Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Equipment, switchboards and substations

Comparing Switchboard Bids: A Technical Checklist

How to compare switchboard bids on technical merit: scope, certification, tests, documents and lead time, with a scoring matrix and a calculated example.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

MT/BTGinterlockATSLV busMMfeederCCMauxiliariesbusesUF 1UF 2UF 3term.Form 1no partitionsForm 2separate busbarsForm 3separate unitsForm 4separate terminalsIEC 61439-2: forms of internal separationIntegrationLSIG unitGatewaySCADA© tizagrp.comMT/BTGinterlockATSLV busMMfeederCCMauxiliariesbusesUF 1UF 2UF 3term.Form 1no partitionsForm 2separate busbarsForm 3separate unitsForm 4separate terminalsIEC 61439-2: forms of internal separationIntegrationLSIG unitGatewaySCADA© tizagrp.com
LV switchboard and MCC: automatic transfer and forms of separation. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

Two switchboard bids can be compared only when they cover the same scope. The method: a single specification, a technical compliance matrix, clarification of what is missing and only then scoring, with price as one criterion among others. An example with three bids and fixed weights shows how the cheapest bid can come last.

Short answer

To compare switchboard bids you must start from one scope: a single specification, a technical compliance matrix, clarification of what is missing and only then scoring, with price as one criterion among others. The lowest bid may be the one that covers least; that does not make it bad, but its price cannot be placed next to that of a bid with more scope.

For what a certified switchboard must carry see certified or uncertified switchboard, and for the delivery clock, switchboard lead time.

The method

How to compare switchboard bids
  1. One specification for everyone. Same scope, same data
  2. Receive the bids. With their scope and exceptions
  3. Technical compliance matrix. One column per bid
  4. Does any bid price less than requested? Yes: continue; No: Score.
  5. Ask for clarification and pricing of what is missing. With the same deadline
  6. Score and decide. With weights fixed before opening prices

The order matters: the weights are fixed before the prices are opened. That way the score is not adjusted to favor anyone. And every clarification question is answered to all bidders, so that none has information the others did not.

What to compare

CriterionWhat to look atWhere it is explained
CurrentsRated current of the assembly and of each outgoing circuitRated current InA and Inc
Short-circuitIcw, Ipk and Icc withstand, not only the breaking capacity of the breakersIcw, Ipk and Icc
StructureForm of separation, IP and IK degrees, fixed or withdrawable partsFixed, removable and withdrawable parts
Design verificationWhich system, from which original manufacturer, by which methodDesign verification
Product certificateOf the complete assembly, valid at the manufacturing dateRETIE product certificate
TestsRoutine verification, FAT and who attendsRoutine verification
DocumentsAs-built drawings, protocol, manuals, settings listManufacturing and handover
Lead timeBy stage and with its starting pointLead time
Warranty and supportDuration, what it covers and who answersBid conditions
PriceWith the complete scopeScored last

Worked example: three bids

Three bids are compared for the same switchboard. Prices are expressed as relative indices (the lowest = 100), not as real values, and the weights add up to 100. All are assumptions of the example.

CriterionWeightBid ABid BBid C
Technical compliance30242930
Certification and design verification20102020
Tests and documents1561415
Lead time10864
Warranty and support5345
Price (index)20100108121

The price score is calculated as 20 × (lowest price ÷ price of the bid):

  • A: 20 × 100 ÷ 100 = 20.0
  • B: 20 × 100 ÷ 108 = 18.5
  • C: 20 × 100 ÷ 121 = 16.5

Totals:

ABC
Sum of technical and lead-time criteria517374
Price score20.018.516.5
Total71.091.590.5

The cheapest bid, A, comes last because it includes neither a valid certificate nor a FAT. Where a product certificate is mandatory, as in Colombia, such a bid is not admissible; it is scored here only to show its effect on the matrix. B wins by one point over C, which costs 121 against 108 and has the longest lead time. If C shortened its lead time the result would change: that is why the matrix is a decision tool, not a verdict. The weights for your project are yours.

Scope that is often left out

What a bid does not include weighs as much as what it includes. Ask in writing whether each item is in or out of the price:

  • Transport, lifting and unloading on site.
  • FAT with the owner present and its travel costs.
  • As-built drawings and manuals.
  • Nameplates, marking and warning labels.
  • Commissioning spares and special tools.
  • Commissioning and operator training.
  • Follow-up of the product certificate during the warranty.

Each item that one bid excludes and another includes must be valued against the specification, not by intuition. If a bidder prices it separately, add it before comparing.

Warning signs in a bid

  • No product certificate for the assembly, or one for the enclosure only.
  • «Equivalent make» without saying which, on the main breakers.
  • No test protocol or FAT in the scope.
  • Lead time with no stages and no starting point.
  • Scope to be clarified «after the order».
  • A short-circuit rating that does not match the study.

Checklist

  • Single specification issued to all with the same deadline.
  • Matrix weights fixed before opening prices.
  • Matrix with one column per bid and exceptions noted.
  • Clarifications requested in writing and answered.
  • Certificates checked at the manufacturing date.
  • Prices compared for the same scope.
  • Decision recorded with its score.

How we help

We provide the design engineering of low-voltage switchboards, including the specification and the bid evaluation matrix: contact us with your specification or load list.

References

  • IEC 61439-1 and IEC 61439-2, low-voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies: design and routine verification.
  • Ministerio de Minas y Energía, RETIE (Resolution 40117 of 2024, amended by Resolution 40284 of 2026): switchboard product certificate.

Frequently asked questions

Why is the lowest bid not always the best?

Because it may cover less: a different short-circuit rating, different breakers, no product certificate, no FAT or no documents. What is not priced today is paid for later as an extra, or carried as a risk. Prices are compared only for bids with the same scope.

Which technical criteria should be compared between bids?

Rated current and short-circuit withstand rating, form of separation, IP degree, make and reference of the breakers, design verification of the system, product certificate of the assembly, tests included, handover documents, lead time by stage, warranty and support.

How is a bid that does not price something the others do treated?

The bidder is asked to clarify and price what is missing before scoring, with the same specification for everyone. If it does not, it is recorded as non-compliance. Its price is not compared with the others as if it were equal.

WhatsApp