Substation grounding practice differs by country in vocabulary and method, not in physics. The United States designs to IEEE 80, the United Kingdom to ENA Engineering Recommendation S34 and Australia to AS 2067. All three tie the design to ground potential rise, touch and step voltages and fault current split, but each defines tolerable limits and calculation steps in its own way.
Grounding practice compared across countries starts with a reassurance: the physics is the same everywhere. A fault current enters the earth, raises the potential of the grid, and a person standing nearby may be exposed to touch or step voltage. What differs is the method, the vocabulary and the limits each standard sets. Three approaches meet most often in international projects: IEEE 80 in the United States, ENA Engineering Recommendation S34 in the United Kingdom and AS 2067 in Australia.
Short answer
Grounding practice compared: IEEE 80 (United States), ENA EREC S34 (United Kingdom) and AS 2067 (Australia) follow the same steps. The designer finds the fault current that flows to earth, the resulting ground or earth potential rise, and the touch and step voltages. These are then compared with tolerable limits. They differ in calculation steps, limits and terminology. Always design to the document the network operator or the authority names.
Editions: IEEE 80-2013 remains the edition in use while IEEE develops its revision. For ENA EREC S34 and AS 2067, use the edition that the network operator names.
The common structure
All three approaches follow the same chain:
- Fault current. Determine the maximum earth fault current for the system.
- Split. Determine how much returns through earth and how much through cable shields, overhead earth wires or neutral conductors. Only the earth portion raises the grid potential. See partial ground fault currents through earth.
- Grid resistance. Estimate or measure the resistance of the earthing system in the soil.
- Potential rise. Multiply earth current by resistance.
- Touch and step voltages. Evaluate the voltages a person can experience, inside and just outside the grid.
- Tolerable limits. Compare them with limits from the body-current model of the standard.
- Transferred voltage. Check what leaves the site on fences, cables, pipes and communication circuits.
Where they differ
IEEE 80 gives a detailed design procedure with equations for tolerable touch and step voltage by body weight and fault duration, and for mesh and step voltage in a grid. It also covers the surface layer effect. See the IEEE 80 design method, tolerable body current and the safety guide.
ENA EREC S34 is the British guide for assessing the rise of earth potential at electrical installations, including its effect on neighbouring networks and telecommunications. The design of substation earthing systems in British practice also follows ENA Technical Specification 41-24.
AS 2067 covers substations and high-voltage installations in Australia, with earthing requirements that tie to network service provider rules and the electrical safety regulator. For low-voltage installations, earthing follows AS/NZS 3000 and its multiple earthed neutral system.
Vocabulary. Ground potential rise (GPR) in the United States is earth potential rise (EPR) in British practice. A grounding grid is an earth grid. Equipment grounding is protective earthing. The terms are interchangeable in meaning only inside a document that says so.
Practical effects of the differences
- Limits. Tolerable voltages depend on assumptions about fault clearing time, body model and contact conditions, so a result that passes in one standard may not pass in another.
- Soil and measurement. Methods for soil resistivity and grid resistance measurements differ in recommended practice, so state which one you used. See the earth analyser used in such tests.
- Fences and service areas. Treatment of fences, handles and arrester earths varies; see substation fence grounding and grounding of switch handles and arresters.
- Third parties. S34 deals explicitly with the effect of earth potential rise on neighbours’ networks and telecoms. Under IEEE 80 the same question appears as transferred voltage.
Figure: a substation grounding grid with the fault current split between the overhead earth wire and the earth, and the GPR profile across the site.
Worked example: ground potential rise
Illustrative data: a maximum earth fault current of 8,000 A, of which 40% returns through earth (split factor 0.4), and a grid resistance of 0.6 ohm. The DC offset is ignored, so the decrement factor is taken as 1.0.
- Earth current: Ig = 8,000 × 0.4 = 3,200 A.
- Potential rise: GPR = Ig × Rg = 3,200 × 0.6 = 1,920 V.
- Compare 1,920 V with the tolerable touch voltage of the standard you apply, calculated for the actual fault clearing time. The standards define tolerable voltage differently, so this comparison is not a pass or fail until the limits are chosen.
- If the GPR exceeds the tolerable voltage, check mesh and step voltages inside the grid, and the transferred voltages outside.
If the grid resistance fell to 0.4 ohm, GPR would be 3,200 × 0.4 = 1,280 V. Resistance and split factor are the two levers, and both depend on site measurements.
Checklist for the engineer
- Identify the standard the network operator or authority requires.
- Confirm the system earth fault current and clearing times.
- Compute or measure the split factor, with the contribution of shields and earth wires.
- Measure soil resistivity with the method the standard accepts.
- Compute grid resistance, GPR, mesh and step voltages.
- Use the tolerable limits from the standard in force, not another.
- Check transferred voltages to fences, cables, pipes and telecoms.
- Document assumptions so a reviewer can follow the calculation: see grounding of distribution substations.
Related guides
Back to the comparison hub. For the US, read the US framework; for Australia, the Australian framework. See also NEC vs IEC 60364.
How Tiza can help
If a substation or plant needs a grounding study, Tiza runs it remotely and in English, with the method your operator requires. It covers fault current split, grid resistance, GPR and touch and step voltages. Tiza does not stamp, sign or certify. We deliver the study ready for your engineer of record to review and stamp, or for your chartered engineer (or RPEQ in Queensland) to sign off. Contact us with the site data and the operator’s requirements.
Frequently asked questions
Is grounding the same as earthing?
They name the same thing in different regions. North American documents say grounding, and British and Australian ones say earthing. The meanings of terms such as ground potential rise and earth potential rise match, but always use the vocabulary of the standard your authority enforces.
Can I design a grid to IEEE 80 and submit it in the UK?
Only if the network operator accepts it. UK distribution network operators usually expect the method in their own engineering documents, so ask which method and which tolerable limits they require before starting. A design that is physically safe can still be rejected on method.
Why do tolerable touch voltages differ between standards?
Each standard sets limits from body-current studies with its own assumptions on fault duration, body weight, contact resistance and probability. The assumptions differ, so numbers are not interchangeable. Use the limits of the standard you design to and show their source.