Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Testing, commissioning and faults

Punch List and Closure Criteria in Commissioning

How a commissioning punch list is built and closed: categories, record fields, closure criteria and what blocks energization.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

A 9 pointsbefore energizationB 21 pointsbefore acceptanceC 26 pointswith date and ownergrid52buspermissive: A closedacceptancecustomer'sfollow-upwith datesA opens the energization gate; B, the acceptance gateclassified when the point is noted, not at the endA before energization9 of 9B before acceptance14 of 21C with date and owner10 of 26open: 0 + 7 + 16 = 23closed: 9 + 14 + 10 = 33 of 56 = 58.9 %scale: 8 px per pointChainDetectClassifyCloseEvidence© tizagrp.comA 9 pointsbefore energizationB 21 pointsbefore acceptanceC 26 pointswith date and ownergrid52buspermissive: A closedacceptancecustomer'sfollow-upwith datesA opens the energization gate; B, the acceptance gateclassified when the point is noted, not at the endA before energization9 of 9B before acceptance14 of 21C with date and owner10 of 26open: 0 + 7 + 16 = 23closed: 9 + 14 + 10 = 33 of 56 = 58.9 %scale: 8 px per pointChainDetectClassifyCloseEvidence© tizagrp.com
Commissioning punch list: points per category, which must be closed to energize and which to accept. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

The punch list collects everything that is missing or wrong when erection and testing end: a label, a drawing not updated, an unfastened cable, a test to repeat. To be useful, each item is classified by what it blocks (energizing, accepting or neither), has an owner and a date, and is closed with evidence. Items that block energization are closed before energizing, with no exceptions.

Short answer

The punch list is the single record of what is missing or wrong when erection and testing end. To serve commissioning, each item carries three things: a category according to what it blocks, an owner with a date and closure evidence. The central criterion is simple: items that block energization are closed before energizing; those that block acceptance, before accepting; the rest, with a date, afterwards. Without that classification the list is a list of complaints, and it becomes impossible to decide whether energizing is allowed.

What goes on the list

Everything detected between the end of erection and acceptance:

  • Erection details: labels, fastenings, covers, paint, signage.
  • Documents: drawings not updated, missing redlines, incomplete signal lists, missing certificates.
  • Test results that did not pass or must be repeated.
  • Differences in settings or configuration found during verification (loaded settings).
  • Observations from the client or the grid operator.

Routine tasks of a test still in progress do not go on it. The list records what was detected, not what was planned.

The three categories

The criterion is a working one, not one from a standard; what matters is agreeing it at the start.

  • A. Before energizing. What affects the safety of people or the operation of protections and interlocks: an untested protection, an unverified setting, an unchecked interlock, a label on switching equipment, an unmeasured earthing.
  • B. Before acceptance. What does not prevent energizing but does prevent acceptance: as-built drawings, reports, tests that can be done with the equipment energized, unsigned protocols.
  • C. With a date and an owner. What can stay open under a plan: improvements, finishes, spares, training.

A useful rule: when in doubt between two categories, take the stricter one until someone with authority decides otherwise.

What each item carries

  1. Unique number.
  2. Location: panel, bay, equipment.
  3. Clear description of what is missing or wrong.
  4. Category (A, B or C).
  5. Owner and deadline.
  6. Status: open, in progress, closed, verified.
  7. Closure evidence: photo, test record, updated drawing, signature.
  8. Who verified the closure and when.

An item is not closed because the person who did it says so: it is closed when someone else verifies the evidence.

How it is handled

  • One list, with one person responsible for maintaining it. Copies in separate sheets produce duplicate items and lost items.
  • A short, periodic review meeting while A or B items remain open.
  • Cut-off before energization: the status is printed or frozen, and it is signed that the A items are closed.
  • Cut-off before acceptance: the same with the B items.
  • C items move to a follow-up plan with dates, outside the job.

How it relates to the rest

The list is fed by the test matrix (each failed test opens an item) and by what is found when reviewing before energizing. It is closed within the commissioning plan, and its final status goes into the dossier.

Worked example

Example data (assumed): when the tests of a substation end, 56 items are noted: 9 of category A, 21 of B and 26 of C. Example criterion: A closed at 100 % to energize; B closed at 100 % to accept. Status on the day of energization: A, 9 closed; B, 14 closed; C, 10 closed.

  1. Total items: 9 + 21 + 26 = 56.
  2. A items: 9 of 9 closed, or 100 %. Energizing is allowed.
  3. B items: 14 of 21 closed; 21 − 14 = 7 remain. Acceptance is not yet possible.
  4. C items: 10 of 26 closed; 26 − 10 = 16 remain, with a date and an owner.
  5. Open in total: 0 + 7 + 16 = 23.
  6. Closed in total: 9 + 14 + 10 = 33, which is 33 / 56 = 0.589, or 58.9 %.

Note that the 58.9 % decides nothing by itself: what allowed energizing was that the 9 A items were closed. If a single one had stayed open, even with 55 of 56 closed overall, there is no energizing.

Examples of items and their category

ItemCategoryReason
Protection function untestedAA fault would not be cleared as expected
Missing label on a disconnectorAA switching error can harm a person
Interlock not verifiedAA safe switching operation depends on it
Drawings not updated (as-built)BDoes not prevent energizing; does prevent acceptance
Unsigned test reportBEvidence is missing, not function
Scratched paint on a cabinetCFinish, no effect on operation
Training of the client’s staffCCan be scheduled with a date

The same defect can change category with context. A cable without a tie in a cable tray is C; the same loose cable near an energized busbar is A.

The review meeting

While A or B items remain open, a short, periodic meeting with a fixed order: A items first, then B; for each item, what is missing, who does it and by when. Only items that bring their evidence are closed in the meeting. What is not closed moves to the next one with the date noted and, if it slips twice, is escalated to whoever leads the commissioning.

Frequent errors

  • Leaving classification for the end: everything is noted as pending and nobody knows what blocks what.
  • Closing by conversation: “I already fixed it” without a photo or a record.
  • Mixing the punch items of several suppliers in one list without an owner for each item.
  • Changing the category in order to energize. If an A item cannot be closed, there is no energizing, or it is decided in writing by whoever has the authority.

What is delivered at closing

When commissioning closes, the list is delivered with its final status: each item with its category, owner, closing date and evidence. Open C items move to a follow-up plan with dates, signed by the client. The whole list goes into the dossier, because it explains what was accepted with remarks and why.

What not to do

  • Do not use the closure percentage to decide whether to energize: the category decides.
  • Do not close an item without evidence verified by someone else.
  • Do not keep two parallel lists.
  • Do not leave items without an owner or a date.
  • Do not change a category without writing down the reason.

Checklist

  • Category criterion agreed with the client at the start.
  • Single list, with a person responsible for maintaining it.
  • Each item with number, location, category, owner and date.
  • Failed tests and settings differences added to the list.
  • A items closed and verified before energizing, with signature.
  • B items closed before acceptance.
  • C items with a follow-up plan.
  • Final status of the list archived in the dossier.

References

  • The categories are a working criterion agreed with the client, not a requirement of a standard.

Need this study?

We build the commissioning plan, with its punch list and closure criteria, as part of our engineering design and studies service, for projects in any country. Contact us.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a punch item and a nonconformity?

A nonconformity is a failure to meet a requirement: a test that did not pass, equipment that does not meet the specification. A punch item is any work that is missing or any detail to correct, whether or not it is tied to a requirement. In practice the punch list usually includes the open nonconformities, with their category, so there is a single picture of what is left.

Who decides the category of an item?

Whoever leads the commissioning, with the safety officer and the client's representative when the item affects people or operation. The criterion is agreed at the start and applied equally to all items; changing a category later requires writing down the reason.

Can you energize with open items?

Yes, as long as none of them blocks energization. Those that do (safety of people, untested protections, unverified interlocks, information the operator needs to operate) are closed first. The others are energized open, with an owner and a date.

WhatsApp