Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Equipment, switchboards and substations

Withdrawable MCC: When Drawers Pay Off and How to Choose

How an MCC with withdrawable drawers works, what interlocks it needs and when it beats fixed units. Includes a worked example of lost service hours.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

MT/BTGinterlockATSLV busMMfeederCCMauxiliariesbusesUF 1UF 2UF 3term.Form 1no partitionsForm 2separate busbarsForm 3separate unitsForm 4separate terminalsIEC 61439-2: forms of internal separationIntegrationLSIG unitGatewaySCADA© tizagrp.comMT/BTGinterlockATSLV busMMfeederCCMauxiliariesbusesUF 1UF 2UF 3term.Form 1no partitionsForm 2separate busbarsForm 3separate unitsForm 4separate terminalsIEC 61439-2: forms of internal separationIntegrationLSIG unitGatewaySCADA© tizagrp.com
LV switchboard and MCC: automatic transfer and forms of separation. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

In an MCC with withdrawable drawers each starter sits in a drawer that is removed and replaced without de-energizing the busbar. That service-continuity benefit costs space and construction, and requires interlocks that prevent withdrawing or inserting the drawer with the load connected.

Short answer

An MCC with withdrawable drawers is a motor control center where each starter is in a drawer that is removed and replaced without de-energizing the assembly busbar. It pays off when stopping a section costs more than the extra cost of withdrawable construction, and when a starter must be replaced quickly. It is chosen with one question: how much is it worth to keep the rest of the MCC in service while one unit is worked on?

The structure and busbar of an MCC, fixed or withdrawable, are in conventional low-voltage MCC. The definitions of fixed and removable parts are in fixed, disconnectable and withdrawable parts. The family context is in the parent guide, types of electrical switchboards.

What a withdrawable drawer is like

  • Drawer on its own carrier holding the breaker or motor circuit breaker, contactor, overload relay and control transformer.
  • Power plug-in contacts taking current from the vertical bus, and control contacts carrying signals to the field terminal.
  • Drawer positions: connected, test (power disconnected, control connected) and disconnected or removed.
  • Breaker interlock: the drawer cannot move with the breaker closed, and the breaker cannot close with the drawer part-way.
  • Insertion interlock: prevents a drawer from being put into a compartment not intended for it.
  • Shutters covering the vertical bus contacts when the drawer is removed.
  • Door interlocked with the breaker, so it cannot open with the drawer energized, except through a controlled override.
  • Replacement capability: drawers of the same size are interchangeable, which allows a spare to be kept.

IEC 61439-1 requires a removable part to have a device that allows it to be withdrawn or inserted only after its main circuit has been opened with respect to the load. The same standard gives the name insertion interlock to a different device: the one that prevents the part from being put into a location not intended for it. The mechanical operation of removable parts, including that interlock, is checked by a test in the design verification.

Fixed, plug-in or withdrawable

CriterionFixedPlug-in (disconnectable)Withdrawable
InterventionDe-energize the sectionDe-energize the section or partWith the busbar energized
Replacement timeLongMediumShort
SpaceSmallerMediumLarger
ComplexityLowMediumHigh
Control test with power openNoLimitedYes, in test position
Typical useProcesses that can stopIntermediate serviceContinuous processes

Worked example: lost service hours

Assumed data to illustrate the decision; not from a real project. An MCC has 14 units spread over three sections; a contactor is replaced in a section of six units.

OptionWhat is de-energizedDurationUnit-hours out of service
Fixed unitsThe whole section, 6 units2 h6 × 2 = 12 h
Withdrawable drawerOnly the unit worked on0.5 h1 × 0.5 = 0.5 h

The difference is 11.5 unit-hours out of service per intervention. If the cost of one hour of downtime for those six loads is high, the withdrawable MCC is justified; if the process stops anyway for scheduled maintenance, the extra cost is not recovered. The calculation is made with real plant data: how many interventions are expected per year and what each hour of downtime is worth.

What to verify when specifying

  1. Interlocks: breaker, door and insertion. Ask for them to be described in writing.
  2. Test position: whether the project needs to test control without power.
  3. Shutters: covering the vertical bus contacts when the drawer is withdrawn.
  4. Interchangeability: standardized drawer sizes and planned spare drawers.
  5. Internal arc: a closed door and an arc-resistant design do not protect someone operating with the door open or a drawer withdrawn; incident energy is calculated in a study.
  6. Unit current: plug-in contacts limit the maximum current per drawer; large units are often fixed or of other construction.
  7. Form of separation: declared and verified under IEC 61439-2.

Maintenance and commissioning

  • Before energizing: each drawer is operated several times between its positions to check that the interlocks act and that the plug-in contacts enter without abnormal effort.
  • In test position: control, signals and process interlocks are verified with no power on the motor.
  • In service: the plug-in contacts are inspected periodically, because heating at a worn contact is a typical failure; thermography under load detects it before damage. See thermography in substations and switchboards.
  • Spares: the spare drawer must be tested and labeled as such, so nobody installs it without checking its settings.

Checklist

  • The withdrawable or fixed decision rests on a downtime calculation.
  • Drawers of the same size are interchangeable.
  • There is a spare drawer for each frequently used size.
  • The interlock prevents moving the drawer with the breaker closed.
  • Shutters cover the vertical bus.
  • The mechanical insertion and removal operation was verified.
  • The withdrawal procedure is labeled and included in the manual.
  • Incident energy was calculated and the assembly labeled.

What not to do

  • Do not withdraw a drawer with the motor running or force the interlock.
  • Do not mix drawers of another design in the same compartment.
  • Do not operate with the door open and the bus energized without the protective equipment the arc study indicates.
  • Do not assume withdrawable means safe live: the decision to work with the rest energized belongs to the plant safety procedure.

How we help

We design the MCC and specify the drawer system: interlocks, form of separation, spares and arc considerations, delivered remotely. See engineering design and studies.

References

  • IEC 61439-1, Low-voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies: general rules, 2020 edition (removable parts and insertion interlock).
  • IEC 61439-2, Power switchgear and controlgear assemblies, 2020 edition.
  • UL 845, Motor Control Centers, sixth edition (2021).

Frequently asked questions

What is a withdrawable drawer in an MCC?

A functional unit mounted on its own carrier that can be removed completely from the assembly and put back while the circuit it is connected to may be live. It connects to the vertical bus through plug-in contacts and usually has connected, test and disconnected positions.

Can a withdrawable drawer be pulled out with the motor running?

No. The drawer must only be withdrawn or inserted after its main circuit has been opened with respect to the load. The breaker interlock forces the drawer breaker to be open before it is moved.

When is a withdrawable MCC not justified?

When the process can stop to work on a section, when there are few units or when space is limited. In those cases fixed or plug-in units give a more compact and simpler assembly.

WhatsApp