Tiza Group

Home / Guides / Communications and control / Interlocking and control logic

H Configuration Interlocking: Bridge and Two Sources

H substation interlocking: bridge with circuit breaker or disconnectors, two lines in parallel, transfer between transformers and node earthing.

By Shadai García, electrical engineer, founder and CEO of Tiza Group. Reviewed by the Tiza Group engineering team · .

5257-189B89B57-152node 189E157E152E57E289E257H1123Close 57H1189B of L1 and T1 open289E1 open3dead (detector or 27)CILO.EnaClstruefalsefalsecommand: close 57H1 · blockedcommand: open 52E · executedcommand: open 89E1 · executedcommand: open 52 of L1 · executedcommand: open L1 89B · executedcommand: open T1 52 · executedcommand: open T1 89B · executedcommand: close 57H1 · executedIEC 61850XCBRXSWICILOCSWIXSWI© tizagrp.com5257-189B89B57-152node 189E157E152E57E289E257H1123Close 57H1189B of L1 and T1 open289E1 open3dead (detector or 27)CILO.EnaClstruefalsefalsecommand: close 57H1 · blockedcommand: open 52E · executedcommand: open 89E1 · executedcommand: open 52 of L1 · executedcommand: open L1 89B · executedcommand: open T1 52 · executedcommand: open T1 89B · executedcommand: close 57H1 · executedIEC 61850XCBRXSWICILOCSWIXSWI© tizagrp.com
H configuration interlocking: node earthing and the bridge. Location in the system, operating principle and IEC 61850. Illustrative: actual values come from the nameplate and the manufacturer's manual.
Short answer

In an H substation the logic revolves around the bridge between the two nodes. With a bridge breaker, its disconnectors operate only with it open, and its close can parallel the two lines, so it goes through synchronism check. With a disconnector bridge, it is operated only with one side dead. The earthing switch of each node requires the three disconnectors that reach it to be open.

H configuration interlocking focuses on the crossbar of the H. In the H configuration two lines each arrive at a node, a transformer leaves from each node and a bridge ties the two nodes. The bridge decides whether the substation works as two independent supplies or as one with both lines in parallel, and the control logic decides when it can change from one mode to the other.

Variants and what changes in the logic

The H has variants depending on where the circuit breakers are, and each one changes the interlocking:

  • Full five-breaker H: each line, each transformer and the bridge with its own breaker. This is the variant described below.
  • Three-breaker H: no transformer breakers or no line breakers. The disconnector on the side without a breaker operates only with the bridge and that branch’s breaker open.
  • Disconnector bridge: the bridge has no breaker and is operated only without current.

Conditions per device (full H)

DeviceOpens ifCloses if
Node disconnector 89B (line or transformer)its breaker is openits breaker open, the earthing switch on its side open and the node earthing switch open
Line disconnector 89Lthe line breaker is openthe breaker open and earthing switches 57-2 and 57L open
Bridge disconnectors 89E1 and 89E2the bridge breaker is openthe 52E open, the bridge earthing switch on its side and the earthing switch of its node open
Bridge breaker 52Efreeits two earthing switches open; if both nodes are live, with permission from the 25
Earthing switch of node 1 (or 2)freethe 89B of the line and of the transformer of that node and the bridge disconnector on that side open
Transformer HV terminal earthing switchfreeits disconnector and its low-voltage breaker open

Each node is a small bus between three breakers. Its earthing switch is the only condition that mixes three bays.

The full table for this arrangement, with the CILO equations and the list of test cases, can be generated with our free interlocking table tool.

The bridge as a parallel of sources

With the bridge closed and both lines in service, the two lines are in parallel through the substation. If the substation sits in the middle of a corridor, power can flow from one line to the other. Closing the bridge, then, is not just another operation:

Close permission for the bridge breaker
  • Are both bridge disconnectors closed and its earthing switches open?
    • NoThe interlocking blocks the close
    • YesAre both nodes live?
      • YesParallel close: the 25 compares the voltages of both nodes
      • NoDid the dead node lose voltage because of its own fault?
        • YesBlocked until the fault is isolated
        • NoDead-node close, by command or by automatic transfer

The synchronism check of the bridge needs the voltage of each node. If the voltage transformers are on the line side, the voltage of each node is taken from the line of its branch through a voltage selection based on the position of its breaker and disconnectors.

Transfer between transformers

If the bridge works open, each line feeds its transformer. When one line is lost, the bridge can close so that the other line picks up both transformers. That automatic transfer lives in the bay controller or in a PLC and has its own permissives: no voltage on the affected node, the breaker of the lost line open, no fault on the node or the transformer, and the other line able to carry the load. See automatic source transfer.

With the bridge closed, the problem is the opposite: taking out a line interrupts nothing, but taking it out with the bridge open leaves its transformer without a source. Good logic warns before executing that command.

Bay level and station level

The interlocks of each line, each transformer and the bridge are bay level. Station level are:

  • the node earthing switches, which need three bays;
  • the bridge close permission, which needs the voltage and fault state of both branches;
  • the automatic transfer.

With five bays, hardwiring is manageable. With IEC 61850 controllers, the bridge subscribes by GOOSE to the positions and protection pickups of both branches.

Critical switching sequences

Taking out a line with the transformer in service
  1. 01Close the bridgeWith permission from the 25 if both branches are live
  2. 02Open the line breakerThat branch's transformer is now fed from the other line
  3. 03Open the 89L and the 89BLine side first, then node side
  4. 04Isolate the remote endDone by the other substation on orders from the control centre
  5. 05Earth the lineWith absence of voltage verified

Medium and high voltage

At high voltage, the H is typical of subtransmission, with motor-operated disconnectors and logic in the bay controllers. At medium voltage it appears in industrial plants with two utility feeds and two transformers, often in switchgear: there, each panel’s interlocks come from the manufacturer according to IEC 62271-200, and anything that depends on other panels, such as the bridge or the node earthing switch, is solved with electrical logic or trapped keys. In both cases, the interlocking cannot see the earth at the remote end of a line: that condition is confirmed with the control centre.

Typical mistakes

  • Disconnector bridge without the isolated-node condition. The bridge is closed with both branches live.
  • Transfer without fault blocking. The bridge closes onto a faulted transformer or node.
  • Incomplete node earthing condition. The condition leaves out the bridge disconnector.
  • Bridge 25 with a single voltage. Without the voltage of the other node there is no sync check and no dead-node detection.

How it is tested

The matrix of each device is covered, the bridge close is tested in the live and dead node combinations, and the transfer is tested with the loss of each line, with a fault present and with the bridge unavailable. Secondary injection covers the 25 and the blocking.

We can help with your interlocking logic

At Tiza Group we design H substation logic as part of secondary engineering: interlocking, bridge logic, transfer and sync check, and we program it through remote configuration, for subtransmission substations and industrial plants with two utility feeds. On-site testing is done in Colombia, or elsewhere on request.

References

  • IEC 61850-7-4: logical nodes CILO, CSWI and RSYN.
  • IEC 60050-605: substation vocabulary (four-breaker arrangements and their bridge variant).
  • IEC 62271-102:2018: alternating current disconnectors and earthing switches.
  • IEC 61936-1:2021: power installations exceeding 1 kV AC.
  • EN 50110-1: operation of electrical installations (five safety rules).
  • IEEE C37.2: device functions 25, 52, 57 and 89.

Frequently asked questions

Why won't the bridge breaker close even though both nodes are live?

Because tying the two nodes with both lines in service closes a parallel. If the angle, magnitude or frequency difference between the two lines is outside the limits of function 25, the close permission does not arrive. Also check that its two disconnectors are closed and the earthing switches open.

Can the bridge be closed with disconnectors instead of a circuit breaker?

Only if there is no current to make: with one of the nodes dead and unloaded. A disconnector does not close a parallel between two sources or energize a transformer. If the H has a disconnector bridge, the interlocking must require one of the nodes to be isolated.

What blocks the automatic transfer through the bridge?

It is usually blocked if the node that lost voltage lost it because of its own fault, for example in the transformer or at the node, and if the bridge is not available. That way closing the bridge does not feed a fault from the healthy line.

WhatsApp