NERC PRC-025-2 requires generator owners, transmission owners and distribution providers to set load-responsive protective relays on generator-connected facilities so they do not trip during heavy but valid loading, following the settings in Attachment 1. The aim is that relays trip for faults and not for stressed-but-recoverable system conditions.
Short answer
NERC PRC-025 is the generator relay loadability standard of the North American Electric Reliability Corporation (NERC). A load-responsive relay can mistake a heavy but valid load for a fault, and a generator tripping at the wrong moment makes a stressed system worse. PRC-025-2 asks owners to set these relays in line with Attachment 1, so they have margin above the loading the generator may carry.
The standard applies to Generator Owners (GO), Transmission Owners (TO) and Distribution Providers (DP) for the circuits it covers. The version in force is PRC-025-2, effective since 1 July 2018. Check NERC’s standards page for any later version. The wider framework is in the US electrical codes and grid interconnection guide, and its transmission-line counterpart is in our PRC-023 guide.
What R1 asks
R1 is the working requirement. Each owner applies settings in line with Attachment 1 for its load-responsive protective relays, while keeping reliable fault protection. Attachment 1 contains Table 1, with setting criteria by relay type and by application, often with more than one option per case. Each option states what the setting must stay above, and which data the engineer must use, for example the generator rating or a calculated maximum. For a synchronous unit, the options start from the gross MW capability reported to the Transmission Planner and a reactive output, at a bus voltage the option specifies.
The implementation plan allowed time for relay changes, with longer periods when relay replacement was needed. Use the plan text for the dates that apply.
Which relays are involved
On a generator circuit, the typical elements are phase distance (21), phase time overcurrent with voltage control or restraint (51V-C and 51V-R) and other phase overcurrent elements. Each can pick up on load in some operating state. Attachment 1 also lists exclusions, such as elements in service only during start-up. The guide on generator protection lists these functions, and the base data for generator settings shows the nameplate and capability data they need.
PRC-025 is also tied to ride-through. A relay that cannot carry the loading during a disturbance forces the unit offline, which PRC-024 is trying to prevent.
The design pattern
- Find the maximum loading the generator can carry, from its capability curve and nameplate.
- Choose the Attachment 1 option for the relay function.
- Compute the minimum pickup the option requires.
- Check that the relay can still see the faults it must see. Protection cannot become blind in order to pass the loadability test.
- Record the option, the inputs and the result.
Step 4 is where engineering judgment lives. If the loadability limit and the fault sensitivity conflict, the owner may need another option, another relay function or a different element.
Worked example (illustrative)
Illustrative data and a simplified criterion. Attachment 1 has no option of this form: its options are built from the unit’s real and reactive power at a specified voltage.
Assumptions. A generator is rated 100 MVA at 13.8 kV. For this exercise only, suppose the phase overcurrent pickup must be at least 150 percent of rated current. The current transformer ratio is 6,000 to 5, which is 1,200 to 1.
Step 1. Rated current. 100,000 kVA ÷ (1.732 × 13.8 kV) = 4,183.7 A.
Step 2. Minimum pickup. 1.5 × 4,183.7 = 6,275.6 A primary.
Step 3. In relay terms. 6,275.6 ÷ 1,200 = 5.23 A secondary.
Step 4. Choose the setting. A relay setting of 5.5 A secondary equals 5.5 × 1,200 = 6,600 A primary, which is above the 6,275.6 A minimum. The margin is 6,600 − 6,275.6 = 324.4 A.
Step 5. Check sensitivity. Compare 6,600 A with the fault current the relay must detect at the remote end. If the minimum fault current were below that value, the element would not see the fault, and another function would have to cover it.
Common mistakes
Mixing primary and secondary values. The criterion is written in primary quantities, and the relay is set in secondary. A wrong CT ratio produces a setting that looks right and is not. Show both values in the calculation.
Using the wrong rating. The generator rating that governs the criterion may differ from the nameplate, for example when the unit is derated or has a different rating at a different temperature. Document which rating the calculation uses and where it comes from.
Passing loadability and losing sensitivity. Raising a pickup to satisfy the criterion can leave the relay unable to see a remote fault. The owner has to check both, and, where they conflict, choose another option or another function. Never solve the conflict by ignoring one side.
Forgetting the step-up transformer. The criteria apply to relays on the generator and on the step-up transformer circuit. Each has its own current base, and the transformer ratio changes the values between them.
Not repeating the check. The calculation is valid for a rating, a CT and a relay. When any of these changes, repeat it. A problem can appear years later, when someone changes a CT and does not revisit the settings.
For the data used in these calculations, see the guide on base data for generator protection settings.
Reading the result
The finished calculation should let a reviewer see, on one page, which Attachment 1 option was used, which rating and which CT ratio entered the formula, the minimum pickup that results, and the value actually set. It should also show the fault current the relay is expected to detect and the margin against the pickup.
If you inherit settings from a previous owner or a previous relay, do not assume they were checked for loadability. The standard asks for evidence, so recompute and keep the record with the settings file. A short, clear calculation sheet is easier to audit than a long report.
Checklist for the engineer
- List every load-responsive relay on each generator and step-up circuit.
- Read the current PRC-025 text, Attachment 1 and implementation plan on NERC’s site.
- Gather ratings and capability data for the machine and the transformer.
- Choose and record an option for each relay.
- Calculate the pickup, including CT ratio and relay units.
- Verify that fault sensitivity remains adequate.
- Keep the calculation with the settings file and relay model.
- Recheck after any rating, CT or relay change.
Who signs and seals
In the United States, protection design is normally signed and sealed by a professional engineer licensed in the state of the project. Our work is delivered ready for your engineer of record to review and stamp. Tiza does not sign, seal or certify work in the United States. Compliance with a NERC standard stays with the registered owner; our studies support its analysis and evidence.
How Tiza can help
If your generator relays need settings calculated against the loadability criteria, Tiza provides remote relay configuration and settings plans in English, ready for your engineer of record to review and stamp. Contact us with the relay settings, CT ratios and unit capability data.
Figure: single-line diagram of a generator and step-up transformer with the load-responsive relays marked.
Frequently asked questions
What is a load-responsive relay?
A relay that operates on current, impedance or a related quantity that rises with load, such as phase distance, phase overcurrent and voltage-controlled or voltage-restrained overcurrent elements. PRC-025 targets these because a high load can look like a fault to them.
Do I choose how to meet Attachment 1?
Yes. Attachment 1 contains a table of setting criteria with several options for each relay type. The owner chooses an option that fits the equipment and applies its criterion with the data it requires.
Is PRC-025 the same as PRC-023?
No. PRC-023 covers relays on transmission lines and some transformers. PRC-025 covers relays on generator and generator step-up transformer circuits. The idea is the same, but the setting criteria differ.