Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Equipment, switchboards and substations

Upgrade or Replace an LV Switchboard: How to Decide

When to upgrade an existing low-voltage switchboard and when to replace it: current, short circuit, spares and safety, with a worked example.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

MT/BTGinterlockATSLV busMMfeederCCMauxiliariesbusesUF 1UF 2UF 3term.Form 1no partitionsForm 2separate busbarsForm 3separate unitsForm 4separate terminalsIEC 61439-2: forms of internal separationIntegrationLSIG unitGatewaySCADA© tizagrp.comMT/BTGinterlockATSLV busMMfeederCCMauxiliariesbusesUF 1UF 2UF 3term.Form 1no partitionsForm 2separate busbarsForm 3separate unitsForm 4separate terminalsIEC 61439-2: forms of internal separationIntegrationLSIG unitGatewaySCADA© tizagrp.com
LV switchboard and MCC: automatic transfer and forms of separation. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

Upgrading a switchboard makes sense when the enclosure, the busbars and the partitions withstand the future current and short circuit, and only the devices are at the end of their life. If the prospective fault exceeds the strength of the assembly or the busbar is not enough, changing devices does not solve the problem and the right decision is a new switchboard.

Short answer

The question of upgrading a switchboard or replacing it is answered with two numbers: the current the assembly must carry and the short-circuit current it must withstand, both in the future scenario, not the present one. If the busbar and the short-circuit strength are enough, upgrading (replacing or extending devices, protection and control) is usually quicker and cheaper. If either one falls short, changing breakers does not correct the defect and the switchboard is replaced.

It is one of the decisions taken before specifying an LV switchboard before ordering.

What to check

AspectQuestionWhere to look
CurrentDoes the main busbar carry the future current within the temperature-rise limits?Nameplate, drawings and original verification; rated current
Short circuitDoes the assembly withstand the future fault (Icw, Ipk, Icc)?Nameplate and short-circuit study; Icw, Ipk and Icc
Physical conditionIs there corrosion, moisture, degraded insulation, hot spots?Inspection and thermography
DevicesAre spares and support available for the present breakers and relays?Device manufacturer
SafetyDo the partitions, the IP degree and the operations protect the operator?Protection against electric shock and IP degree
DocumentationDo drawings and verifications of the assembly exist?Project file
OutageHow long can the installation be out of service?Operating plan

Decision tree

Upgrade or replace the existing switchboard
  • Does the assembly withstand the future short circuit (Icw and Ipk)?
    • Yes: Does the main busbar carry the future current within temperature-rise limits?
      • Yes: Are spares and support available for the devices, and is the physical condition good?
        • Yes: Upgrade: replace or extend devices, protection and control
        • No: Replace the switchboard: the cost of keeping what exists is higher
      • No: Replace the switchboard or add a new section with its own busbar
    • No: Can the prospective fault at the site be reduced?
      • Yes: Check with a study whether the reduction is enough; if not, replace the switchboard
      • No: Replace the switchboard: no change of devices corrects the strength

Worked example: the transformer grows

A plant has a main switchboard at 480 V with a 1,600 A busbar and 25 kA Icw (1 s) according to its nameplate. Today it is fed from a 1,000 kVA transformer with 6 % impedance and the maximum measured load is 1,250 A. The plan is to extend the plant with 400 A more and move to a 1,600 kVA transformer, 6 %.

Current.

  • Future: 1,250 + 400 = 1,650 A, higher than the 1,600 A busbar. With the real diversity factor it can be checked whether the busbar is enough at simultaneity, but there is no margin.

Short circuit (infinite source, conservative value).

  • Today: 1,000 kVA, In = 1,203 A; Icc = 1,203 / 0.06 = 20.0 kA, below the 25 kA of the assembly.
  • Future: 1,600 kVA, In = 1,925 A; Icc = 1,925 / 0.06 = 32.1 kA, above the 25 kA.

The result is that replacing the outgoing breakers with larger ones does not help: the assembly does not withstand the future fault and the busbar has no margin. The decision is a new switchboard, or limiting the fault or the transformer rating to a value the assembly can withstand, as confirmed by the short-circuit study.

Upgrading properly

When the decision is to upgrade:

  • Respect what was verified. A change of devices or arrangement can alter temperature rise and short-circuit strength. IEC 61439-1 asks to check with clause 10 whether the modification affects performance and to repeat the verifications if an adverse effect is likely. Who takes that verification on is explained in original manufacturer and assembly manufacturer.
  • Use kits and devices foreseen by the system manufacturer when they exist, because they come with their verification.
  • Update the documentation: drawings, nameplate and records of the modified part.
  • Test again what changed: commissioning of electrical panels and MCCs.
  • Check certification requirements with the manufacturer and the applicable body before intervening.

When a new switchboard is better, besides the two numbers: insufficient partitions to work safely, corrosion of the structure, lack of spares for the devices and a total lack of documentation.

Upgrading without stopping the whole plant

The outage is often the real constraint. Some ways to reduce it, to be agreed with operations and with whoever carries out the work:

  • By sections. If the switchboard has independent columns with separate busbars, one is worked on at a time.
  • Temporary supply. A temporary source (another switchboard or an emergency generator) holds the critical loads during the change.
  • Maintenance windows. Long operations are done in scheduled shutdowns.
  • Tests before energizing. Each new part is tested out of service, and re-energization follows the commissioning protocol.

If the only way to upgrade requires a longer outage than acceptable, a new switchboard installed alongside and switched over in a single operation can be the lowest-risk option, even if it costs more.

Checklist

  • Future current measured and projected.
  • Future short circuit calculated with the final transformer.
  • Nameplate and verifications of the existing switchboard.
  • Physical and thermal condition inspected.
  • Spares and support confirmed.
  • Acceptable outage time.
  • Who takes on the verification of the modification.

How we can help

At Tiza Group we prepare the engineering for the upgrade or replacement of low-voltage switchboards: short-circuit study, capacity check of the existing assembly and design review. See our primary engineering service and send us your nameplate, single-line diagram and measured load so we can quote the scope.

References

  • IEC 61439-1:2020, Low-voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies: general rules (clauses 5.3, 10 and 11).
  • IEC 61439-2:2020, Power switchgear and controlgear assemblies.

Frequently asked questions

What does upgrading a switchboard mean?

Keeping the enclosure, busbars and structure, and replacing or extending what is at the end of its life or insufficient: breakers, trip units, relays, meters, control wiring. It is used when the structure still meets what the installation requires.

Can I replace a breaker with a larger one in the same switchboard?

Only if the switchboard allows it. Short-circuit strength, temperature rise and clearances were verified for certain devices and arrangements. IEC 61439-1 asks to check with clause 10 whether a change affects performance, and to repeat the verification if an adverse effect is likely.

Who takes responsibility for the verification of a modified switchboard?

Whoever modifies it must take it on, or the original manufacturer must confirm that the change stays within the verified design. Agree it in writing before the work starts, and update the nameplate and the records of the modified part.

WhatsApp