ISO 8528-2:2018 sets what the combustion engine of a generating set must declare: its site power, speed, consumptions and brake mean effective pressure. It defines P, PI and PID governors, the speed droop for each performance class, and explains that a turbocharged engine accepts smaller load steps than one without a turbocharger.
Short answer
The combustion engine is the part of the generating set that turns fuel into rotation. ISO 8528-2:2018 states what data the engine manufacturer must give the set manufacturer: site power, declared speed, fuel and oil consumption and brake mean effective pressure. It also defines the speed governor types (P, PI and PID), sets the speed droop for each performance class and explains why a turbocharged engine accepts smaller load steps than one without a turbocharger.
What power the engine must deliver
The engine does not only drive the customer’s load. ISO 8528-2:2018, clause 5.1, asks that the power at the engine coupling covers three things:
- The electrical power used by the customer’s plant.
- The electrical power of the engine’s essential independent auxiliaries, as defined in ISO 3046-1.
- The losses of the alternator itself.
The engine is declared with its ISO standard power, according to ISO 3046-1. The power that matters on site is the service power: what the engine delivers in the real site conditions, with its auxiliaries, while the set delivers its rated power. For the load to get a continuous supply, what is asked of the engine must never exceed that service power.
The standard also asks to consider sudden load changes, such as starting an electric motor, because they affect the engine response and the alternator voltage.
The minimum engine data
Under clause 5.2, the engine manufacturer provides at least:
- The power at the conditions of ISO 8528-1 and at service conditions.
- The declared speed, which is the speed at declared power corresponding to the rated frequency of the set.
- Fuel and oil consumption at the conditions of ISO 8528-1.
To assess load acceptance, the standard also asks for the brake mean effective pressure, pme, in kPa:
pme = K · P / (Vst · nr)
K = 1.2 × 10⁵ for four-stroke engines; 0.6 × 10⁵ for two-stroke engines
where P is engine power in kW, Vst the swept volume in litres and nr the declared speed in min⁻¹.
Our own example. An 18 L four-stroke engine delivering 400 kW at 1800 min⁻¹ has pme = 1.2 × 10⁵ × 400 / (18 × 1800) = 1481 kPa, about 14.8 bar. In a turbocharged engine, the load step it accepts at once depends on that pme.
Load acceptance: with and without a turbocharger
Clause 7 explains that load acceptance depends mainly on the combustion air supply system:
- Without a turbocharger (naturally aspirated or mechanically driven compressor): the maximum possible load step equals the service power.
- With an exhaust-gas turbocharger: the acceptable step varies with the pme corresponding to the service power.
The standard asks the set manufacturer to consider the actual load acceptance of the engine and alternator it uses. If your plant needs to start a large electric motor, declare that step when buying. See starting large motors and voltage dip.
P, PI and PID governors
The governor adjusts the fuel to hold speed, and with it frequency. Clause 6.2 defines three types:
| Governor | How it corrects | What happens to speed when load rises |
|---|---|---|
| Proportional (P) | In proportion to the speed change | It drops slightly: it has droop |
| Proportional integral (PI) | Adds an integral action | It normally returns to the same speed: isochronous |
| Proportional integral differential (PID) | Adds an action based on the rate of change | It returns to the same speed and responds better to sudden changes |
Wording and format by Tiza Group from clause 6.2 of ISO 8528-2:2018.
In single operation, any of the three may be used according to the performance the application needs. In parallel with other sets, the standard sets conditions (clause 6.3.3). Paralleling with the grid is covered in generator in parallel with the grid.
- The P governor is used for classes G1 and G2.
- PI and PID are used for G1 to G4. If they work isochronously, they need an auxiliary load-sharing device.
- Without that device, a PI or PID must also be able to work as a P governor, with droop, so the sets share the load.
Droop and no-load speed
Speed droop is the difference between no-load speed and speed at declared power, at a fixed setting, as a percentage of declared speed:
δnst = (ni,r − nr) / nr × 100
ISO 8528-2:2018, Table 2, asks for a droop of up to 8 % in G1, up to 5 % in G2 and up to 3 % in G3; in G4 it is agreed between manufacturer and customer. Values from Table 2 of ISO 8528-2:2018; wording by Tiza Group.
Our own example. A 60 Hz, 4-pole set has a declared speed of 1800 min⁻¹. If it runs at 1854 min⁻¹ at no load, its droop is (1854 − 1800) / 1800 = 3 %: it meets G3. At half load, with the linear characteristic of the standard, it would run at 1854 − 0.5 × 54 = 1827 min⁻¹.
Droop is what allows load sharing between paralleled sets when there is no load-sharing device. The relationship with paralleling and synchronising is explained in generator synchronisation.
Other data the engine must declare
ISO 8528-2:2018 also asks for:
- Low load (5.3): the minimum load the engine sustains without deterioration and what to do if it will run below it.
- Vibration (8): torsional and linear vibration data to calculate the complete set.
- Heat balance (9): heat to coolant, oil, air, exhaust gas and radiated heat, to design the room ventilation.
- Intake and exhaust (10): the maximum pressure losses in filters, ducts and silencers.
- Starting (11): starting capability in special conditions, such as low temperature, and the aids it needs.
- Fuel (12): density, viscosity, calorific value, cetane number and vanadium, sodium, silica and alumina content.
Typical mistakes
- Taking engine power as electrical power. Auxiliaries and alternator losses are missing.
- Paralleling isochronous sets without load sharing. The standard asks for that auxiliary device, or for the governor to work with droop.
- Designing the room without the heat balance. ISO 8528-1 asks for the air temperature around the engine because the site power depends on it.
- Intake or exhaust ducts without checking pressure losses. They must stay within the limits set by the engine manufacturer.
- Always exercising the set at no load. The standard warns that extended running at low load affects engine life.
Protection of the whole set, including overspeed, is explained in generating set protection.
We support you with your generating set
At Tiza Group we test generating sets in medium, high and extra-high voltage substations and in industry: load steps, frequency response, load sharing in parallel and protection. Learn about our testing and commissioning service or write to us for a quote.
Related guides
- Generating set ratings: COP, PRP, LTP and ESP
- Generating set performance classes G1 to G4
- Generating set alternator to ISO 8528-3
- Emergency diesel generator: parts, ISO 8528 and tests
- Generator synchronisation
- Generating set protection
References
- ISO 8528-2:2018, Reciprocating internal combustion engine driven alternating current generating sets — Part 2: Engines, third edition, clauses 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12 and 13, Tables 1 and 2.
- ISO 3046-1, Reciprocating internal combustion engines — Performance — Part 1, for the declaration of engine power.
Frequently asked questions
What speed droop should a generating set governor have?
ISO 8528-2:2018, Table 2, asks for a speed droop of up to 8 % in class G1, up to 5 % in G2 and up to 3 % in G3; in G4 it is agreed between manufacturer and customer. Droop is the difference between no-load speed and speed at declared power, as a percentage of the latter.
Can an isochronous governor run in parallel with other sets?
Yes, but it needs an auxiliary load-sharing device. Without it, the standard asks that the PI or PID governor can also work as a proportional governor, with droop, so that the paralleled sets share the load (clauses 6.2.2, 6.2.3 and 6.3.3).
Why is it a bad idea to leave a set running for many hours at low load?
ISO 8528-2:2018, clause 5.3, warns that extended running at low load may affect the reliability and life of the engine. The engine manufacturer must give the minimum load the engine sustains without deterioration and, if it will run below it, the measures to avoid the problem.