The fault current of a synchronous generator is not constant: it starts high and decays to a sustained value that can be lower than the rated current. With a 5 MVA generator and assumed data, that decay is calculated, a fixed 51 is shown to stop seeing the fault at 1.29 s, and a voltage-restrained 51V that keeps it picked up is set.
Short answer
The current a synchronous generator delivers in a fault decays with time: it starts high, falls during the transient stage and settles at a sustained value limited by the synchronous reactance, which is much larger than the other two. If that sustained value is lower than the pickup of the 51 overcurrent protection, the protection stops seeing the fault and resets without tripping. The usual solution is a 51V, which lowers its pickup when the voltage drops. The case of a 5 MVA generator is calculated below. It complements the generator backup protection.
Why the current decays
In a fault near the generator, the terminal voltage drops and the magnetic field of the machine weakens gradually. At first the current is limited by the subtransient reactance, the smallest; a few cycles later, by the transient one; and finally, when the field has been reduced, by the synchronous reactance, which is several times larger. That is why the fault current of a generator falls from several times the rated current to a value that can be lower than the rated one. The KG factor and the difference between far-from and near-to-generator short circuit describe that effect in studies. A large grid does not behave that way: it keeps its fault current almost constant. That change of behaviour is what complicates the setting when the generator runs in parallel with the grid and the grid is the one that opens first.
Data of the example
All values are assumptions to show the calculation. For your generator, they come from the manufacturer’s data sheet; see the base data for setting generator protections.
- 5 MVA synchronous generator, 13.8 kV.
- Subtransient reactance Xd″ = 0.15 pu; transient Xd′ = 0.25 pu; synchronous Xd = 1.8 pu.
- Transient time constant Td′ = 1.0 s. The subtransient part lasts a few hundredths of a second and is omitted from the relay calculation.
- 51 relay with a pickup of 1.5 times the rated current, IEC 60255-151 normal inverse curve: t = TMS × 0.14 / ((I / Is)^0.02 − 1), TMS 0.3.
- Three-phase fault on the plant feeder, with the grid already disconnected: the grid cleared its side and the generator is left feeding the fault. Solid fault near the terminals: the voltage drops almost to zero and the external impedance is neglected. The prior internal voltage is taken as 1 pu.
Step 1: rated current and pickup
Rated current = 5,000 / (√3 × 13.8) = 209.2 A. The 51 pickup is 1.5 × 209.2 = 313.8 A.
Step 2: fault currents
The current in per unit is the inverse of the reactance that limits it:
- Subtransient: 1 / 0.15 = 6.67 pu = 1,394.6 A.
- Transient: 1 / 0.25 = 4.00 pu = 836.7 A.
- Sustained: 1 / 1.8 = 0.556 pu = 116.2 A.
The sustained current, 116.2 A, is lower than the rated current, 209.2 A, and lower than the 51 pickup, 313.8 A. A fixed 51 would never pick up with that current.
Step 3: how long the current takes to fall below the pickup
After the subtransient stage, the current in pu follows:
i(t) = (4.00 − 0.556) × e^(−t / 1.0) + 0.556.
The 51 pickup is 1.5 pu. The time is solved:
(1.5 − 0.556) / 3.444 = 0.274, so t = −ln(0.274) × 1.0 = 1.29 s.
At 1.29 s the current has already fallen below the pickup. The 51 only counts time while the current is above it.
Step 4: the curve time against the decay
With the transient current, 836.7 A, M = 836.7 / 313.8 = 2.67 and the curve gives t = 0.3 × 0.14 / (2.67^0.02 − 1) = 2.12 s. The relay would need 2.12 s with that current, but the current falls below the pickup at 1.29 s: the 51 resets without tripping. The fault stays fed by the generator with no overcurrent protection clearing it.
Step 5: the 51V
The 51V reduces its pickup in proportion to the voltage. Assumption of the example: the reduction is linear with voltage and has a minimum of 25 % of the set pickup; real relays use different shapes and the manufacturer’s manual defines them.
With the voltage almost at zero, the factor stays at its minimum of 0.25. The effective pickup is 0.25 × 313.8 = 78.4 A.
The sustained current of 116.2 A is greater than 78.4 A: M = 116.2 / 78.4 = 1.48 and the curve gives t = 0.3 × 0.14 / (1.48^0.02 − 1) = 5.32 s. Since the real current is greater than the sustained one during the first seconds, the relay trips in 5.32 s at most.
| Item | 51 with fixed pickup | 51V with the voltage almost at zero |
|---|---|---|
| Pickup | 313.8 A | 78.4 A |
| Sustained fault current | 116.2 A | 116.2 A |
| Does the current exceed the pickup? | No, from 1.29 s | Yes, permanently |
| Result | Resets without tripping | Trips in 5.32 s at most |
What to do with the 5.3 s time
A backup protection does not need to be fast, but to arrive after the ones closest to the fault. 5.3 s is the maximum time with this current, and it must stay above the times of the feeder protections, which clear in tenths of a second. If it is too high for the damage curve of the generator or the transformer, the TMS or the curve is changed and the calculation repeated.
Other points of a generator in parallel with the grid
- When the grid does contribute. With the grid connected, the fault current is larger and the grid-side 51 coordinates with those of the plant as in any feeder. The critical case is the one in this case: the grid has already opened and the generator is left alone with the fault.
- The excitation system. If it sustains the current during the fault, the sustained current is larger than in the example. It is data the manufacturer must provide; see generator excitation systems.
- Distance protection 21. It is the alternative to the 51V; its advantages and limits are in the guide on generator backup.
- Connection permits. Parallel connection to the grid also requires whatever the utility asks for; see generator in parallel with the grid.
Checklist
- I have Xd″, Xd′, Xd, Td′ and the excitation of the generator, from the manufacturer.
- I calculated the sustained fault current and compared it with the rated current and the pickup.
- I verified how long the current takes to fall below the 51 pickup.
- I set the 51V with the voltage-restraint shape from the relay manual.
- The 51V trip time stays above those of the feeder protections.
- The maximum clearing time stays below the generator damage curve.
- I tested the relay with voltage and current at the same time, not with current only.
Related guides
- Base data for setting generator protections
- Synchronous generators in short circuit: factor KG
- Far-from and near-to-generator short circuit
- Generator protection: zones, backup and trips
- Studies CNO requires to connect generation
References
- IEC 60255-151:2009, Measuring relays and protection equipment, Functional requirements for over/under current protection: normal inverse curve.
Need this study?
We do the coordination study of plants with own generation, with the generator data, the backup protections and the settings, within our engineering design and studies service. It is engineering work done remotely, valid for projects in any country. To load the settings into the generator relay, see remote relay configuration. Contact us.
Frequently asked questions
Why may a 51 overcurrent protection not trip for a fault at a generator?
Because the generator fault current decays with time. At the start it is several times the rated current, but after the transient stage it is limited by the synchronous reactance and can be lower than the 51 pickup. If the relay does not complete its time before the current falls, it resets without tripping.
What does the 51V do that the 51 does not?
It lowers its pickup when the generator voltage drops. A fault depresses the voltage and the 51V uses that data: with low voltage it picks up with a smaller current, the one the generator does sustain in steady state. The shape of the restraint depends on each relay.
Is the sustained fault current always lower than the rated current?
No. It depends on the synchronous reactance and on the excitation system. Some excitation systems sustain the fault current and others let it fall. The data comes from the generator manufacturer and must be used in the study.