Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Codes and grid connection: US, UK, CA, AU

NEC 240.87 Arc Energy Reduction: Methods and Studies

NEC 240.87 requires arc energy reduction on circuit breakers of 1,200 A or more. See the methods, testing and documentation, with a clearing-time example.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

480 V source1,600 A main breakerCT480 V busZSI restraint lineprotectionrelaymaintenanceswitchstatusPowerProtection and controlarc power: 200 V x 20 kA = 4.0 MW0.5 s: 4.0 MW x 0.5 s = 2.0 MJ0.05 s: 4.0 MW x 0.05 s = 0.2 MJratio 2.0 / 0.2 = 10: one tentharc energy (MJ)2.0 MJ0.2 MJ0.5 s, as set0.05 s, maintenance switchcheck: setting below the lowest arcing currentReductionArcing currentMaintenance switchRelayTripArc energy© tizagrp.com480 V source1,600 A main breakerCT480 V busZSI restraint lineprotectionrelaymaintenanceswitchstatusPowerProtection and controlarc power: 200 V x 20 kA = 4.0 MW0.5 s: 4.0 MW x 0.5 s = 2.0 MJ0.05 s: 4.0 MW x 0.05 s = 0.2 MJratio 2.0 / 0.2 = 10: one tentharc energy (MJ)2.0 MJ0.2 MJ0.5 s, as set0.05 s, maintenance switchcheck: setting below the lowest arcing currentReductionArcing currentMaintenance switchRelayTripArc energy© tizagrp.com
NEC 240.87 on a 1,600 A main breaker: current transformer, protection relay and trip, maintenance switch with its status indicator and the zone-selective interlocking line, and the arc energy at two clearing times. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

NEC 240.87 applies to circuit breakers rated or adjustable to 1,200 A or higher. It requires the installation to use a method that reduces the arc energy during a fault, such as zone-selective interlocking, differential relaying, an energy-reducing maintenance switch or an active arc flash mitigation system. The method must be documented and performance tested on site.

The larger the breaker, the longer the arc can last before it trips. A large breaker is set to ride through downstream faults without opening, and that same delay is what lets an arc in the equipment burn longer. NEC 240.87 asks the designer to deal with that delay.

Section numbers in this guide follow the 2023 edition of the NEC (NFPA 70). NFPA issued the 2026 edition in 2025. Many jurisdictions still enforce an earlier edition, so confirm the edition and local amendments adopted where you build.

Short answer

NEC 240.87 is the arc energy reduction requirement for circuit breakers. It applies to a breaker whose highest continuous trip setting is, or can be set to, 1,200 A or higher. For these breakers, the installation must use an approved method that reduces the clearing time or the arc energy during a fault. The method is documented, and the arc energy reduction system is performance tested on site by primary current injection or another approved method when first installed. A similar requirement for fuses is in 240.67.

Figure: a main breaker with a protection relay and a maintenance switch, with a signal from the relay to the breaker trip coil.

The wider framework is in the US electrical codes and grid interconnection guide. The general overcurrent rules are in the guide on NEC Article 240.

Why large breakers need it

A main breaker protects the whole switchboard, and it is set to coordinate with the devices downstream. Coordination means the main waits while a downstream device clears a fault. That wait is useful for service continuity. It is a problem when the fault is inside the switchboard on the line side of the downstream devices, because nothing downstream can clear it. Then the main breaker is the only device that can open, and its time delay applies in full.

An arc releases energy in proportion to the arcing current and the time it lasts. A fault that a smaller breaker clears in a few cycles may last half a second on a large breaker set for coordination. The energy, and the burns and damage it can cause, rise accordingly.

The methods

The section lists several methods. They include:

  • Zone-selective interlocking. The breakers communicate. A downstream device that sees the fault tells the upstream device to wait. A device that sees the fault and receives no restraint signal trips with no intentional delay.
  • Differential relaying. A relay compares the current into and out of a protected zone and trips quickly for an internal fault.
  • An energy-reducing maintenance switch. A switch, with a local status indicator, that puts the breaker on a fast setting while people work on the equipment.
  • An energy-reducing active arc flash mitigation system. A system that senses the arc and acts to cut it short.
  • A permanent instantaneous setting or an instantaneous override set below the available arcing current, or an approved equivalent means.

The right method depends on the equipment, the coordination needs and who works on it. The maintenance switch protects maintenance workers but gives no benefit when it is off. An interlocking scheme works all the time but needs wiring and testing. The guide on how to reduce arc flash incident energy compares the options from the point of view of the study.

Documentation and testing

The section expects the method to be documented and marked so that people working on the equipment know which one is in place and how it works. The arc energy reduction system must be performance tested when first installed on site. A study of the results, with the arcing currents and clearing times the system gives, supports the documentation. The guide on arc flash PPE categories explains how incident energy turns into protective-equipment levels, and the guide on NFPA 70B covers how maintenance keeps the method working.

Worked example

Illustrative data and a deliberate simplification, not a calculation under a standard. A 1,600 A breaker feeds a 480 V switchboard. Assume an arcing current of 20 kA and an arc voltage of 200 V.

  1. Arc power: 200 V x 20,000 A = 4.0 MW.
  2. Without a reduction method, the breaker is set to coordinate and clears the arcing fault in 0.5 s. Arc energy: 4.0 MW x 0.5 s = 2.0 MJ.
  3. With a maintenance switch that puts the breaker on a fast setting, assume clearing in 0.05 s. Arc energy: 4.0 MW x 0.05 s = 0.2 MJ.
  4. The ratio is 2.0 MJ / 0.2 MJ = 10. The arc energy falls to one tenth, because the arcing current is the same and the time is ten times shorter.

The incident energy at a worker’s position depends on distance, enclosure and electrode configuration, which an arc flash study calculates with the method in IEEE 1584. The simple ratio shows why clearing time is the lever. One caution: the fast setting may let the arcing current fall below the instantaneous pickup, in which case the breaker does not trip fast. The designer must check that the setting is below the lowest expected arcing current.

Common mistakes

  • Assuming a breaker below 1,200 A at its present setting is outside the rule when its trip unit can be adjusted higher.
  • Choosing a maintenance switch and leaving it with no label or status indicator.
  • Setting the fast mode above the minimum arcing current, so it never trips fast.
  • Using a temporary adjustment during work as the compliance method.
  • Treating the study label as proof that the method works.
  • Not performance testing the system when first installed.

Checklist for the engineer

  • Identify the NEC edition and local amendments the authority enforces.
  • List every breaker rated or adjustable to 1,200 A or higher, and every fuse of that size.
  • Choose a method for each one and record why.
  • Check the method against the minimum and maximum arcing current from the study.
  • Confirm the indicator, labeling and documentation that tell workers which method is in place.
  • Specify the on-site performance test of the system, with the injection method.
  • Update the arc flash study and labels with the clearing times that the method gives.
  • Keep the settings and test records with the drawings.

Who signs and seals

An arc flash study and the design that depends on it are normally signed and sealed by a professional engineer licensed in the state of the project. Tiza delivers studies ready for your engineer of record to review and stamp. Tiza does not sign, seal or certify work in the United States.

How Tiza can help

If your switchboard needs an arc energy reduction method chosen and justified, Tiza delivers power-system studies ready for your engineer of record to review and stamp. They include short-circuit and arc flash analysis, delivered remotely and in English. Send us the single-line diagram and the breaker data, and we will scope the work with you. Contact us to start.

Frequently asked questions

Which circuit breakers does NEC 240.87 apply to?

It applies to circuit breakers whose highest continuous trip setting is, or can be adjusted to, 1,200 A or higher. Fuses at that size fall under the parallel section, 240.67.

Is an arc flash study the same as a 240.87 method?

No. A study calculates incident energy so the equipment can be labeled and the protective choices evaluated. Section 240.87 requires a method that reduces the arc energy at the breaker. They support each other, but one does not replace the other. The study can show whether the chosen method gives a useful result.

Can I lower the instantaneous trip setting temporarily instead?

Temporarily adjusting the setting during work does not meet the intent of the requirement and is not accepted as the compliance method. The chosen method must be permanent, documented and available when needed. Ask the authority and the manufacturer how a maintenance setting is controlled.

WhatsApp