Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Testing, commissioning and faults

FAT Protocol for a Protection and Control Panel

What to test at the factory on a protection and control panel: inspection, supply, I/O, injection, trip and acceptance criteria.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

protection and control panel at the factorysource125 V c.c.supplytest settestinjectionIED ofprotectiontripsimulator ofcircuit breakerstop contactno power energy: test signals only1 Inspection and wiringdrawing against panel, terminals and labels2 Auxiliary supply 88 to 150 V DC70.4 % at 120 % of 125 V3 144 I/O points: 3.6 h3 IEDs × (32 inputs + 16 outputs) × 1.5 min4 Analog injection: 1.33 %1,000 A in; 608 A out; expected 600 A; limit 2 %5 Trip: 31 msexample limit: 40 mstrip time (6 px per ms)limit 40 ms31 msaccepted: no critical nonconformitiesChainInspectionFunctionalInjectionAcceptance© tizagrp.comprotection and control panel at the factorysource125 V c.c.supplytest settestinjectionIED ofprotectiontripsimulator ofcircuit breakerstop contactno power energy: test signals only1 Inspection and wiringdrawing against panel, terminals and labels2 Auxiliary supply 88 to 150 V DC70.4 % at 120 % of 125 V3 144 I/O points: 3.6 h3 IEDs × (32 inputs + 16 outputs) × 1.5 min4 Analog injection: 1.33 %1,000 A in; 608 A out; expected 600 A; limit 2 %5 Trip: 31 msexample limit: 40 mstrip time (6 px per ms)limit 40 ms31 msaccepted: no critical nonconformitiesChainInspectionFunctionalInjectionAcceptance© tizagrp.com
Factory acceptance test (FAT) of a protection and control panel: supply, inputs and outputs, analog injection and trip time against its limit. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

The FAT of a protection and control panel checks, before shipment, that the panel does what the design says: inspection against drawings, supply across its whole range, every input and output of the signal list, current and voltage measurement by injection, and trip times. Each test has an acceptance criterion written before it starts, and anything that fails is recorded as a nonconformity and closed out.

Short answer

The FAT (factory acceptance test) of a protection and control panel is done with the panel assembled and powered, but without power-system energy: only with test signals. The panel is checked against the drawings, powered across its whole range, every input and output of the signal list is tested, current and voltage are injected to verify the measurements, and the full trip chain is timed. Each test has an acceptance criterion written before it starts; whatever fails is recorded and closed out before shipment. For the standards that frame the FAT and the SAT, see standards for commissioning, FAT and SAT.

What the FAT is and is not

According to IEC 61850-4, the FAT validates and verifies from the customer’s point of view; its scope is agreed between integrator and customer, documented in checklists that form part of the contract, and the result is signed by both parties. The standard treats it as optional; in practice, you make it mandatory by putting it in the specification.

It is not the type test of the equipment (the relay manufacturer already did that) nor the routine test of each part. Nor is it the SAT: the FAT is done without the switchyard, with simulators; the SAT is done with the equipment installed and is a separate guide. For equipment in a solar plant there is a specific case in FAT of solar plant equipment. The subject here is the panel that protects and controls a bay or a substation.

Before the test

The protocol is written before the panel arrives. It needs four documents:

  • Drawings and signal list in the revision that will be built. The test compares the panel against them, not against anyone’s memory.
  • Settings and configuration files for each IED, with their version and checksum. If the integrator loads a file other than the approved one, the test is worthless.
  • Test plan with the sequence, the test equipment and its current calibration.
  • Acceptance criteria per test, in numbers: measurement tolerance, maximum trip time, supply range.

For the relay-level plan, see the test plan of a relay.

The tests, in order

Order matters: each test assumes the previous one passed.

FAT sequence
  1. Inspection. Drawings, labels, terminals, tightness, wire identification and panel condition
  2. Supply. Start-up across the declared range, voltage dip and return
  3. Inputs and outputs. Every point of the signal list, one by one
  4. Analog injection. Current and voltage at the test terminals; measurement in each IED
  5. Functions and trip. Test settings, operate times and the complete chain to the simulator
  6. Documentation. Signed record, nonconformities and final drawings

Inspection. Check that the panel matches the drawings: terminals, labels, wire size, short-circuiting test terminals for current circuits, earth continuity and the state of the paint and enclosure. It is the cheapest test and the one that finds the most errors.

Supply. Energize the panel and verify that each IED starts within the DC voltage range its manufacturer declares, rides through a brief dip and returns to operation without intervention. Do not assume the range from memory: take it from each device’s data sheet.

Inputs and outputs. Each point is tested once: apply the signal and verify that the IED sees it, and activate each output and measure it at the terminal. It is repetitive and that is where a script or a record sheet pays off: progress is measured and each point is signed. Interlocks are tested here with simulated positions.

Analog injection. With a test set, inject current and voltage at the test terminals and verify the measurement each IED shows, with the transformer ratio loaded. Compare at least three points per channel.

Functions and trip. Test the functions with the agreed test settings and measure the time from the moment the test set starts injecting until the trip contact closes the circuit of the breaker simulator.

Acceptance criteria

A useful criterion is measurable, written before the test and independent of who looks at it.

TestWhat is measuredHow it is accepted
InspectionMatch with drawingsNo open differences
SupplyStart-up in the declared rangeOperates across the range, no resets
Inputs and outputsEach point of the list100 % of points tested and signed
InjectionMeasurement errorWithin the agreed tolerance
TripTime to the contactLess than or equal to the agreed maximum

Tolerances come from each IED’s data sheet and from your specification; there is no single value.

Worked example

Example data (assumed): a 115 kV line-bay panel with three IEDs (main protection, backup protection and bay controller), each with 32 binary inputs and 16 binary outputs. CT of 600/1 A. Estimated time per point: 1.5 min. Nominal supply 125 V DC; the IED manufacturer’s declared range is 88 to 150 V DC. Example criteria: measurement error of 2 % at most and trip time of 40 ms at most.

  1. Input and output points: 3 × (32 + 16) = 144 points.
  2. Time for the I/O test: 144 × 1.5 min = 216 min = 3.6 h. That figure is used to plan the shift, not to improvise it.
  3. Supply extremes: 88 / 125 = 0.704, that is 70.4 % of nominal; 150 / 125 = 1.20, that is 120 %. Those are the two points where start-up is tested.
  4. Measurement: 1.000 A is injected in the secondary; with a 600/1 ratio the IED must show 600 A. If it shows 608 A, the error is (608 − 600) / 600 = 0.0133, that is 1.33 %: within 2 %.
  5. Trip: 31 ms is measured between the start of the injection and the contact at the simulator. 31 ms is less than 40 ms: it passes, with 9 ms of margin.

Had step 4 given 620 A, the error would be 3.33 % and the test fails. The most likely cause would be a wrongly loaded ratio or a miswired channel; it is corrected and the whole channel test is repeated.

Nonconformities

Everything that does not comply is recorded with its description, the test where it appeared, the cause, the action and who closes it. A panel with a critical nonconformity is not shipped. Minor ones can be closed on site if the protocol allows it and it is noted who verifies them. Also keep the settings and configuration file used in the test: it is the evidence that what arrived on site is what was approved.

Checklist

  • Protocol and acceptance criteria approved before the test.
  • Drawings, signal list and configuration files in the revision being built.
  • Test equipment with current calibration.
  • Inspection against drawings with no open differences.
  • Supply tested at both ends of the range.
  • All input and output points tested and signed.
  • Current and voltage measurements within tolerance in each IED.
  • Trip time measured on the complete chain.
  • Nonconformities recorded, with owner and closing date.
  • Record signed by integrator and customer.

References

  • IEC 61850-4, Communication networks and systems for power utility automation, Part 4: System and project management (system tests; FAT and SAT).
  • Calculations and data: our own, with assumed data for the example.

Need this study?

We design the FAT protocol, the signal lists and the acceptance criteria as part of our engineering design and studies service, for projects in any country. Write to us.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between the FAT and the manufacturer's routine tests?

Routine tests are done by the manufacturer on each device to secure its own quality. The FAT is agreed between integrator and customer, documented in checklists that form part of the contract, and signed by both parties. IEC 61850-4 describes it as optional: what makes it mandatory is that you ask for it in the specification.

Must every signal be tested, or is a sample enough?

On a protection and control panel every signal is tested, because the cost of a wiring error found on site is higher than the cost of checking it at the factory. What can be sampled, if the contract agrees, is the repetition of identical tests across panels of a series. That decision must be written into the protocol.

Who has to be present at the FAT?

The integrator running the test, a customer representative with the specification and the signal list and, if the design requires it, the person responsible for the project's protection. The signature of both parties at the end of the protocol is what turns the test into an acceptance record.

WhatsApp