Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Codes and grid connection: US, UK, CA, AU

S5.2.5.9 Protection Impact on Security: NER Guide

How NER clause S5.2.5.9 sets fault clearance times, protection redundancy and breaker fail for a generator, with a clearance time budget worked out here.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

132 kV plant busCT ACT BVT AVT BCT BF21 / 85group Atrip 121 / 85group Btrip 250BFbreaker failto adjacent breakersremote endnetwork substationfaultPowerMeasure / tripCommslimits: primary 100 ms, breaker fail 200 msgroup A 80 ms: margin 20 msgroup B 95 ms: margin 5 msbreaker fail 170 ms: margin 30 msthe slower group sets the time that countsms0100200A: 15 + 5 + 60 = 80 msB: 30 + 5 + 60 = 95 msbreaker fail: 15 + 90 + 5 + 60 = 170 ms100200illustrative; times come from S5.1.9ProtectionGroup AGroup BBreaker failChannelTrip© tizagrp.com132 kV plant busCT ACT BVT AVT BCT BF21 / 85group Atrip 121 / 85group Btrip 250BFbreaker failto adjacent breakersremote endnetwork substationfaultPowerMeasure / tripCommslimits: primary 100 ms, breaker fail 200 msgroup A 80 ms: margin 20 msgroup B 95 ms: margin 5 msbreaker fail 170 ms: margin 30 msthe slower group sets the time that countsms0100200A: 15 + 5 + 60 = 80 msB: 30 + 5 + 60 = 95 msbreaker fail: 15 + 90 + 5 + 60 = 170 ms100200illustrative; times come from S5.1.9ProtectionGroup AGroup BBreaker failChannelTrip© tizagrp.com
NER S5.2.5.9: a 132 kV connection point with two independent protection groups, each with its own CT core, VT winding and trip coil, breaker fail protection with its own CT, and the teleprotection channel to the network substation, with clearance times of 80, 95 and 170 ms against limits of 100 and 200 ms. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

Clause S5.2.5.9 of the National Electricity Rules requires a generator to have primary protection that clears faults within set times, enough redundancy to survive any single protection element out of service, breaker fail protection, and a design coordinated with the network service provider.

Clause S5.2.5.9 of the National Electricity Rules (NER) is titled “Protection systems that impact on power system security”. S5.2.5.8 limits what protection may do to a plant that must ride through. S5.2.5.9 sets what the plant’s protection must do for the grid. It must clear faults fast, keep working when one element fails, and not drag other network users offline. The Australian Energy Market Operator (AEMO) and the network service provider (NSP) assess it. The relays work from current transformers (CTs) and voltage transformers (VTs).

The clause is part of the generator performance standards (GPS) described in the Australia electrical codes and grid connection guide.

Short answer

S5.2.5.9 asks for four things. Primary protection that clears any fault inside the generating system and in the protection zones that include the connection point within the fault clearance times. Redundancy so that one failed protection element, including a communications link, does not stop the clearance. Breaker fail protection. A design coordinated with the network’s protection.

What the clause says, in plain words

  • Primary protection. Primary protection disconnects any faulted element inside the plant, and in the zones that include the connection point, within the fault clearance times. Those times are fixed under clause S5.1.9, subject to some of its exceptions, and are tabled by voltage in the performance standard.
  • Redundancy. A faulted element in a zone still clears within the required time with any single protection element out of service. The wording names the communications facility the protection depends on.
  • Breaker fail. Breaker fail protection clears faults that the circuit breakers controlled by the primary protection failed to clear, also within times set under clause S5.1.9.
  • Coordination. The design is coordinated with other protection. It avoids consequential disconnection of other users’ facilities and respects the NSP’s obligations under its connection agreements.

AEMO and the NSP ask for concrete material. It includes protection single line diagrams and a design report deriving each element’s pickup and operating time. It also needs confirmation that the clearance times can be met, and the NSP’s confirmation that the interface is coordinated.

Designing for a single failure

Redundancy is the costly part of the clause. Three questions decide whether a design passes.

  1. Is the second protection group independent? A pair of relays sharing one CT core, one DC supply or one trip coil is not two protection systems. A single failure takes out both.
  2. Does the clearance time still hold with one group out? If the B group alone is slower than the A group, the time that counts is the B group’s. The guide on protection reliability explains the dependability and security trade-off behind this.
  3. What does the protection need from outside the plant? Teleprotection channels are part of the protection. If the primary scheme needs a channel to reach the clearance time, the channel needs its own redundancy. See redundant teleprotection channels for routes and diversity.

Worked example (illustrative)

The numbers are illustrative. Real clearance times come from clause S5.1.9 and the NSP for your connection.

Assume a 132 kV connection where the performance standard records a primary clearance time of 100 ms and a breaker fail clearance time of 200 ms.

Primary protection, group A

StepTime
Relay operating time15 ms
Auxiliary trip relay5 ms
Breaker opening and arc interruption (3 cycles at 50 Hz)60 ms
Total80 ms

The margin against 100 ms is 20 ms. If group B uses a slower relay of 30 ms, its total is 95 ms. The margin is then 5 ms, so the design must be checked against the slower group.

Breaker fail

  1. The primary relay detects the fault and trips in 15 ms.
  2. The breaker fail timer is set to 90 ms: the 60 ms breaker time, 20 ms for current reset in the breaker fail relay, and 10 ms of margin.
  3. After the timer, the breaker fail relay sends trip to the adjacent breakers through an auxiliary relay, 5 ms.
  4. The adjacent breakers open in 60 ms.

Total: 15 + 90 + 5 + 60 = 170 ms. The margin against 200 ms is 30 ms. Lengthening the timer by 30 ms would use up the whole margin, so it is a setting to protect.

The instrument transformers matter as much as the timers. The line CTs must not saturate before the relay operates, at the maximum fault current at the connection point. Check this from the fault level and the X/R ratio at that bus. The guide to the instrument security factor covers the measuring-class side of the same question.

Checklist for the engineer

  • Fault clearance times for the connection voltage, taken from clause S5.1.9 and confirmed with the NSP.
  • Two independent protection groups, with separate CT cores, VT windings, DC supplies and trip coils.
  • A time budget for each group and for breaker fail, with the margin stated.
  • Communications paths that the protection depends on, each with its own redundancy.
  • Breaker fail logic, including what trips and whether it also sends transfer trip to the remote end.
  • Coordination study with the NSP’s protection, showing no consequential trip of other users.
  • CT saturation check against maximum fault current and X/R.

Figure

Figure: single line of a 132 kV connection point with two protection groups, breaker fail, CTs and VTs on each side of the breaker, and the teleprotection channel to the network substation.

Next step

Tiza prepares the protection design report and the clearance-time budgets for submissions to the network service provider and AEMO, working remotely and in English. Tiza does not stamp, sign or certify: it delivers engineering ready for review and certification by your RPEQ in Queensland, or by the registered engineer your state requires. Contact us with the single line diagram and the connection offer.

Companion clauses are S5.2.5.8 on protection of generating systems and S5.2.5.10 on tripping for unstable operation. For the settings method, read protection coordination step by step.

Frequently asked questions

Where do the fault clearance times for S5.2.5.9 come from?

They are determined under clause S5.1.9 of the National Electricity Rules for the voltage level of the connection, and they are recorded in the generator performance standard for the plant. Check the clause and the network service provider's own requirements for the figures that apply to your connection.

What does single-element redundancy mean in practice?

A faulted element must still be cleared within the required time with any one protection element out of service, and that includes the communications path the protection relies on. In practice this leads to two independent protection groups with separate instrument transformer cores, separate DC supplies and separate trip coils.

Did the 2025 rule change rename S5.2.5.9?

No. The title is still protection systems that impact on power system security. The Improving the NEM access standards, Package 1 rule, in force from 21 August 2025, renamed the neighbouring clauses S5.2.5.8 and S5.2.5.10.

WhatsApp