IEC 61660-2:1997 calculates what a short circuit does to the rigid busbars and equipment of a DC auxiliary system. With the peak and shape of the current given by IEC 61660-1, it obtains the force between conductors, the stress in the bars, the load on the supports and the heating, and compares them with what they can withstand.
Short answer
A short circuit on the DC board of a substation has two effects on the busbars: a force between conductors and heating. IEC 61660-2:1997 calculates both for rigid busbars, bare conductors and equipment of DC auxiliary installations in power plants and substations. It starts from the current calculated with IEC 61660-1 and compares the result with what the conductor, its supports and the equipment can withstand.
Where the current comes from
A DC short-circuit current does not look like an AC wave. It rises to a peak and then falls to an almost constant value. IEC 61660-1 describes it with a standard approximation function of six parameters (IEC 61660-2:1997, clause 2.1):
- ip, peak short-circuit current;
- Ik, quasi steady-state current, the value 1 s after the start;
- tp, time to peak;
- τ1 and τ2, rise and decay time constants;
- Tk, short-circuit duration.
The sources considered are those of Part 1: three-phase bridge rectifiers for 50 Hz, stationary lead-acid batteries, smoothing capacitors and separately excited DC motors (clause 1.1). How each contribution is calculated is explained in short circuit in DC auxiliary systems and in battery short circuit in DC.
The duration Tk depends on the protection concept of the system, that is, on the fuse or circuit-breaker that clears the fault.
The electromagnetic effect: force between busbars
The positive and negative bars of a board carry the same current in opposite directions, so they repel each other. If the bars are long compared with their spacing, the force is spread along the span. The maximum force between main conductors is calculated with the peak current (clause 2.2.1):
Fm = (μ0 / 2π) · ip² · l / am
Here l is the largest distance between supports and am is the effective distance between conductors. For conductors of circular cross-section, am is the centre-line distance. For rectangular bars, the centre-line distance is corrected with a shape factor given in Figure 1 of the standard (clause 2.2.3). When each pole is made of several flat bars, the force between them is also calculated.
The force does not act alone: the conductor and its supports respond as a system that can oscillate. The standard replaces the square of the real current with a substitute rectangular function, whose value and duration produce the same mechanical stress (clause 2.3.6.2). This avoids integrating the full waveform.
Stress in the bar and load on the supports
From the force, the bending stress in the bar is obtained. The standard calculates it with the section modulus of the conductor and two factors: a dynamic one, from Table 2, and one that depends on the type and number of supports, from Table 3 (clause 2.3.2). The bar withstands the force if the stress does not exceed the yield point of the material multiplied by a plasticity factor q. That factor depends on the shape of the cross-section (Table 4, clause 2.3.4).
With that criterion a small permanent deformation may remain, of the order of 1 % of the span. The standard accepts it as long as it does not reduce the minimum clearances between poles or to the earthed structure.
The force on the supports also uses a dynamic factor and a support-type factor (clause 2.3.5). The maximum dynamic factor is 1.0 for the conductor stress and can reach 2.0 for the force on the support (Table 2). That force must not exceed the withstand value declared by the manufacturer of the insulator or support. If it acts above the insulator head, a lower value is used (clause 2.4).
Three mounting rules come from the same clause 2.3.2:
- In continuous bars with unequal spans, calculate with the largest span everywhere.
- Avoid spans shorter than 20 % of the adjacent spans. If that is not possible, decouple them with flexible joints at the supports.
- If it is not clear whether the bar is simply supported or fixed, calculate the less favourable case.
For a finer calculation, the standard allows lower dynamic factors if the natural frequency of the conductor is calculated. That route only applies when the short-circuit duration is short compared with the oscillation period of the bar (clause 2.3.6).
The thermal effect: heating of conductors and equipment
During the short circuit the bar has almost no time to lose heat, and the standard treats the heating as adiabatic (clause 3.2.1). The governing quantity is the thermal equivalent short-time current, Ith. It is the constant current that, over Tk, heats the conductor as much as the real current. The idea is the same as the Joule integral in AC.
There are two checks (clauses 3.2.3 and 3.2.4):
- Equipment: Ith must not exceed the rated short-time withstand current of the equipment during its rated time. If the short circuit lasts longer than that time, the limit is reduced by the square root of the ratio of times.
- Bare conductors: the equivalent current density must not exceed the rated density of the material, corrected by the square root of the ratio of times. The standard gives that density in Figure 10, for 1 s.
The recommended maximum temperatures are 200 °C for solid copper or aluminium bars and 300 °C for steel (Table 6). The heat must not damage terminals or clamps either.
An example with our own data
A 125 V board has 40 × 5 mm copper bars, 100 mm between centre lines and supports every 500 mm. The study with IEC 61660-1 gives a peak of 14 kA at the bars. The battery fuse clears in 0.1 s.
- Force: the bars are small compared with their spacing, and the shape factor is close to 1. Then Fm ≈ 2 × 10⁻⁷ × 14,000² × 0.5 / 0.1 ≈ 196 N per span. With that value, the stress in the bar and the load on each insulator are calculated and compared with the copper limit and the support manufacturer’s data.
- Heat: taking Ith equal to the peak, which is conservative, the density is 14,000 / 200 = 70 A/mm² for 0.1 s. Referred to 1 s, it is equivalent to about 22 A/mm². That value is compared with the rated density of copper in Figure 10 of the standard.
If either check fails, the remedies are well known: bring the supports closer, separate the poles further, increase the cross-section or clear faster.
Typical mistakes
- Checking only the breaking capacity of the fuse and forgetting the bars and their insulators.
- Calculating the force with the quasi steady-state current Ik instead of the peak ip.
- Using this method for the battery cables: the standard does not cover them.
- Leaving a short span next to a long one without a flexible joint.
- Replacing the battery bank with a larger one without repeating the stress calculation. The fuse selection criterion is in main battery protection.
We do your study
Our team calculates the short circuit of your DC system with IEC 61660 and delivers the calculation report. We check the bars, insulators and equipment of the DC distribution board. We work from your drawings and the battery and charger data. See our engineering design and studies service and write to us for a quote.
Related guides
- Short circuit in DC auxiliary systems (IEC 61660)
- Battery short circuit in DC: estimate (IEEE 946)
- Short circuit of the charger and DC motors
- Main battery protection: DC fuse or circuit-breaker
- Joule integral and thermal equivalent current Ith
- DC distribution board
- Substation DC system
References
- IEC 61660-2, Short-circuit currents in d.c. auxiliary installations in power plants and substations – Part 2: Calculation of effects, edition 1.0 (1997), clauses 1.1, 2.1, 2.2.1, 2.2.3, 2.3.2, 2.3.4, 2.3.5, 2.3.6, 2.4, 3.2.1 to 3.2.4, Tables 2, 3, 4 and 6 and Figures 1 and 10.
- IEC 61660-1, Short-circuit currents in d.c. auxiliary installations in power plants and substations – Part 1: Calculation of short-circuit currents, edition 1.0 (1997).
Frequently asked questions
Can IEC 61660-2 be used to check DC cables?
No. Its method covers rigid conductors, bare conductors and equipment. For cables and insulated conductors, the standard itself refers to others, for example IEC 60949 and IEC 60986 (clause 1.1).
Which current do I use for the thermal effect if I do not have the full waveform?
The standard allows the peak current ip to be taken as an upper limit of the thermal equivalent short-time current Ith, with a conservative result (clause 3.2.2). If the circuit has a current-limiting device, Ith and the duration are given by its manufacturer.
What temperature may a copper busbar reach during the short circuit?
IEC 61660-2:1997 recommends at most 200 °C for solid bare conductors of copper, aluminium or aluminium alloy, and 300 °C for steel ones (Table 6). It also asks you to check that the heat does not exceed the permissible temperature of terminals and clamps.