines, on lines that gain load after a system change, and on circuits whose rating was upgraded. The settings were right on the day they were set, and the circuit rating changed later. Keep the rating and the settings linked, so any rating change triggers a loadability check.
Common mistakes
Setting zone 3 from the line impedance alone. A third zone is often set as a multiple of the line impedance and then never checked against load. On a long line the load impedance can be close to that reach. The loadability check is the step that catches it.
Using the wrong rating. The criteria refer to the facility rating, which is the lowest rating of the elements in the circuit, such as the conductor, the terminal equipment and the current transformer. A rating taken only from the conductor can be higher than the rating that governs.
Mixing units. Impedances in primary ohms, secondary ohms and per unit are easy to confuse. Write the base next to each value, and keep the CT and VT ratios in the same table as the result.
Skipping the reach in the load direction. With a mho characteristic the reach in the load direction is smaller than the nominal reach. With a quadrilateral characteristic the resistive reach and the load encroachment settings play the role instead. Know which one your relay uses.
Forgetting the rating change. A line is often reconductored or its rating is raised after a study. The relay settings were derived from the old rating, and the check has to be repeated for the new one.
The relay and its inputs are covered in the guide on CTs for distance protection, and the generator-side counterpart of this standard is PRC-025.
Checklist for the engineer
- List every transmission circuit terminal in scope.
- Read the current PRC-023 text and implementation plan on NERC’s site.
- Record the facility rating for each circuit and its source.
- Choose the R1 criterion for each terminal and document the reason.
- Compute pickup or reach at 0.85 per unit voltage and 30 degrees.
- Convert to relay secondary values with the correct CT and VT ratios.
- Check coverage of the remote end and coordination with neighbors.
- Repeat when a rating, CT or relay changes.
Who signs and seals
In the United States, protection design is normally signed and sealed by a professional engineer licensed in the state of the project. Our work is delivered ready for your engineer of record to review and stamp. Tiza does not sign, seal or certify work in the United States. Compliance with a NERC standard stays with the registered owner; our studies support its analysis and evidence.
How Tiza can help
If your line relays need settings calculated and checked against the loadability criteria, Tiza provides remote relay configuration and settings plans in English, ready for your engineer of record to review and stamp. Contact us with the line data, facility ratings and relay settings.
Figure: R-X diagram with the mho characteristic, the load region at 0.85 per unit voltage and the maximum reach.
Frequently asked questions
Why does the standard use 0.85 per unit voltage?
Heavy loading often happens when voltage is depressed, and a low voltage turns the same load into a smaller impedance that a distance relay may mistake for a fault. The standard evaluates relays at 0.85 per unit voltage and a 30 degree power factor angle to represent that stressed condition.
Does the owner have to use one criterion for all circuits?
No. R1 lets the owner use any one of the listed criteria for each circuit terminal. The choice depends on the type of relay, the circuit and the system conditions, for example a weak source or a load center.
Does PRC-023 replace line protection coordination?
No. It sets a ceiling on how far the settings may reach in the load direction. Coordination with neighboring relays, fault sensitivity and clearing time are still design requirements.