Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Studies and design

Specifying Control and Protection Panels

What the purchase specification of a control and protection panel must say: scope, supply, wiring, communications, documents and tests.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

panel auxiliary supplysource125 V c.c.Q1 2 A4 IED95 WQ2 4 Acoil 1150 Wcoil 2150 Wterminals: 96 used + 20 % spare96 × 1.2 = 115.2: order 120each circuit with its own breakercurrent in amperes (60 px per A)0.76 A0.95 AQ1: 2 A2.4 AQ2: 4 ADC: 95 W / 125 V = 0.76 Awith 25 % margin: 0.95 A (Q1 of 2 A)trip: 2 × 150 W / 125 V = 2.4 A (Q2 of 4 A)Q1 stays at 0.95 A during the tripthe order sets these values and the factory testsChainScopeCircuitsFactory testsDocuments© tizagrp.companel auxiliary supplysource125 V c.c.Q1 2 A4 IED95 WQ2 4 Acoil 1150 Wcoil 2150 Wterminals: 96 used + 20 % spare96 × 1.2 = 115.2: order 120each circuit with its own breakercurrent in amperes (60 px per A)0.76 A0.95 AQ1: 2 A2.4 AQ2: 4 ADC: 95 W / 125 V = 0.76 Awith 25 % margin: 0.95 A (Q1 of 2 A)trip: 2 × 150 W / 125 V = 2.4 A (Q2 of 4 A)Q1 stays at 0.95 A during the tripthe order sets these values and the factory testsChainScopeCircuitsFactory testsDocuments© tizagrp.com
Auxiliary supply of a control and protection panel: DC current, trip current and its breaker, as set by the specification. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

The specification of a control and protection panel fixes what the supplier must build and what the customer will verify: scope and functions, site conditions, auxiliary supply and its sizing, wiring and spare terminals, communications, documents to deliver and factory tests with their acceptance criterion. What is not written in the specification cannot be demanded afterward.

Short answer

The purchase specification of a control and protection panel says, in writing and in measurable terms, what the supplier must build and what you will verify. It is made of six blocks: scope and functions, site conditions, auxiliary supply, wiring and construction, communications, and documents and factory tests. In the example, the supply of a 125 V DC panel is solved with a 2 A breaker for the IEDs and a 4 A one for the trip circuits, and terminals are requested with a 20 % reserve. For the description of the equipment, see the control and protection panel.

What to specify and what not

What can be verified is specified: functions, ranges, protocols, tolerances, documents and tests. What only describes an intention, such as “high quality” or “according to good practice”, is not. Nor is a brand named without a reason; compatibility with what you already have is requested, by protocol and by interface. The specification does not include the programming procedure of the IEDs: that is done by the integrator with the settings you hand over separately.

Block 1: scope and functions

It defines what the supply includes: how many panels, for which bays, with which protection and control functions in each. It starts from the design’s list of functions: per bay, the protections, the control functions and the measurement ones. It adds the list of signals toward the SCADA and toward other panels, and the interlocking scheme each panel must implement; for the wiring and typical signals of a bay, see control wiring and signals of a substation. It also says what is left out, for example yard wiring or SCADA engineering.

Block 2: site conditions

Altitude, ambient temperature and humidity, pollution level and vibration, and whether the panel goes inside a building or outdoors. From those come the enclosure’s degree of protection, ventilation or heating and the operating ranges of the equipment. If this data is missing, the supplier assumes the most favorable.

Block 3: auxiliary supply

The nominal DC voltage, its range of variation, which circuits of the panel are fed from it and how each is protected are specified. Sizing it well is simple and prevents serious problems: the permanent loads are added up, the reserve is added and the trip circuit, which draws current only during the trip, is sized separately. Battery and charger data are covered in auxiliary services by voltage level and the load schedule.

Block 4: wiring and construction

Request the wire size and color, the identification of each wire at both ends, the terminals, short-circuiting test terminals for current circuits and disconnectable ones for voltage circuits, the terminal reserve, the separation between power, control and communication circuits, and the earth connection. Finish and enclosure are requested by their degree of protection, not by description. The criterion that governs construction is set by the panel standards you adopt.

Block 5: communications

Protocols toward the SCADA and between IEDs, number and type of ports (copper or fiber), network redundancy, time synchronization, and the configuration files the supplier must deliver. The corresponding cybersecurity items are requested too: user management, access logging and disabling of unused services. For the network design, see network redundancy in substations.

Block 6: documents and factory tests

The documents are listed with their format and revision: wiring and layout drawings, signal list, terminal list, settings and configuration files, manuals and data sheets. The factory test protocol is required in advance, to approve it before it is run, with acceptance criteria per test. The content of that protocol is described in the guides on FAT and SAT standards and on cybersecurity in FAT and SAT. It also defines who attends, what happens with a nonconformity and what warranty covers the panel.

What to ask for in the factory tests

The specification sets the minimum content of the factory tests; the detailed protocol is written by the supplier and you approve it. As a minimum, ask for: inspection against drawings, supply across its whole range, a test of every input and output of the signal list, verification of the measurements by injection with a written tolerance, trip times of the complete chain, a test of interlocks and communications, and a record signed by both parties. Two demands avoid arguments: that the files used in the test are those of the final version, and that whatever a correction touched is repeated.

Worked example

Example data (assumed): a panel with 125 V DC supply, four IEDs of 20 W each, 15 W of permanent signaling and heating, two trip coils of 150 W each (considered energized at the same time in the worst case) and 96 terminals used. Current reserve of 25 %. Terminal reserve of 20 %.

  1. Permanent load: 4 × 20 + 15 = 95 W.
  2. Permanent current: 95 / 125 = 0.76 A.
  3. With a 25 % reserve: 0.76 × 1.25 = 0.95 A. A 2 A breaker (Q1) is specified for this circuit, which covers 0.95 A with margin.
  4. Trip: 2 × 150 / 125 = 2.4 A, during the instant of the trip. A separate circuit with a 4 A breaker (Q2) is specified, which covers 2.4 A.
  5. Q1 during a trip: since the trip circuit is independent, Q1 stays at 0.95 A and the IEDs do not see the dip caused by the trip.
  6. Terminals: 96 × 1.2 = 115.2, rounded to 116 and requested as 120 terminals to fit a usual block size.

The 2 A and 4 A values are example ratings: the breaker’s trip curve, its DC breaking capacity and the cable’s voltage drop are checked against the breaker data sheet and the wiring drawing.

What to review when the bid arrives

Compare each bid against the six blocks: does it comply, comply with a deviation or not comply? Every deviation is requested in writing, with its justification. A cheap bid that deviates on supply, terminals or documents usually costs more on site.

Checklist

  • Scope, functions and signal list attached to the specification.
  • Site conditions written down.
  • Auxiliary supply with its range, loads and separate trip circuits.
  • Wiring: identification, test terminals and terminal reserve.
  • Communications: protocols, ports, redundancy, time and cybersecurity.
  • List of documents with format and revision.
  • FAT protocol approved before it is run, with acceptance criteria.
  • Treatment of nonconformities and warranty defined.
  • Bid deviations requested in writing.

References

  • The standards applicable to construction are set by the owner in its specification.
  • Calculations and data: our own, with assumed data for the example.

Need this study?

We prepare the panel specification, with its signal list, the sizing of the auxiliary supply and the factory test protocol, as part of our engineering design and studies service. We do it for projects in any country. Write to us.

Frequently asked questions

Must the relay brand be named in the specification?

It is not necessary. Functions, protocols, inputs and outputs, supply range and the tests to pass are specified. Naming a brand limits competition and makes you dependent on one supplier; it is only justified if the owner already has a fleet of equipment to keep, and then it is better stated as a compatibility requirement.

How many spare terminals are requested?

It is the owner's criterion. A common starting value is a reserve of around 20 % of the terminals used, rounded up to the block size the supplier offers. The number is set by your project, according to how much you expect to extend the panel.

What documents must the supplier deliver?

Wiring and layout drawings, signal and terminal lists, settings and configuration files in their final version, the protocol and record of the factory tests, manuals and data sheets. They are requested in the specification with their format and the revision in which they are delivered; without that, the file is incomplete.

WhatsApp