Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Grid, regulation and connection

IEC 81346-1 Reference Designation: Aspects =, - and +

How a reference designation is built under IEC 81346-1: function (=), product (-) and location (+) aspects, levels and sets, with a substation example.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

115 kV busbar-QB1=1.03.QA1-BC1line 3M-M1panel+SC.05control roomOne breaker, three viewsFunction (=)=1.03.QA1what it does: switching of bay 3Product (-)=1.03.QA1-M1by what: the motor inside the breakerLocation (+)+1.03…where: the bay space in the yardSet=1.03.QA1 / +1.03…one object, one designation per aspectAspectsFunction =Product -Location +Set© tizagrp.com115 kV busbar-QB1=1.03.QA1-BC1line 3M-M1panel+SC.05control roomOne breaker, three viewsFunction (=)=1.03.QA1what it does: switching of bay 3Product (-)=1.03.QA1-M1by what: the motor inside the breakerLocation (+)+1.03…where: the bay space in the yardSet=1.03.QA1 / +1.03…one object, one designation per aspectAspectsFunction =Product -Location +Set© tizagrp.com
IEC 81346-1 reference designation: the breaker of a 115 kV bay seen by function, product and location, and its designation set. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

A reference designation identifies an object within the system it belongs to, seen from one aspect: = for function, - for product, + for location and # for other aspects. IEC 81346-1 sets how levels are chained, how they are shortened and how one piece of equipment gets several designations, one per aspect, which form its reference designation set.

This guide is based on the 2009 edition of IEC 81346-1. The current edition is edition 2.0 of 2022. According to the publisher, that edition introduces, among other changes, the type aspect, an information model of the reference designation system and rules for designating relations between objects. The letter classes are covered in our guide on IEC 81346-2 object classes.

Short answer

A reference designation is the code that identifies an object within the system it belongs to. IEC 81346-1:2009 builds it by looking at the object from one aspect: what it does (function, sign =), what it is made of (product, sign -) or where it is (location, sign +). Each level of the structure adds a short segment, for example =QA1, and the segments are chained from the top down. The same circuit breaker can have one designation per aspect, and those designations together form its set.

What it is for

The standard says it in its scope (clause 1): the designation is used to create and retrieve information about an object. The label fixed on the equipment is the key to finding that object in drawings, cable lists, parts lists and test reports. If the cubicle label, the drawing and the SCADA database use the same code, the technician in the field and the engineer in the office talk about the same object with no doubt.

The three aspects

An aspect is a specified way of viewing an object (definition 3.3). The standard works with three main aspects (clause 4.2):

AspectSignQuestion it answersExample in a bay
Function=What must the object do?The switching of line bay 3
Product-By which means does it do it?The circuit breaker delivered by the manufacturer and its spring-charging motor
Location+In which space is it?The 115 kV yard, the control room, panel 05

When none of the three is enough, the project can use another aspect with the # sign, for example a logistic or financial one. Rule 3 requires that use to be described in the supporting documentation.

Viewing through an aspect works like a filter: only the sub-objects that matter from that view are seen. The function-oriented structure shows the tasks regardless of which brand performs them. The product-oriented structure shows how the delivery is put together. The location-oriented structure shows the spaces and what is inside each one (clauses 5.3 to 5.5).

How the designation is built

Each single-level segment carries the aspect sign followed by one of three things: a letter code with a number, a letter code alone, or a number alone (clause 6.2.1, rule 6). The number always follows the letters and tells apart objects with the same code inside the same parent object (rule 9).

Letters are capital Latin letters A to Z. I and O are not used if they can be confused with 1 and 0 (rule 14). When the letters give the class of the object, they come from the IEC 81346-2 scheme (rule 15). Numbers should not carry a meaning of their own; if they do, the document must explain it (rule 10).

The multi-level designation is formed by chaining the segments from the top node down to the object (rule 12). The top node is the whole system, for example the substation, and it gets no designation of its own (rule 5). It can have a name or an order number, written between «< >» when two systems need to be told apart (clause 9.3).

To write it shorter, when two consecutive segments have the same sign, the second sign can be replaced by a full stop (rule 28): =1=03=QA1 can be written =1.03.QA1. The designation goes on a single line and no segment is split (rules 26 and 27).

Our example: line bay 3 of a 115 kV substation

Take a 115 kV substation with several bays. The project defines and documents this numbering: 1 is the 115 kV yard and 03 is line bay 3. With that rule, the objects of the bay circuit breaker read as follows:

ObjectDesignationAspect
Switching of line bay 3=1.03.QA1Function
Spring-charging motor of the breaker=1.03.QA1-M1Function, then product
Place of the breaker in the yard+1.03Location
Protection and control panel of the bay, in the control room+SC.05Location

The second row mixes aspects on purpose: the breaker is placed by its function and its motor by the structure of the product the manufacturer delivered. The standard allows it (clause 5.7). The letter Q is the class for controlled switching of energy, and M the class for mechanical energy used for actuating; both come from IEC 81346-2.

The same circuit breaker is identified by this reference designation set:

=1.03.QA1
+1.03…

The first line identifies it unambiguously. The second names the space that contains it, and that is why it ends with an ellipsis: that space also contains other objects (clause 7, rule 19). Each designation of the set is kept apart from the others, on separate lines or with a solidus «/» if they share a line (rules 17, 32 and 33).

With this code, the open command in the SCADA, the label on the breaker cubicle, the control drawing and the cable list name the same object. When the substation is extended with a bay 04, the numbering rule is already written and the new code follows directly.

Labels in the field

Clause 10 covers the labelling of components and also the identification of objects on operator displays. The label with the designation, or with the part that is needed, goes next to the component that corresponds to the object (rule 36). If all devices of a panel share the initial part of the code, that part can go only on the panel label, and each device carries its final segment (rule 37). For cables and conductors, the standard refers to IEC 62491.

Typical mistakes

  • Mixing codes without explaining them. In drawings of the ANSI tradition each device carries its function number, such as 52-L1, as we explain in the single-line diagram of a plant. That number and the IEC 81346 designation can live together, but the supporting documentation must say how they correspond.
  • Numbers with a hidden meaning. If 03 means «line bay 3», it must be written in the project rules document (rule 10).
  • Designating the top node. The substation as a whole system gets no designation; it gets a name or an identifier between «< >».
  • Splitting the code. A code split over two lines of a drawing or a label reads as two objects.
  • Using I and O. They are confused with 1 and 0 on small labels.
  • Using the same sign for two aspects. A panel designated with «=» as if it were a function, instead of with «+» as a place, makes the database treat it as another object.

Where it shows in a substation project

The designation orders the secondary design package with its protection and control drawings and the lists of the control and signal wiring. In IEC 61850, logical node names follow their own standard, as we explain in logical node and signal names in SCL. A well-ordered project documents how the IED name in the SCL relates to the designation of the equipment in the drawings.

When to call us

If your project needs a clear designation rule for drawings, panels and SCADA, or you are extending a substation whose drawings follow another tradition, at Tiza Group we define it and apply it in the engineering. Engineering is a remote service, available worldwide. See our secondary engineering service. Write to us and we will send you a quote.

References

  • IEC 81346-1, Industrial systems, installations and equipment and industrial products – Structuring principles and reference designations – Part 1: Basic rules, edition 1.0 (2009), clauses 1, 3.3, 3.11 to 3.14, 4.2, 5.3 to 5.7, 6.1, 6.2, 7, 9.1, 9.3 and 10.
  • IEC 81346-1, edition 2.0 (2022), current edition.
  • IEC 81346-2, Part 2: Classification of objects and codes for classes, edition 1.0 (2009), Table 1.
  • IEC 62491, labelling of cables and cores (referenced by IEC 81346-1, clause 10).

Frequently asked questions

What do the =, - and + signs mean in a reference designation?

They show the aspect from which the object is viewed. The = sign is used for function, the - sign for product and the + sign for location. The # sign is kept for other aspects that the project defines and documents (IEC 81346-1:2009, clause 6.2.1, rule 7).

Can the same piece of equipment have two different designations?

Yes. A circuit breaker can carry one designation for its function in the bay and another for the place where it is installed. Together they form its reference designation set, and at least one of them must identify it unambiguously (clause 7, rules 17 and 18).

Does the IEC 81346 designation replace ANSI device numbers such as 52 or 89?

They are not the same thing. The ANSI number of IEEE C37.2 says what function a device performs; the IEC 81346 designation says where that object sits in the structure of the system. A project can use both, as long as its supporting documentation explains how they relate.

WhatsApp