Numerical case of a 10 MW solar plant connected at 115 kV through a 10 MVA step-up transformer. Rated and short-circuit currents are calculated, the inverter contribution is shown to be small next to the grid's, and the feeder, 34.5 kV side and 115 kV side relays are set in cascade with a 0.3 s interval between curves.
Short answer
In a solar plant with a step-up transformer, coordination is solved as a cascade: first the collector feeder relay (the closest to the fault), then the relay on the medium-voltage side of the transformer, and finally the one on the high-voltage side. Each must take at least one coordination interval longer than the previous one at the fault current it sees. Inverters barely change the magnitudes, because they limit their current to a little above rated, but they do change which current each relay sees. This case works it out with assumed numbers, from start to finish. For the general method, see protection coordination step by step.
The example system
Example data (assumed):
- 10 MW (10 MVA) solar plant, with two 34.5 kV collector feeders of 5 MVA each.
- 10 MVA step-up transformer, 34.5/115 kV, 8 % impedance.
- 115 kV grid with a short-circuit power of 1,500 MVA at the connection point.
- Inverters limit their current to 1.1 times rated during a fault (example value; the real one comes from the manufacturer).
- Example coordination interval: 0.3 s.
- Curve of the three relays: standard inverse from the IEC 60255-151:2009 family, with the formula t = TMS · 0.14 / ((I/Is)^0.02 − 1).
Three phase overcurrent relays: A on each 34.5 kV feeder, B on the transformer’s 34.5 kV breaker and C on the transformer’s 115 kV breaker.
Step 1: rated currents
Rated current is S / (√3 · V).
- 115 kV side: 10,000 kVA / (1.732 · 115 kV) = 50.2 A.
- 34.5 kV side: 10,000 / (1.732 · 34.5) = 167.3 A.
- Each 5 MVA feeder: 5,000 / (1.732 · 34.5) = 83.7 A.
Step 2: short circuit at the 34.5 kV bus
The per-unit method is used, on a 100 MVA base. The short-circuit current in this case is calculated in a simplified way, without resistances:
- Grid: 100 / 1,500 = 0.0667 pu.
- Transformer: 8 % on a 10 MVA base equals 0.08 × (100 / 10) = 0.80 pu on a 100 MVA base.
- Total impedance up to the 34.5 kV bus: 0.0667 + 0.80 = 0.8667 pu.
- Base current at 34.5 kV: 100,000 / (1.732 · 34.5) = 1,673.5 A.
- Three-phase fault current supplied by the grid: 1,673.5 / 0.8667 = 1,931 A.
- Seen from the 115 kV side: 1,931 × 34.5 / 115 = 579 A.
Step 3: the inverter contribution
Inverters do not behave like a rotating machine: they limit their current with power electronics. In the example, each one contributes 1.1 times its rating. For how this is modeled, see the inverter contribution to short circuit.
- Whole plant, at 34.5 kV: 1.1 × 167.3 = 184 A.
- One 5 MVA feeder: 1.1 × 83.7 = 92 A.
- Whole plant, seen at 115 kV: 1.1 × 50.2 = 55.2 A.
With a fault on the 34.5 kV bus, 1,931 A from the grid against 184 A from the plant: the inverter contribution is under 10 % of the total. That is why it does not dominate the setting. But it does change what each relay sees, as shown next.
Step 4: relay A on the feeder
Fault on feeder 1. Relay A on that feeder sees the grid current arriving through the transformer plus the contribution of the other feeder (92 A):
- I(A) = 1,931 + 92 = 2,023 A.
- Pickup: 1.25 times the feeder’s rated current, 1.25 × 83.7 = 104.6 A. 105 A is adopted.
- Multiple: 2,023 / 105 = 19.27.
- With TMS 0.10: t = 0.10 × 0.14 / (19.27^0.02 − 1) = 0.230 s.
The inverters of the faulted feeder itself feed from the far end of the cable and do not pass through relay A; a full study handles them with the protection at the other end of the feeder.
Step 5: relay B on the 34.5 kV side
Relay B sees only the grid current: 1,931 A. It must back up relay A with a 0.3 s interval, that is, take at least 0.230 + 0.30 = 0.530 s.
- Pickup: 1.3 times the transformer’s rated current, 1.3 × 167.3 = 217.6 A. 220 A is adopted.
- Multiple: 1,931 / 220 = 8.78.
- With TMS 0.17: t = 0.17 × 0.14 / (8.78^0.02 − 1) = 0.536 s.
- Actual interval against relay A: 0.536 − 0.230 = 0.306 s. It complies.
A TMS of 0.16 would give 0.505 s, that is, a 0.275 s interval: it does not comply. That is why it goes up to 0.17.
Step 6: relay C on the 115 kV side
For a fault on the 34.5 kV bus, relay C sees 579 A and must take at least 0.536 + 0.30 = 0.836 s.
- Pickup: 1.3 × 50.2 = 65.3 A. 65 A is adopted.
- Multiple: 579 / 65 = 8.91.
- With TMS 0.27: t = 0.27 × 0.14 / (8.91^0.02 − 1) = 0.845 s.
- Interval against relay B: 0.845 − 0.536 = 0.309 s. It complies.
Reverse check: if there is a fault on the 115 kV grid, the plant contributes 55.2 A toward the fault through relay C. That is below its 65 A pickup, so the relay does not pick up on that contribution.
Step 7: what is checked next
With the numbers closed, the study continues with what this case does not cover:
- The transformer damage curve must stay above the curve of relay B; see equipment damage curves.
- Ground faults have their own settings, which depend on the grounding; see the ground setting according to grounding.
- The minimum short-circuit conditions (weak grid, fewer inverters in service) to confirm the relays still see the fault.
- The settings the grid operator already has; see coordinating the plant relay with the grid operator.
Frequent mistakes
- Calculating inverters as if they contributed several times their rating, like a synchronous machine, and oversizing the pickups.
- Forgetting that the relay of a healthy feeder sees the contribution of the others in a neighboring fault.
- Setting the high-voltage relay without checking that the plant’s contribution, in a grid fault, does not make it pick up.
- Accepting a curve calculated with the maximum current without checking the minimum.
- Copying the TMS from another plant: it depends on the currents and equipment of each one.
Checklist
- Rated currents of each level calculated and checked against the single-line diagram.
- Maximum and minimum short circuit received in writing from the grid operator.
- Inverter contribution taken from the manufacturer’s datasheet, not from an assumption.
- Each relay checked with the current it really sees, including the contribution of other feeders.
- Coordination interval defined and verified between each pair of relays.
- Curves above the inrush and starting currents, and below the damage curves.
- Check that the plant’s contribution does not make the high-voltage relay pick up in a grid fault.
- Settings transferred to each relay’s sheet with primary and secondary values.
Related guides
- Protection coordination step by step
- Inverter contribution to short circuit and its modeling
- How short circuit is calculated in a plant
- Inverter contribution and protection setting
- Coordinating the plant relay with the grid operator
- Coordination time intervals (CTI)
References
- IEC 60255-151:2009, Measuring relays and protection equipment, Part 151: Functional requirements for over/under current protection, inverse-curve family and its formula.
Need this study?
We carry out the coordination study of a solar plant, with its short circuit, curves and setting sheets, as part of our protection coordination work, for projects in any country. Write to us.
Frequently asked questions
Do inverters change the coordination of a solar plant?
Yes, but little in magnitude. An inverter limits its current to a value close to its rating (1.1 times in the example), so its contribution is a few hundred amperes against thousands from the grid. What does change is what each relay sees: a healthy feeder can feed the fault on another one, and that contribution must be added when checking the curve.
Why use a 0.3 s interval between one relay and the next?
Because it must cover the breaker opening time, the relay error and a safety margin. 0.3 s is the value this example uses; in your study the interval is defined with the real equipment and the grid operator's criterion.
Can I use these settings in my plant?
No. All the data is assumed to illustrate the method. Your plant's settings come from your study, with the single-line diagram, the short-circuit current supplied by the grid operator and the real equipment.