Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Testing, commissioning and faults

Breaker Trip and Close Tests Before Energizing

What is measured when a breaker is tripped and closed at commissioning: time per pole, pole spread, total time from the relay, with a worked example.

By Shadai García, CEO and protection engineer at Tiza Group.

50/51 relaytripcoil oftripbattery125 VmechanismABCanalyzerof timingbreaker isolated, no power voltageopening and closing of each pole is measuredopening of each pole (5 px per ms)At 31.0 msB 31.6 msC 30.8 msdifference: 31.6 − 30.8 = 0.8 ms (limit 2.0 ms)closing: A 62.4; B 63.1; C 62.0 msdifference: 63.1 − 62.0 = 1.1 ms (limit 3.0 ms)total trip (5 px per ms)relay 18 ms + breaker 31.6 ms = 49.6 msexample limit: 60 ms; margin 10.4 mscoil voltage at trip: 118 of 125 V (−5.6 %)ChainCommandCoilPolesTime© tizagrp.com50/51 relaytripcoil oftripbattery125 VmechanismABCanalyzerof timingbreaker isolated, no power voltageopening and closing of each pole is measuredopening of each pole (5 px per ms)At 31.0 msB 31.6 msC 30.8 msdifference: 31.6 − 30.8 = 0.8 ms (limit 2.0 ms)closing: A 62.4; B 63.1; C 62.0 msdifference: 63.1 − 62.0 = 1.1 ms (limit 3.0 ms)total trip (5 px per ms)relay 18 ms + breaker 31.6 ms = 49.6 msexample limit: 60 ms; margin 10.4 mscoil voltage at trip: 118 of 125 V (−5.6 %)ChainCommandCoilPolesTime© tizagrp.com
Breaker trip and close test: opening time per pole, difference between poles and total time from the relay. Location in the system and operating principle. Illustrative: real values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

Before energizing, the breaker is checked to open and close when it should and in the time it should. The time of each pole is measured with an analyzer, along with the spread between poles, the voltage reaching the coil during the operation and the total time from the relay's decision to contact separation. The limits come from the breaker's nameplate and manual, and from the time the coordination needs.

Short answer

Before energizing, the breaker is checked to open and close on every intended command and within the intended times. With the breaker isolated and no power voltage present, the opening and closing time of each pole, the spread between poles, the coil voltage during the operation and the total trip time from the relay’s decision to contact separation are measured. The limits for each breaker come from its nameplate and manual; the total time must be compatible with what the coordination study assumes.

What is tested and why

Tripping is the part of protection that nobody sees until it is needed. It is tested in four layers:

  1. The breaker alone. Local control: how long each pole takes to open and to close. It reveals slow mechanisms, tired springs or times that differ from the nameplate.
  2. The control circuit. Coils, auxiliary contacts, interlocks and the DC supply (see the breaker control cabinet). A voltage drop in the cable can make the coil slower or stop it operating.
  3. The trip from the relay. A fault condition is injected into the relay (see secondary and primary injection tests) and the time until the breaker opens is measured.
  4. Supporting functions. Trip circuit supervision, anti-pumping, pole discrepancy and lockout. See pole discrepancy.

Each layer rules out a different cause. If the breaker alone is slow, the relay is not to blame; if it is fast alone and slow from the relay, the problem is in the trip contact or its wiring.

What is measured

Opening time of each pole. From the moment the trip coil is energized until the pole’s contacts separate. The breaker’s time is that of the slowest pole. The test is also described in breaker operating time test. Detail in opening time and break time. Arcing time is not included here: complete fault clearing takes somewhat longer.

Closing time of each pole. From the moment the close coil is energized until the pole’s contacts touch.

Spread between poles. The slowest pole minus the fastest, for opening and for closing. It shows how well synchronized they are. A high value can point to a misadjusted mechanism.

Coil voltage. Measured at the coil terminals during the operation, not only at the battery. A long cable with a poor connection can pull the voltage down just when the current is highest.

Total trip time. Relay operating time (from injection to output contact) plus the breaker’s opening time. If there is an auxiliary trip relay or a message over the station network, that is added too. It is the measurable part of the clearing time: coordination uses the manufacturer’s break time (opening plus arcing), and this test confirms the part that can be measured.

Auxiliary contacts. The contact that reports position must change state with the real position of the poles. See auxiliary contacts of the breaker.

Where it is measured

The timing analyzer is connected to the contacts of each pole, which must be free of power voltage. Earths are handled according to the analyzer’s method and the site safety procedure. The time, temperature, battery voltage and breaker state (for example gas pressure or spring charge) are recorded. The times depend on those conditions, which is why the record keeps them.

Worked example

Example data (assumed): breaker of a line bay with a 125 V DC battery. Measured trip times per pole: A 31.0 ms, B 31.6 ms, C 30.8 ms. Closing: A 62.4 ms, B 63.1 ms, C 62.0 ms. Relay operating time: 18 ms. Example criteria: maximum spread between poles of 2.0 ms on trip and 3.0 ms on close; total trip time of 60 ms at most. Coil voltage measured on trip: 118 V.

  1. Breaker time on trip: that of the slowest pole, 31.6 ms.
  2. Spread between poles on trip: 31.6 − 30.8 = 0.8 ms. Less than 2.0 ms: pass.
  3. Spread between poles on close: 63.1 − 62.0 = 1.1 ms. Less than 3.0 ms: pass.
  4. Total trip time: 18 + 31.6 = 49.6 ms. Less than 60 ms: pass, with 60 − 49.6 = 10.4 ms of margin.
  5. Coil voltage drop: 125 − 118 = 7 V, which is 7 / 125 = 5.6 % of nominal. It is compared with the minimum operating value on the breaker nameplate, which is met in the example.

If pole B had read 34.5 ms, the spread would be 34.5 − 30.8 = 3.7 ms: it fails and the mechanism is adjusted before repeating. If the total time had exceeded 60 ms, the coordination study would have to be revisited with the real value.

If a time is out of limits

Check in this order: first the battery voltage and the drop in the cable to the coil; then the connections of the coil and the auxiliary contacts; then the state of the mechanism (springs, pressure or level, depending on the breaker type), and last the adjustment and lubrication. The mechanism is not adjusted without authorization from the manufacturer or the equipment owner, and after any adjustment the complete measurement is repeated, not only the pole that failed. If the breaker simply does not operate, the diagnosis is in the breaker does not open.

Reference values for maintenance

The commissioning times become the baseline. In later maintenance it is not enough to know whether the time is within the nameplate limit: what matters is whether it is drifting from what was measured at the start. A breaker that moves from 31.6 ms to 36 ms is still within a wide tolerance, but the trend warns before it fails. Without the baseline you only know pass or fail.

Relation to coordination

The breaker time enters the coordination margin between protections: together with the breaker’s break time, the relay overtravel (in electromechanical relays) and a safety margin, it is part of what the study assumes for clearing a fault before the backup protection acts. If the measured time is longer than the assumed one, the margin shrinks and the study must be revisited; if it is shorter, the study is conservative and nothing changes. That is why the report gives the measured value, not just “pass”.

What is recorded

For each pole and each operation: measured time, instrument, battery voltage, coil voltage, temperature and breaker state. The command used (local control, relay, remote) and who ran the test are also noted. With that set, whoever repeats the test years later can compare under equivalent conditions and not just against the number.

What not to do

  • Do not accept a single time: all three poles are measured.
  • Do not measure with the breaker energized. Earths are handled according to the analyzer’s method and the site safety procedure.
  • Do not use the limits of an example as a criterion: use the nameplate and the study.
  • Do not test only from local control: the relay’s trip contact counts too.
  • Do not forget to record the test conditions (voltage, temperature, pressure).

Checklist

  • Breaker nameplate and manual at hand, with times and tolerances.
  • Breaker isolated, no power voltage, earths per the site safety procedure.
  • Opening time of each pole measured and recorded.
  • Closing time of each pole measured and recorded.
  • Pole spread calculated and compared with the limit.
  • Coil voltage measured during the operation.
  • Trip from the relay measured end to end.
  • Auxiliary contacts and trip circuit supervision checked.
  • Breaker state (gas, springs) and temperature noted.

References

  • The time limits of each breaker come from its nameplate and manual and from the project’s coordination study.

Need these tests?

We define which times are measured and against what criterion as part of our engineering design and studies service, for projects in any country. Contact us.

Frequently asked questions

Why measure per pole and not just the breaker's time?

Because a three-phase breaker only isolates when all three poles open, and a pole that lags leaves the fault fed for longer or creates an imbalance. The breaker's value is that of the slowest pole, and the difference between the fastest and the slowest shows how closely they move together.

Where do the time limits come from?

From the manufacturer, on the breaker's nameplate and manual, and from what the coordination study requires for the total clearing time. The values in the example are assumed; do not use them as criteria for your equipment.

Is testing the trip from the relay the same as from the local control?

No. From the local control you test the breaker and its control circuit; from the relay you also test the trip contact and its wiring. That is why commissioning asks for both: the breaker's own time and the time of the complete chain.

WhatsApp